Case: Blanciak v. Allegheny Ludlum

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

CASE REASSIGNED to Judge Donald J. Lee (admin) (Entered: 11/06/1992)

JOINT MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR., ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, UNITED STEEL WORKERS, COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO, R. C. THOMAS, CHARLES E. SWARTZ, JOHN DOE, JANE DOE(S) for Leave to File with Proposed Order. ( filed under Seal ) (aen) Modified on 11/23/1992 (Entered: 11/23/1992)

ORDER upon motion granting [101−1] joint motion for Leave to File that Defts motoin for Summary Judgment due on 12/14/92 opposing briefs due 1/14/93, Pltfs Pre Trial Narrative is due 12/14/92, defts due 1/4/93 and pre trial stipulation due 2/22/93 and pre trial conf is set for 3/4/93 at 9:15 am ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 11/24/92 ) CM all parties of record. ( SEALED PLEADING ) (aen) (Entered: 11/24/1992)

Deadline updated; set Pretrial Order Deadlines: Pretrial Statements for Plaintiffs by 12/14/92 ; Pretrial Statements for Defendants by 1/4/93 ; Motion Filing to 12/14/92 ; Pretrial Stipulations 2/22/93 ; Pretrial Conference for 9:15 3/4/93 ; (aen) (Entered: 11/24/1992)

JOINT MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR., ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, UNITED STEEL WORKERS, COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO, R. C. THOMAS, CHARLES E. SWARTZ, JOHN DOE, JANE DOE(S) to Extend Time with Proposed Order. ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 12/11/1992)

ORDER upon motion granting [102−1] joint motion to Extend Time defts file any motion for summary Judgment on or before 12/31/92, Pltfs Pre Trial Statement due 12/31/92 and defts due 1/21/93. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 12/14/92 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 12/14/1992)

Deadline updated; reset Pretrial Order Deadlines: Pretrial Statements for Plaintiffs by 12/31/92 ; Pretrial Statements for Defendants by 1/21/93 ; Motion Filing to 12/31/92 ; (aen) (Entered: 12/14/1992)

PRETRIAL STATEMENT by (Plaintiffs) ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. (Filed under seal) (rvb) (Entered: 12/30/1992)

JOINT MOTION to Extend Time for Company &Union Defts' Motions for Summary Judgment. (Filed under seal). (rvb) (Entered: 12/30/1992)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO for Summary Judgment with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 01/04/1993)

BRIEF by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO in support of [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 01/04/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [104−1] joint motion to Extend Time that the Company and Union Defts file any Motions for Summary Judgment on 1/21/93 and Company and Defts file their pre trial Narrative Statements on Feb 11, l993. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 1/5/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 01/05/1993)

Deadline updated; reset Pretrial Order Deadlines: Pretrial Statements for Defendants by 2/11/93 ; Motion Filing to 1/21/93 ;for the Defts. (aen) (Entered: 01/05/1993)

CONSENT MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Extend Time to file Pre Trial Narrative Statement on or before 2/28/93 with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 01/21/1993)

ORDER, set Pretrial Conference for 9:15 3/31/93 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 1/25/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 01/25/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA to Strike [103−1] pre−trial statement by plaintiff with Proposed Order.( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 01/25/1993)

SUPPLEMENT TO MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA for Summary Judgment with Proposed Order.( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 01/26/1993)

RESPONSE by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. to [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 02/04/1993)

BRIEF by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. in support of Pltfs Response to Commonwealth Defts Motion for Summary Judgment. (aen) (Entered: 02/04/1993)

Stipulation by ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, UNITED STEEL WORKERS Dismissing the Claims against Allegheny Ludlum Corp. and the United Steelworkers of America With Prejudice. with proposed order. (aen) (Entered: 02/05/1993)

RESPONSE by COMMONWEALTH OF PA to Stipulation of Dismissal and Request for Status conf and or Fairness Hearing (aen) Modified on 02/19/1993 (Entered: 02/05/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Extend Time to file a Reply to Pltfs Response to Commonwealth Defts Motion for Summary Judgment with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 02/22/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [114−1] stipulation Dismissing the Claims against Allegheny Ludlum Corp. and the United Steelworkers of America With Prejudice. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 2/17/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 02/23/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [115−1] motion response, set Status Conference for 10:00 3/5/93 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 2/17/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 02/23/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Extend Time to file Pre Trial Narrative Statement with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 03/01/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [117−1] motion to Extend Time to file Pre Trial Narrative Statement, of the Commonwealth Defts reset Commonwealth Defendants Pretrial Statements deadline for 3/22/93 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 3/1/93

Status Conference held on 3/5/93 before Judge Lee and the Pre Trial conf set for 3/31/93 will be Continued. [ Reporter: None ] (aen) (Entered: 03/05/1993)

MOTION by ALLEGHENY LUDLUM to Retain under Seal Selected Documents filed under Seal With the Court. with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 03/09/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [119−1] motion to Retain under Seal Selected Documents filed under Seal With the Court. ( DOCUMENTS NUMBERS 97,104,98, and 90 ) ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 3/12/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 03/12/1993)

PRETRIAL STATEMENT by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO (aen) (Entered: 03/23/1993)

SUPPLEMENT I PRETRIAL STATEMENT by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO, Report of Dr. John Hunter. (aen) (Entered: 03/23/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK to Extend Time with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 04/01/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [122−1] motion to Extend Time Commonwealths Brief shall be Filed on or before 4/12/93, and Pltfs brief shal be filed on or before May 3 l993. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 4/1/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 04/01/1993)

BRIEF by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. in opposition to [110−1] motion for Summary Judgment by COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 04/05/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Seal memorandum of law with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 04/13/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [124−1] motion to Seal memorandum of law if no Objections from the parties are filed on or before April 26, l993 shall no longer be filed under seal. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 4/14/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 04/14/1993)

MEMORANDUM OF LAW Filed by the Commonwealth Defts. (aen) Modified on 04/27/1993 (Entered: 04/14/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO for Leave to File Reply to Pltfs Briefs in oppositoin to Summary judgment. with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 04/19/1993)

ORDER dated 4/27/93 that the Memorandum ( Doc # 125 ) be Unsealed and made a Part of the courts File. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 4/27/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 04/27/1993)

BRIEF ( Memorandum of Law ) of Pltfs Regarding the Effect of Pltfs Settlement of this matter with Allegheny Ludlum and Union on Pltfs Remaining Civil Rights Action against the Commonwealth. (aen) Modified on 05/03/1993 (Entered: 05/03/1993)

CONSENT MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Extend Time to file Reply Brif with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 06/01/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [129−1] motion to Extend Time to file Reply Brie by Commonwealth Defts., reset reply Brief deadline to 6/14/93 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 6/1/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 06/01/1993)

SUPPLEMENT AND REPLY by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to response by pltfs' to [110−1] motion for Summary Judgment by COMMONWEALTH OF PA (femp) (Entered: 06/15/1993)

REPLY BRIEF by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to [123−1] brief in opposition by plaintiff (femp) (Entered: 06/15/1993)

CONSENT MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. for Leave to File Reply to Commonwealth defts' supplement and reply to pltfs' opposition to their motion for summary judgment with Proposed Order. (femp) (Entered: 06/18/1993)

ORDER upon motion granting [132−1] motion for Leave to File Reply to Commonwealth defts' supplement and reply to pltfs' opposition to their motion for summary judgment, on or before 7/17/93 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 06/21/1993)

LETTER DATED July 13. 1993 from Gloria A. Tischuk, Esq to the Court that this Letter ( Corrispondence ) be filed as part of the Commonwealth' Defts REPLY BRIEF. (aen) (Entered: 07/14/1993)

RESPONSE by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. to [130−1] response reply by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 07/16/1993)

LETTER DATED July 27, l993 from James B. Lieber to the court that this Letter be filedas Part of Pltfs Brief in Oppositoin to defts Motion for summary Judgment which was filed July 16, l993. (aen) (Entered: 08/11/1993)

ORDER, referring [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment to Mag. Judge Robert C. Mitchell and for Report and recommendation ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 9/15/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 09/16/1993)

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION of Mag. Judge Robert C. Mitchell signed on 9/29/93 Recommending that [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment be Granted as to all claims except the ADEA claim submitted on behalf of pltfs Bowman, Calhoun, Clark, Cook, Delcimmuto, Farah, Fleeger, Fulton, George, Holmes, Miller, Morda, Patty, Poskus, Pocetti, Primack, Rodnicki, Rowe, Shellhammer, Sibek, Stewart, Suman, Talmadge and Walker; The parties have 10 days from the date of service to file objections to this Report and Recommendation. (tt) (Entered: 09/29/1993)

MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. for Transfer to Magistrate and Enlargement of time to file Written Objections with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 10/04/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO for Reconsideration of the report and Recommedation of the Magistrate/Judge dated Sept 29,1993. with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 10/06/1993)

PRETRIAL STATEMENT by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO (aen) (Entered: 10/12/1993)

RESPONSE by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. to [139−1] motion for Reconsideration of the report and Recommedation of the Magistrate/Judge dated Sept 29,1993. by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, MAURICE NATES, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 10/12/1993)

SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION of Mag. Judge Robert C. Mitchell signed on 10/12/93 Recommending that [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment be Granted; The parties have 7 days from the date of service to file objections to this Report and Recommendation. (aen) Modified on 10/13/1993 (Entered: 10/13/1993)

OBJECTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. to [142−1] report and recommendations (aen) (Entered: 10/29/1993)

CORRECTED OBJECTIONS by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to the Objections to the Supplemental [142−1] report and recommendations (aen) (Entered: 11/03/1993)

RESPONSE by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. to [145−1] objection by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, MAURICE NATES, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 11/05/1993)

MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. for Hearing on Cross−Objections to the Magistrates Supplemental Report and Recommendation W/Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 11/08/1993)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to Extend Time to reply to Pltfs Objections to the Supplemental Report and Recommendation by 11/19/93 with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 11/10/1993)

ORDER upon motion denying [148−1] motion to Extend Time to reply to Pltfs Objections to the Supplemental Report and Recommendation by 11/19/93 ( signed by Mag. Judge Robert C. Mitchell on 11/15/93 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 11/15/1993)

REPLY BRIEF by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR.to [123−1] brief in opposition by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LEROY A. CALDERONE, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, MARLIN D. BYERS, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK [131−1] reply brief by STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA (aen) (Entered: 01/12/1994)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO for Leave to File Brief Under Seal with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 01/28/1994)

ORDER upon motion granting [151−1] motion for Leave to File Brief Under Seal ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 1/31/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 02/01/1994)

REPLY BRIEF by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 02/01/1994)

AMENDED PRETRIAL STATEMENT by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) Modified on 02/09/1994 (Entered: 02/09/1994)

TRANSCRIPT for dates of 2/10/94 before Judge Lee. Court Reporter: John Wayne Struble. (rvb) (Entered: 02/24/1994)

ORDER, set Pretrial Conference for 1:30 5/20/94 ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 4/21/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 04/21/1994)

MOTION by COMMONWEALTH OF PA, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO to continue Pre Trial Conf , and to Stay Pre Trial Proceedings. with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 05/03/1994)

ORDER granting in part, denying in part [157−1] motion to continue Pre Trial Conf, granting in part, denying in part [157−2] motion to Stay Pre Trial Proceedings., reset Pretrial Conference for 10:00 6/24/94 and the order of April 21 1994 is Vacated. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 5/5/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 05/05/1994)

MEMORANDUM OPINION granting in part, denying in part [105−1] motion for Summary Judgment denying [109−1] motion to Strike [103−1] pre−trial statement by plaintiff ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 6/3/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 06/07/1994)

MOTION by ALLEGHENY LUDLUM to Intervene and Uncontested Motion to Extend Time for Pltfs to file Objections to Proposed Order of Court Dismissing Injunctive and Declaratory relief. with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 06/17/1994)

ORDER granting [160−1] motion to Extend Time for Pltfs to file Objections to Proposed Order of Court Dismissing Injunctive and Declaratory relief. and Pltfs are Excused from filing said Objections pending further order of court. and each interested party file a position regarding continued confidentiality of Sealed Settlement Agreement on or before July 1 l994 with a memorandum in support of that position. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 6/17/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 06/17/1994)

ORDER dated 6/20/94 that the Pre Trial conf set for 6/24/94 is Postponed until further notice. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 6/20/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 06/20/1994)

MOTION with Brief in Support by ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, UNITED STEEL WORKERS In Opposition To Disclosure Of Their Settlement Agreement with proposed order. (rvb) (Entered: 06/30/1994)

NOTICE OF APPEAL by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. from [159−1] order dated 6/3/94 FILING FEE $ 105.00 RECEIPT # 139507 TPO issued. (aen) (Entered: 07/05/1994)

Certified copy of Notice of Appeal [164−1] appeal by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK , certified copy of docket, certified copy of order dated 6/3/94 mailed to USCA; copy of Notice of Appeal and information sheet to ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR., ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, UNITED STEEL WORKERS, COMMONWEALTH OF PA, Harris Wofford, MAURICE NATES, JOHN KRISIAK, STELLA RAVETTO, R. C. THOMAS, CHARLES E. SWARTZ, JOHN DOE, JANE DOE(S) , court reporter Wayne struble, and judge. Copy of information sheet to appellant. (aen) (Entered: 07/05/1994)

Transcript Purchase order re: [164−1] appeal by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK and Indicating that there is NO Transcript. (aen) (Entered: 07/06/1994)

Record complete for Appeal purposes, certified copy of docket entries forwarded to USCA. (aen) (Entered: 07/06/1994)

NOTICE of Docketing ROA from USCA Re: [164−1] appeal by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK USCA Number: ( 94−3363 ) (aen) (Entered: 07/13/1994)

MOTION by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. for Hearing with Proposed Order. (aen) (Entered: 10/31/1994)

ORDER denying [167−1] motion for Hearing and the Claims for Injunctive and Declaratory relief against the individual Commonwelath Defts in their official capacity will be dismissed, and this court's order entered on June 7, 1994 will become final on 11/18/94 unless Pltfs Files Objections on or before 11/18/94. and the Joint motion in Opposition to disclosure is Granted. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 11/1/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) Modified on 11/01/1994 (Entered: 11/01/1994)

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT and Joint Tortfeasor Release ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 11/18/1994)

RESPONSE by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. in opposition to Proposed Order of Court Disimssing Injunctive and Declaratory relief. (aen) (Entered: 11/18/1994)

BRIEF by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, MARLIN D. BYERS, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, LEROY A. CALDERONE, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. in support of Pltfs Objections to Proposed order of Court Dismissing Injunctive and Declaratory Relief. ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (sealed) Modified on 11/23/1994 (Entered: 11/23/1994)

MOTION by ALLEGHENY LUDLUM and memorandum of Law in opposition to Disclosure of Information regarding Settlement Agreement. with Proposed Order. (sealed) (Entered: 11/23/1994)

ORDER upon motion granting [172−1] motion and memorandum of Law in opposition to Disclosure of Information regarding Settlement Agreement.and this court's Order of 11/1/94 is Amended and more fully explained on this order. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 12/1/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 12/01/1994)

RESPONSE by JANE DOE(S), JOHN DOE, CHARLES E. SWARTZ, R. C. THOMAS, STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, MAURICE NATES, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA, UNITED STEEL WORKERS, ALLEGHENY LUDLUM in opposition to Pltfs Objections to Proopsed Order of Court Dismissing Injunctive Declaratory Relief. ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 12/12/1994)

REPLY BRIEF by The Commonwelath Defts. ( FILED UNDER SEAL ) (aen) (Entered: 12/12/1994)

MOTION by pltfs to Strike defts' [173−1] reply in opposition to pltfs' objections to proposed order of court dismissing injunctive declaratory relief filed under seal . (tt) (Entered: 12/22/1994)

ORDER dated 12/30/94 that Pltfs Objections are Denied and this Court's Order entered June 7, 1994 is <Made a Final Order of Court, Summary Judgment in Defts Favor is Granted and all remaining Claims against the Remaining commonwealth of Pa. Defts are Dismissed With Prejudice. ( signed by Judge Donald J. Lee on 12/30/94 ) CM all parties of record. (aen) (Entered: 01/03/1995)

Case closed, notices Mailed. (aen) (Entered: 01/03/1995)

NOTICE OF APPEAL by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK from [176−1] order dated 12/30/94 FILING FEE $ 105.00 RECEIPT # 145434 TPO issued. (aen) (Entered: 01/26/1995)

Certified copy of Notice of Appeal [177−1] appeal by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. CULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. , certified copy of docket, certified copy of order dated 12/30/94 mailed to USCA; copy of Notice of Appeal and information sheet to JANE DOE(S), JOHN DOE, CHARLES E. SWARTZ, R. C. THOMAS, STELLA RAVETTO, JOHN KRISIAK, MAURICE NATES, Harris Wofford, COMMONWEALTH OF PA, UNITED STEEL WORKERS, ALLEGHENY LUDLUM, JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. CULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LEROY A. CALDERONE, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, MARLIN D. BYERS, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK , court reporter John Wayne Struble, and judge. Copy of information sheet to appellant. (aen) (Entered: 01/26/1995)

NOTICE of Docketing ROA from USCA Re: [177−1] appeal by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. GULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. USCA Number: ( 95−3055 ) (aen) (Entered: 02/03/1995)

Transcript Purchase order re: [177−1] appeal by ROBERT J. BLANCIAK, RAYMOND BOWMAN, WILLIAM BURKETT, RICHARD COOK, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, JACK DELCIMMUTO, RICHARD T. FARAH, DONALD E. HOLMES, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD C. MILLER, HOWARD MUMAU, DOMINIC POCETTI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, ANTHONY RODNICKI, WILLIAM D. ROWE, DON SHELLHAMMER, PAUL R. SIBIK, JAMES WALKER, THEODORE W. WALKER, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, JOSEPH W. CLARK, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, RONALD R. FULTON, RICHARD L. GEORGE, JOHN M. GULYAS, JACK C. HESKETH, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, ROBERT D. KNABB, BERNARD C. KUMPF, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, JAMES E. PATTY, LAURA G. POSKUS, ARTHUR L. RAMER, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ROBERT L. STEWART, WESLEY E. SUMAN, DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, JACK WILMOT JR. by JACK WILMOT JR., DOUGLAS E. TALMADGE, WESLEY E. SUMAN, ROBERT L. STEWART, F. EUGENE SMELTZER, ARTHUR L. RAMER, LAURA G. POSKUS, JAMES E. PATTY, WILLIAM JOHN MORDA, BERNARD C. KUMPF, ROBERT D. KNABB, ROBERT HUTCHERSON, JACK C. HESKETH, JOHN M. GULYAS, RICHARD L. GEORGE, RONALD R. FULTON, GEORGE L. FLEEGER, JOSEPH W. CLARK, LOUIS ECARAVAGGIO, RONALD E. CALHOUN, LEROY A. CALDERONE, FRANCIS N. AMARANTO, THEODORE W. WALKER, JAMES WALKER, PAUL R. SIBIK, DON SHELLHAMMER, WILLIAM D. ROWE, ANTHONY RODNICKI, EDWARD E. PRIMACK, DOMINIC POCETTI, HOWARD MUMAU, DONALD C. MILLER, JAMES MARKBY, DONALD E. HOLMES, RICHARD T. FARAH, JACK DELCIMMUTO, ROBERT E. DELLEDONNE, RICHARD COOK, WILLIAM BURKETT, RAYMOND BOWMAN, ROBERT J. BLANCIAK and Indicating that a Transcript is Already on file in the District Court Clerk's Office. (aen) (Entered: 02/03/1995)

Record complete for Appeal purposes, certified copy of docket entries forwarded to USCA. (aen) (Entered: 02/03/1995)

RECEIPT from USCA. of the certified List in Lieu of the Record. (aen) (Entered: 02/09/1995)

SLIP OPINION from USCA. that the Court Will Affirm the Judgment of the District Court. (aen) (Entered: 02/20/1996)