Case: Medley v. Ginsberg

2:78-cv-02099 | U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia

Filed Date: April 21, 1978

Closed Date: 2001

Clearinghouse coding complete

Case Summary

On April 21, 1978, the Executive Director of the, Kanawha Putnam Association for Retarded Children and an individual plaintiff, represented by Mountain State Justice, Inc., filed this lawsuit pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia (Charleston) to redress alleged deprivation of the constitutional rights of all children and young adults with intellectual disabilities institutionalized by the State of West Virginia.Plaintiffs alleged depr…

On April 21, 1978, the Executive Director of the, Kanawha Putnam Association for Retarded Children and an individual plaintiff, represented by Mountain State Justice, Inc., filed this lawsuit pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia (Charleston) to redress alleged deprivation of the constitutional rights of all children and young adults with intellectual disabilities institutionalized by the State of West Virginia.

Plaintiffs alleged deprivation of their constitutional rights and statutory rights under the Developmentally Disabled Assistance and Bill of Rights Act, the Education for All Handicapped Children Act, the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Community Mental Health Center Act.

Plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief to enjoin defendants keeping plaintiffs institutionalized and compel them to provide plaintiffs with appropriate education, treatment and care, and services in a foster home or other community-based facility in their home communities. Plaintiffs also sought monetary damages in the amount of $20,000 for each plaintiff.

The District Court (Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) certified the class as consisting of all citizens of the State of West Virginia under the age of twenty-three (23) years who suffer from intellectual disabilities and who were or would be institutionalized by reason of the failures of the defendants to place them in foster homes or other community-based facilities.

Defendants moved for summary judgment, arguing that the Court did not have subject matter jurisdiction, that plaintiffs failed to exhaust their administrative remedies and that the Court should abstain from hearing the matter. On June 10, 1980, the District Court (Judge Copenhaver) denied defendants' motion. Medley v. Ginsberg, 492 F.Supp. 1294 (S.D.W.Va., 1980).

Following denial of defendants' motion, the parties continued pre-trial discovery. The docket reflects that at Court status conferences of September 23 and October 23, 1980, settlement was discussed and the Court directed the parties to submit proposed settlement plans/offers. Defendants filed an Offer of Judgment on November 21, 1980, which was accepted on December 16, 1980. Class notification was issued and the District Court (Judge Copenhaver) approved the settlement and entered a Consent Decree on October 8, 1981. In accordance with the Decree, the State filed "A Comprehensive Plan for Community Based Services for Developmentally Disabled Persons in West Virginia" on November 2, 1980. As a copy of the Consent Decree was not available, its exact terms were unknown at the time of this summary.

The District Court pre-PACER docket chronicles the procedural history of the implementation phase from 1981 to 1993. During that period, the plaintiffs filed numerous motions to for contempt and/or to compel compliance with the Consent Decree. The District Court, in turn, issued various orders and memorandums directing compliance and approving reform plans. Several state agencies were involved in the implementation process, including the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources and the West Virginia Department of Education. The "Medley Management Team" was created to coordinate the implementation efforts and it reported its progress to the Court on a periodic basis. Gail Falk was designated as the Court Monitor.

Our copy of the automated PACER docket for the case contains consistent entries for the period of 1989 until 2001. (There were, however, no hyper-links to filed documents). Those entries reflect that the implementation phase continued through 2001.

On January 12, 2001 the District Court (Judge Copenhaver) held that the State Superintendent of Schools was in substantial compliance with the Consent Decree entered October 8, 1981 and granted in part and denied in part the W.V. Department of Education's motion to dissolve the Consent Decree. The State Superintendent of Schools and the W.V. Dept. of Education were dismissed as a parties to the action.

On January 16, 2001 the District Court allowed plaintiffs to add the W.V. Division of Rehabilitation Services as a party to the case. The Court denied without prejudice the W.V. Department of Health and Human Resources' motion to dissolve the Consent Decree, indicting that the motion could be renewed. The Court set a follow-up conference for the purpose of identifying the remaining compliance issues and plans for resolving them. That conference occurred on January 25, 2001. Pursuant to the conference, W.V. Division of Rehabilitation Services filed a report with the Court on March 20, 2001 and W.V. Dept. of Health and Human Resources filed its report on March 21, 2001. No further activity was noted on the PACER docket.

Summary Authors

Dan Dalton (3/22/2007)

People

For PACER's information on parties and their attorneys, see: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/19825186/parties/medley-v-lewis/


Judge(s)

Copenhaver, John Thomas Jr. (West Virginia)

Attorney for Plaintiff
Attorney for Defendant

Braun, Michael A. (West Virginia)

Brissell, David R. (West Virginia)

Browning, Chauncey H. (West Virginia)

Cleek, David P (West Virginia)

Expert/Monitor/Master/Other

Documents in the Clearinghouse

Documents in this case

2:78-cv-02099

Docket Sheet

Aug. 8, 1995

Aug. 8, 1995

Docket

2:78-cv-02099

Docket (PACER)

March 21, 2005

March 21, 2005

Docket
192

2:78-cv-02099

Memorandum Order

June 10, 1980

June 10, 1980

Order/Opinion

492 F.Supp. 1294

2:78-cv-02099

Correspondence

Jan. 27, 1997

Jan. 27, 1997

Correspondence

Docket

See docket on RECAP: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/19825186/medley-v-lewis/

Last updated Oct. 29, 2026, 11:06 a.m.

Docket for: Medley v. Lewis
ECF Number Date Description Link
1 April 21, 1978

PAPER DOCKET SHEET. (ras) (Entered: 09/11/2015)

RECAP
Oct. 18, 1981

This case was closed before being entered completely into the automated system. For previous entries, check the manual docket sheet (skh)

Oct. 19, 1981

Case closed (skh)

359 Aug. 8, 1984

MOTION by Deft. Truby to Quash Subpoena, with affidavit and certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
478 Aug. 12, 1987

MOTION by Deft. W.Va. Dept. of Health to Quash Subpoena directed to Asst. Atty General Barbara L. Freedy, with notice and certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
508 Dec. 8, 1987

MOTION by Deft. Lipscomb for Protective Order, with certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
509 Dec. 8, 1987

MEMORANDUM by Deft. Lipscomb in support of [508-1] motion for Protective Order (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
535 Jan. 3, 1989

MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree, with notice and certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
536 Jan. 13, 1989

RESPONSE by All Defendants to [535-1] motion for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
539 Jan. 19, 1989

RESPONSE by Deft. (WV Dept. of Human Services) to [535-1] motion for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree Regarding Medicare Catastrophic Coverage Act of 1988, by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
542 Jan. 19, 1989

MOTION by Defendants (State Defts) for Production of Documents, with notice and certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
545 Feb. 2, 1989

AMENDED MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree, with notice and certificate of service attached (skh) Modified on 11/10/1992 (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
546 Feb. 3, 1989

MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an Order of Contempt or for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree, with certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
547 Feb. 9, 1989

MOTION by Deft (WVDH) for Continuance, with notice and certificate of service attached (integrated with previous entry) (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
548 Feb. 16, 1989

RESPONSE by Leon Ginsberg (Commissioner, WV Dept. of Human Services) to [535-1] motion for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree alleging late payments to providers by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
549 Feb. 21, 1989

RESPONSE by Deft (WV Dept. of Health) to [546-1] motion for an Order of Contempt or for an Order of Compliance with the Consent Decree by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
558 April 13, 1989

NOTICE and MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an Order of Compliance with Consent Decree (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
559 April 14, 1989

NOTICE and AMENDED MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an Order of Implementation of the Consent Decree or in the Alternative for Appointment of a Monitor--hearing noticed for 2:00 4/21/89 (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
560 April 20, 1989

ANSWER by Deft (WV Dept. of Health) to Pltfs' [559-1] amended motion for an order of implementation of the consent decree or in the alternative for the appointment of a monitor, with certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
561 April 21, 1989

RESPONSE ny Deft (WV Dept. of Health) to [559-1] motion for an Order of Implementation of the Consent Decree or in the Alternative for Appointment of a Monitor by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
562 April 21, 1989

RESPONSE by Deft (Pisapia) to [559-1] amended motion for an Order of Implementation of the Consent Decree or in the Alternative for Appointment of a Monitor 4/21/89 by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
568 May 29, 1990

MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for an order of compliance and implementation with notice and certificate of service attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
569 June 28, 1990

RESPONSE by Deft(WV Dept. of Health & Human Services) to [568-1] motion for an order of compliance and implementation by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
571 Jan. 4, 1991

MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees (skh) Modified on 11/10/1992 (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
572 Jan. 4, 1991

AFFIDAVIT by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart Re: [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
Jan. 4, 1991

Motion(s) referred: [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees referred to Magistrate Judge Jerry D. Hogg (skh)

573 Jan. 7, 1991

AFFIDAVIT by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart Re: [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
574 Jan. 24, 1991

RESPONSE by All Defendants to [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
575 Feb. 6, 1991

ANSWER by Deft Marockie to [571-1] motion for award of partial interim attorney fees (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
578 Jan. 15, 1992

SUPPLEMENTARY MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees, with notice attached (skh) (Entered: 11/10/1992)

RECAP
579 Jan. 15, 1992

AFFIDAVIT by Daniel F. Hedges in Support of Re: [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
Jan. 15, 1992

Motion(s) referred: [578-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees referred to Magistrate Judge Jerry D. Hogg (skh)

580 Jan. 22, 1992

RESPONSE by All Defendants to [578-1] supplementary motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (skh) Modified on 11/12/1992 (Entered: 11/12/1992)

RECAP
581 Jan. 11, 1993

AGREED ORDER mooting [578-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees, mooting [571-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees; The Dept. of Health and Human Resources shall pay to the Pltfs the sum of $13,775.00 and the Dept. of Education shall pay the Pltfs the sum of $6,475.00. Said sums shall be paid on or before 03-15-93; these payments shall constitute complete & full payment of attorney fees for the calendar years of 1989, 1990, 1991 & 1992. ( signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys)(rac) Modified on 01/11/1993

RECAP
582 Dec. 2, 1993

NOTICE AND MOTION by Macel Medley & Nancy Barchart for an Order of Compliance (rac) (Entered: 12/07/1993)

RECAP
583 Dec. 20, 1993

RESPONSE by WV Dept of Education to [568-1] motion for an order of compliance. (rac) (Entered: 12/21/1993)

RECAP
584 Dec. 20, 1993

NOTICE of Substitution of Counsel for WV Dept of Education by Paul E. Jordan. (rac) (Entered: 12/21/1993)

RECAP
585 Dec. 20, 1993

RESPONSE by Ruth Ann Panepinto to [568-1] motion for an order of compliance (rac) Modified on 12/29/1993 (Entered: 12/21/1993)

RECAP
586 Jan. 7, 1994

NOTICE & SUPPLEMENTARY MOTION by Macel Medley & Nancy Barchart for Partial Interim Award of Attorney Fees referring to: [578-1] motion for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees. (rac) (Entered: 01/10/1994)

RECAP
587 Jan. 7, 1994

AFFIDAVIT by Daniel Hedges o/b/o Macel Medley & Nancy Barchart in support of [586-1] supplementary motion for Partial Interim Award of Attorney Fees. (rac) Modified on 01/12/1994 (Entered: 01/10/1994)

RECAP
588 March 17, 1994

AGREED ORDER: mooting [586-1] supplemental amended motion for Partial Interim Award of Attorney Fees; the Dept of Health & Human Resources shall pay to Appalachian Research & Defense Fund, the sum of $1,872.00 & that the Dept of Ed. shall pay to Appalachian Research & Defense Fund the sum of $624.00 etc. ( signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys) (rac)

RECAP
589 April 4, 1994

RETURN: Agreed Order entered 03/17/94 and forwarded to Gail Falk at 5l9 Court Street, Charleston, WV 2530l returned by the U. S. Postal Service marked "Returned to Sender, No Such Number." (ras) (Entered: 04/05/1994)

RECAP
April 5, 1994

FORWARDED Agreed Order entered 03/17/94 to Gail Falk at Route 1, Box 1244, Montpelier, VT 05602 per conversation with receptionist at Appalachian Research & Defense Fund, Inc. (ras)

590 April 21, 1994

ORDER: The parties have reached an agreement on [582-1] motion for an Order of Compliance; the specific terms of the agreement are fully described within the order. ( signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys) (rac)

RECAP
591 Sept. 23, 1994

NOTICE & MOTION by WV Dept of Health & Human Resources to Modify Reimbursement Methodology (rac) (Entered: 10/21/1994)

RECAP
592 Dec. 30, 1994

AGREED ORDER that the defts shall pay to the pltfs. the sum of $1,637.50 for 13.1 hours at $125.00, which shall constitute complete and full payment of attorney fees for the calendar year 1994. ( signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys) (tih)

RECAP
593 Jan. 3, 1995

NOTICE & MOTION by Pltfs for Enforcement of Decree (rac)

RECAP
594 Jan. 4, 1995

MEMORANDUM by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart in support of [593-1] motion for Enforcement of Decree by Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley (rac)

RECAP
595 Jan. 20, 1995

RESPONSE by All Defendants to pltfs Medley and Barchart's [593-1] motion for Enforcement of Decree. (skh)

RECAP
596 Aug. 8, 1995

ORDER granting [591-1] motion to Modify Reimbursement Methodology; the management incentive is deleted and removed from the reimbursement methodology; the cost upper limits will be based on an assumed occupancy of ninety-five percent and a calendar year of 354 days; the weighing of the reported allowable costs is hereby reduced to ninety-five percent occupancy on a calendar year of 354 days; the matters set forth in paragraphs, 1, 2 & 3 of this Order may be incorporated by the Dept. of Health and Human Resources into the State's Medical Plan w/out additional publication of Notice. ( signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys) (tih) Modified on 08/10/1995

RECAP
597 Dec. 8, 1995

STIPULATION by Plaintiff Macel Medley, Plaintiff Nancy Barchart and interested party WV Dept of Health and Human Resources in regard to the Plaintiffs' Motion for Enforcement of Decree. (emb) Modified on 12/15/1995

RECAP
598 Jan. 2, 1996

NOTICE & SUPPLEMENTARY MOTION by Macel Medley and Nancy Barchart for Award of Partial Interim Attorney Fees (emb)

RECAP
599 Feb. 28, 1996

AGREED ORDER: It is ordered that the Defendants shall pay to Daniel F. Hedges the sum of $3,487.50 for 27.9 hours at $125/hour, which shall constitute complete and full payment of attorney fees for the calendar year 1995. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr.) (cc: attys) (emb) Modified on 03/02/1996 (Entered: 02/29/1996)

RECAP
600 March 1, 1996

AGREED ORDER: that the Department shall begin to provide those services identified in Exhibit "B" to the extent that they can be funded out of the Department's budget for State fiscal year 1995-96 and that all services identified in Exhibit "B" be provided in State fiscal year 1996-97; and inasmuch as the categorization of these amounts are estimates, said total amount shall be set aside and the Medley Management Team shall allocate said amounts for the unmet needs of class members as the need indicates; and further, the planning therefor, as well as planning for the provision for futher unmet needs, shall begin immediately. Over objection of Defendants, the Plaintiffs reserve for determination by the appropriate court the issue of the constitutionality of W. Va. Code 5-3a. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ) (cc: attys) (emb) (Entered: 03/04/1996)

RECAP
601 March 1, 1996

ORDER: that either of the parties may seek reconsideration of the Agreed Order on or before 05/15/96, in order to allow the Defendant, Department of Health and Human Resources, to otherwise comply with and obtain the benefit of the procedure set forth in W. Va. Code 5-3-2a. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr.) (cc: attys) (emb) (Entered: 03/04/1996)

RECAP
602 July 1, 1997

NOTICE by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart TO TAKE DEPOSITION of John and Joyce Bostic on 7/18/97 at 1:30; Eric M. Francis on 7/18/97 at 2:00; and John L. Persinger on 7/18/97 at 3:30. (skh)

RECAP
603 July 3, 1997

AMENDED NOTICE by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart TO TAKE DEPOSITION of John and Joyce Bostic on 7/11/97 at 3:30; Eric M. Francis on 7/18/97 at 2:00; and John L. Persinger on 7/18/97 at 3:30. (skh)

RECAP
604 July 11, 1997

MOTION by Eric M. Francis to Quash subpoena . (Referred to Magistrate Judge Jerry D. Hogg) (skh)

RECAP
605 July 16, 1997

NOTICE by All Defendants of substitution of counsel of Charlene A. Vaughan. (skh)

RECAP
606 July 16, 1997

RESPONSE by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart to Eric M. Francis' [604-1] motion to Quash subpoena. (skh) (Entered: 07/17/1997)

RECAP
607 July 18, 1997

ORDER denying Eric M. Francis' [604-1] motion to Quash subpoena and directing him to appear at the deposition and fully answer all questions propounded; the Court supports pltfs' counsel's interest in sharing information obtained with the counsel and parties in the Greenbrier County proceeding in order to further the pursuit of Michael Persinger's entitlements under this Court's orders. (signed by Magistrate Judge Jerry D. Hogg) (cc: attys) (skh)

RECAP
July 18, 1997

COURT PROCEEDING: hearing on Eric Francis' motion to quash; MAGISTRATE JUDGE Hogg; COURT REPORTER electronic recording #529 (2607-3876). (skh)

608 Sept. 16, 1998

MOTION by WV Dept of Health to dissolve consent decree . (pdb)

RECAP
609 Sept. 16, 1998

MEMORANDUM OF LAW by WV Dept of Health in support of [608-1] motion to vacate consent decree. (pdb)

RECAP
610 Oct. 9, 1998

RESPONSE by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart to [608-1] motion to vacate decree by WV Dept of Health. (pdb)

RECAP
611 Feb. 15, 2000

ORDER by agreement of the parties, directing that the community behavioral health centers shall make available, upon written request, behavioral health and other health and service records and information concerning Medley class members to Medley counsel and Medley Advocates, without charge to the requesting entity; to the extent such information is confidential, it shall be so maintained. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (pdb) Modified on 02/17/2000

RECAP
612 Feb. 23, 2000

RETURN: Copy of [611-1] order mailed to Eric M. Francis, P. O. Box 1458, Lewisburg, WV 24901-1458 returned by U.S. Postal Service marked "Forward Time Exp; Rtn to Send; Eric M. Francis, 208 W. Randolph St., Lewisburg, WV 24901-1024." Copy of order remailed to new address. (pdb) Modified on 02/29/2000

RECAP
613 March 2, 2000

ORDER scheduling Hearing for 2:00 3/17/2000 for defts' [608-1] motion to dissolve consent decree . (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (pdb)

RECAP
614 March 15, 2000

RETURN: Copy of [613-1] order entered 3/2/2000 mailed to Geraldine M. Guerin, Bastien & Gerwig, P.O. Box 2151, Charleston, WV 25328-2151 returned by U.S. Postal Service with handwritten note "Return to sender; no longer w/this firm -- or at this address," and marked "Returned to Sender; Not Deliverable As Addressed, Unable To Forward." (pdb) Modified on 03/16/2000

RECAP
615 March 16, 2000

NOTICE of Attorney Appearance for WV Dept of Education by Katherine A. Schultz, Kelli D. Talbott. (pdb)

RECAP
616 March 21, 2000

AMENDED NOTICE OF APPEARANCE for WV Dept of Education by Katherine A. Schultz and Kelli D. Talbott. (skh)

RECAP
617 March 21, 2000

ORDER granting the oral motion of defts made during a 3/16/2000 conference call to continue hearing and continuing the hearing on defts' [608-1] motion to dissolve consent decree to 1:15 on 4/28/2000 . (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (skh)

RECAP
618 April 17, 2000

AFFIDAVITS by WV Dept of Health in support of [608-1] and [619-1] motions to vacate/dissolve consent decree, with affidavits of compliance of Frank W. Kirkland, Director of the Division of Developmental Disabilities, Desmond Byrne, Assistant to the Deputy Secretary of the WV DHHR, Phillip A. Lynch, Chief Financial Officer, WV DHHR, Ann M. Burds, Director of the WV DHHR, and Patricia Moss, Director of the Office of Maternal and Child Health, attached. (pdb) Modified on 04/18/2000

RECAP
619 April 17, 2000

MOTION by WV Dept of Education to dissolve consent decree, with affidavit of compliance of the West Virginia Department of Education, Office of Special Education, and exhibits 1 through 7, attached. (skh)

RECAP
620 April 28, 2000

NOTICE of Attorney Appearance for John Barnette, Executive Director, Shawnee Hills Community Mental Health/Mental Retardation Center, Inc. by James W. Thomas, Thomas J. Hurney. (skh)

RECAP
April 28, 2000

COURT PROCEEDING: hearing on deft's motion to vacate consent decree; JUDGE Copenhaver; COURT REPORTER Barbara Steinke. (skh)

621 May 8, 2000

MOTION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart to add the director of the Division of Rehabilitation Services, in her official capacity, as a party deft . (pdb)

RECAP
622 May 16, 2000

SUPPLEMENTATION by Macel Medley, Nancy Barchart to pltfs' original [610-1] response to WV Dept of Health's [608-1] motion to dissolve consent decree. (skh)

RECAP
623 May 25, 2000

REPLY by WV Dept of Education in support of its [619-1] motion to dissolve consent decree. (skh) (Entered: 05/26/2000)

RECAP
624 June 15, 2000

NOTICE of Special Appearance by WV Div. of Rehab. (pdb)

RECAP
625 June 15, 2000

RESPONSE by WV Div. of Rehab to pltfs' [621-1] motion to add party and to [622-1] supplementation to pltfs' original response to motion to vacate decree. (pdb)

RECAP
626 June 15, 2000

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by WV Div. of Rehab for document nos. 624 and 625 to all parties. (pdb)

RECAP
627 Dec. 19, 2000

ORDER scheduling a Hearing at 1:15 p.m. on 1/9/2001 for WV Dept. of Health's [608-1] motion to dissolve consent decree, WV Dept. of Education's [619-1] motion to dissolve consent decree and pltfs' [621-1] motion to add the director of the Division of Rehabilitation Services, in her official capacity, as a party deft, at which lead counsel for all parties shall appear. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (mkw) (Entered: 12/20/2000)

RECAP
Jan. 9, 2001

COURT PROCEEDING: hearing on pltfs' motion to add a party deft and defts WVDHHR and WV Dept. of Education's motions to dissolve consent decree; JUDGE Copenhaver; COURT REPORTER Barbara Steinke. (skh)

Jan. 10, 2001

COURT PROCEEDING: hearing on motion; JUDGE Copenhaver; COURT REPORTER Barbara Steinke. (skh)

628 Jan. 12, 2001

ORDER at the 1/10/01 hearing, counsel agreed that the movant State Superintendent of Schools is in substantial compliance with the consent decree entered 10/8/81; granting in part, denying in part the WV Dept. of Education's [619-1] motion to dissolve consent decree; granting to the extent that the State Superintendent of Schools and the WV Dept. of Education are dismissed as a party to this action, denying otherwise. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (skh) Modified on 01/16/2001

RECAP
629 Jan. 16, 2001

ORDER granting pltfs' [621-1] motion to add party; directing the West Virginia Division of Rehabilitation Services be made a party deft in this action; denying without prejudice the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources' [608-1] motion to dissolve consent decree; once the court's efforts to conciliate the remaining issues have concluded, the WV Dept. of Health and Human Resources may renew the motion to dissolve consent decree on the basis of the motion, memorandum and affidavits heretofore filed or file a new motion for that purpose at any time; directing counsel for the pltfs and deft WV Dept. of Health and Human Resources attend a conference with the court at 9:30 on 1/19/01, for the purpose of identifying significant issues respecting substantial compliance and measures for resolving them . (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (ENTERED NUNC PRO TUNC 1/13/01) (skh) (Entered: 01/17/2001)

RECAP
630 Jan. 18, 2001

PARTIAL TRANSCRIPT of hearing held 1/9/01 on motions to add party and dissolve consent decree; Judge Copenhaver; Court Reporter Barbara Steinke. (skh)

RECAP
631 Jan. 19, 2001

ORDER rescheduling the conference previously scheduled for 1/19/01 at 9:30 to 1:30 on 1/25/01, at which counsel for the pltfs and the deft WV Dept. of Health and Human Resources shall be present. (signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr.) (cc: attys) (skh)

RECAP
632 Feb. 15, 2001

NOTICE of Attorney Appearance for Leon Ginsberg, John E. Burdette II, Mark Hudnall, George Pickett by Stephen J. Small. (skh)

RECAP
633 March 20, 2001

REPORT TO THE COURT by WV Div. of Rehabilitation Services pursuant to the status conference held 1/25/01. (skh)

RECAP
634 March 21, 2001

PROGRESS REPORT by Department of Health and Human Resources, Leon Ginsberg, John E. Burdette II, Mark Hudnall, George Pickett pursuant to the status conference held 1/25/01. (skh)

RECAP
635 March 5, 2012

LETTER-FORM MOTION by Kathryn Davis, Alec Davis to opt out as a Medley class member. (Attachment: # 1 Proposed Order) (taq)

RECAP
636 March 5, 2012

ORDER taking judicial notice that Leon Ginsburg, former Secretary of the West Virginia Department of Welfare, has now been succeeded by Michael J. Lewis, M.D., Ph.D., who is the current Secretary of the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources, the style is amended accordingly; pursuant to receipt of the 2/27/2012 written communication from movant Kathryn Davis, writing on behalf of her son, Alec Davis, for whom she apparently acts as guardian, treating said letter as a motion seeking Alec's exclusion as a class member, permitting his guardian Ms. Davis to decline the services provided to him as a result of the prior orders of the court in this action, directing Ms. Davis to file by 4/1/2012 her appointment papers establishing the alleged guardianship, along with an accompanying affidavit reflecting that the appointment remains in full force and effect, without expectation of any impending modification or termination; directing class counsel and defendant Secretary Lewis to respond to the 635 motion by 4/10/2012, showing cause why the relief requested by Ms. Davis should not be granted, and the remaining defendants may respond by that same date should they so desire; in the event that the relief requested is not opposed by any party, that class counsel and defendant Secretary Lewis are directed to execute, and tender for entry by the aforementioned response date, a proposed order granting the relief requested, with the same also executed by Ms. Davis if she does not wish to be further heard on the matter; and the 2/27/2012 letter is filed today as a part of the official record in this action. Signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr. on 3/5/2012. (cc: attys; Kathryn Davis, P.O. Box 1057, Shepherdstown, West Virginia, 25443; Steve Wiseman, Executive Director, West Virginia Developmental Disabilities Council, 110 Stockton Street, Charleston, West Virginia, 25312-2521; any unrepresented or interested parties) (taq)

RECAP
637 March 14, 2012

NOTICE of Substitution of Counsel by West Virginia Division of Rehabilitation Services (Campbell, Katherine)

RECAP
638 April 3, 2012

ORDER pursuant to the 3/5/2012 636 Order directing movant Kathryn Davis to file certain materials establishing the alleged guardianship of Alec Davis and receipt of certain materials herein on 3/29/2012, directing that said materials are filed as a part of the record in this action. Signed by Judge John T. Copenhaver, Jr. on 4/3/2012. (cc: attys; Ms. Davis, P.O. Box 1057, Shepherdstown, West Virginia, 25443; Steve Wiseman, Executive Director, West Virginia Developmental Disabilities Council, 110 Stockton Street, Charleston, West Virginia, 25312-2521; and any unrepresented or interested parties) (taq)

RECAP
639 April 3, 2012

MATERIALS SUBMITTED by Kathryn Davis, re: appointment papers establishing the alleged guardianship of Alec Davis, pursuant to the Court's 638 Order entered 4/3/2012. (taq)

RECAP
640 April 4, 2012

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY INFORMATION by Charlene A. Vaughan on behalf of Pleasants County Board of Education. (Vaughan, Charlene)

RECAP
641 April 10, 2012

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY INFORMATION by Deborah G. Weston on behalf of Nancy Barchart, Macel Medley. (Weston, Deborah)

RECAP
642 April 10, 2012

RESPONSE by Macel Medley in opposition of 635 LETTER-FORM MOTION by Kathryn Davis, Alec Davis to opt out as a Medley class member. (Attachment: # 1 Exhibit 1)(Weston, Deborah) (Modified description of attachment on 4/10/2012 (skh).

RECAP

Case Details

State / Territory:

West Virginia

Case Type(s):

Intellectual Disability (Facility)

Key Dates

Filing Date: April 21, 1978

Closing Date: 2001

Case Ongoing: No

Plaintiffs

Plaintiff Description:

All citizens of the State of West Virginia under the age of 23 years who suffer from mental retardation and who were or would be institutionalized by reason of the failures of the defendants to place them in foster care or community-based facilities.

Public Interest Lawyer: Yes

Filed Pro Se: No

Class Action Sought: Yes

Class Action Outcome: Granted

Defendants

State

Shawnee Hills Community Mental Health/Mental Retardation Center

Facility Type(s):

Government-run

Case Details

Causes of Action:

42 U.S.C. § 1983

Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act, 42 U.S.C. § 15001 et seq.

Indv. w/ Disab. Educ. Act (IDEA), Educ. of All Handcpd. Children Act , 20 U.S.C. § 1400

Section 504 (Rehabilitation Act), 29 U.S.C. § 701

Constitutional Clause(s):

Due Process

Equal Protection

Other Dockets:

Southern District of West Virginia 2:78-cv-02099

Available Documents:

Any published opinion

Trial Court Docket

Outcome

Prevailing Party: Plaintiff OR Mixed

Relief Granted:

Injunction / Injunctive-like Settlement

Source of Relief:

Settlement

Form of Settlement:

Court Approved Settlement or Consent Decree

Order Duration: 1981 - 2001

Issues

General/Misc.:

Funding

Juveniles

Disability and Disability Rights:

Developmental disability without intellectual disability

Integrated setting

Intellectual/developmental disability, unspecified

Jails, Prisons, Detention Centers, and Other Institutions:

Deinstitutionalization/decarceration

Habilitation (training/treatment)

Recommended Citation