Case: Calhoun v. Pennington

1:09-cv-03286 | U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia

Filed Date: Nov. 24, 2009

Case Ongoing

Clearinghouse coding complete

Case Summary

On November 24, 2009, patrons of Atlanta Eagle, a gay bar in Atlanta, Georgia, filed this lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against the City of Atlanta, the chief of police, and officers of the Atlanta Police Department in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division. The plaintiffs, represented by private lawyer Dan Grossman, and public interest lawyers from Lambda Legal Defense and the Southern Center for Human Rights, asked the Court for damages and declaratory and injunctive relief to redress defendants' violations of plaintiffs' rights under the U.S. Constitution and Georgia Constitution to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. Specifically, plaintiffs claimed that the police action was taken without any particularized reasonable suspicion or probable cause to believe that any individual was involved in any criminal activity. The plaintiffs also sought redress for the numerous state law torts committed by individual defendants, including false imprisonment, assault, battery, and trespass.

According to the complaint, on September 10 and 11, 2009, a paramilitary, SWAT-type force of Atlanta police officers entered the Atlanta Eagle without a warrant, claiming to be searching for public sex, drugs, and illegal weapons. The police forced dozens of bar patrons to lie face-down on the floor, which was covered with spilled beer, dirt, and broken glass. Officers allegedly made threats of violence and anti-gay slurs. Plaintiffs claim that although they were not suspected of any criminal activity, police officers emptied their pockets, confiscated their IDs, and entered every patron's name into a police computer. After the raid, not a single patron was charged with any crime, and no weapons, drugs, or evidence of sex was found.

In December 2010, the parties reached a settlement that required the Atlanta Police Department to rewrite their policies regarding arrest, search, and seizure, and to make other changes to protect the public from police misconduct. The settlement required, among other provisions:

Changes in search and seizure policy to accord with a set of legal principles spelled out in the settlement, covering the requirements for arrests, stops, and searches.
All Atlanta police officers in uniform must wear a conspicuously visible nametag, and any Atlanta police officer who is in uniform or has displayed a badge or other indicia of police authority must identify himself by name and badge number upon request at some point before the end of an encounter with a civilian.
Atlanta police officers may not interfere in any way with a citizen's right to record police activity
Payment of $1,025,000 by the City of Atlanta.

Judge Timothy C. Batten, Sr. issued an order to approve the settlement agreement on December 8, 2010. The court retained jurisdiction to enforce the City of Atlanta's compliance with the terms of the settlement if it failed to implement the actions set forth in the settlement agreement within 180 days of the entry of the order.

On June 16, 2011, the plaintiffs filed a motion for sanctions on the grounds that the Atlanta Police Department had not implemented the police reform policies outlined in the settlement agreement. The police department agreed to implement the policies if plaintiffs withdrew their motion for sanctions.

After three years of inactivity, on March 17, 2015, the plaintiffs filed a motion for contempt sanctions on the grounds that the police department had still not implemented police reform policies. The plaintiffs requested post-judgment discovery. On May 19, 2015, the Court granted the plaintiffs' motion.

In response to a joint motion by the parties, the court ordered the appointment of a special master, Joe D. Whitley, on June 22, 2016 to monitor the Atlanta Police Department's compliance with court orders and assist the parties in addressing any obstacles with compliance or relevant discovery. On September 23, 2016, the court granted the parties' Consent Order Setting Forth Initial Special Master Monitoring, Discovery, and Dispute Resolution Procedures. The consent order laid out detailed procedures for ensuring compliance and a feedback mechanism for the creation of a civil rights training program. The consent order also provided a detailed monitoring scheme. Further, all post-judgment discovery requests were stayed without prejudice.

In two 2016 status reports, Mr. Whitley found that the police department had complied or attempted in good faith to comply with the requirements of the court order. However, after six months, it became clear that there were existing areas of disagreement between the parties regarding the following elements of the court order: (1) the identification requirement for officers; (2) the requirement of no interference with audio or video recordings; (3) documentation of warrantless seizures and identification checks; and (4) timely resolution of citizen complaints. But at that point, Mr. Whitley still believed that all of the issues could be resolved, particularly through increased communication between the parties.

After nine months had passed, however, Mr. Whitley determined that there were fundamental disagreements between the parties regarding the court order's requirements and how compliance should be evaluated. At Mr. Whitley's urging, on July 25, 2017, the Court issued two orders: one requiring that the police department show cause why it should not be held in contempt for violating the court order and another requiring that the department show cause as to why it is entitled to relief from any of the court order's provisions.

On September 25, 2017, the police department filed a motion to disqualify the special master and reassign matters to the district court, as well as an emergency motion to stay the special master's activities. However, the court did not grant the emergency motion and the special master continued to carry out his responsibilities. And on November 28, 2017, the court denied the police department's motion to disqualify the special master and adopted his October 2017 status report.

On February 12, 2018, the court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees incurred by responding to the police department's emergency petition. The court called for briefing and a special master report and recommendation on the issue of whether the attorneys' fees sought were reasonable.

Throughout 2018, the parties engaged in extensive settlement discussions with the goal of reaching an agreement with respect to the show cause order on contempt issues and the police department's compliance with the original settlement agreement. They proposed a new consent order on November 28, 2018, and the court approved it the following day.

The order required the police department to modify 1) training procedures; 2) standard operating procedures; 3) handing citizen complaints; 4) "stop and think" forms; and 5) identification procedures. It also provided the plaintiffs the right to engage in post-judgment discovery, and the right to address any failure to comply in court. Additionally, the city agreed to pay the plaintiffs attorneys' fees.

The case remains open such that the parties may resume litigation if the defendants fail to comply with the consent order.

Summary Authors

Xin Chen (4/3/2011)

Katherine Reineck (1/30/2016)

Virginia Weeks (11/6/2016)

Eva Richardson (12/20/2018)

People

For PACER's information on parties and their attorneys, see: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/4548299/parties/calhoun-v-pennington/

Judge(s)

Batten, Timothy C. Sr. (Georgia)

Attorney for Plaintiff

Barham, Travis C (Georgia)

Attorney for Defendant

Anderson, Cleora S. (Georgia)

Baines, Tamara Nikki (Georgia)

Expert/Monitor/Master/Other

Augsback, Scott David (Georgia)

Judge(s)

Batten, Timothy C. Sr. (Georgia)

Attorney for Plaintiff

Barham, Travis C (Georgia)

Bracewell, Tiffany Nichols (Georgia)

Brinckerhoff, Matthew D. (Georgia)

Burnett, Katharine Madison (Georgia)

Butler, Marla R. (New York)

Cortman, David A. (Georgia)

Dubanevich, William Joseph (Georgia)

Grossman, Daniel J. (Georgia)

Hayes, Thomas (Georgia)

Kung, Lisa L. (Georgia)

Langhofer, Tyson C (Georgia)

Lee, Graham Spencer (Georgia)

Littman, Aaron Michael (Georgia)

Littrell, Elizabeth Lynn (Georgia)

LoPalo, Christopher R. (Georgia)

Nevins, Gregory R. (Georgia)

Norred, Warren V (Georgia)

Reed, Derek D. (Georgia)

Reilly, Thomas Edward (Georgia)

Saylor, Elizabeth S. (Georgia)

Shapiro, Samuel (Georgia)

Skinner, Clayton (Georgia)

Smith, William Alexander (Georgia)

Warring, Jane (Georgia)

Weber, Gerald R. (Georgia)

Attorney for Defendant

Anderson, Cleora S. (Georgia)

Baines, Tamara Nikki (Georgia)

Bridges, Leslie Ann (Georgia)

Brown, Bruce P. (Georgia)

Clifford, Carroll Louis (Georgia)

Crownover, Arthur Crownover (Georgia)

DeLoach, Jerry L. (Georgia)

Gill, Sean Lamar (Georgia)

Godfrey, Robert N. (Georgia)

Gov, Marc A. (Georgia)

Gov, Tommy D. (Georgia)

Grillo, Kevin W. (Georgia)

Hart, Steven Ashley (Georgia)

Hilliard, Robert C. (Georgia)

Hoffler, Veronica L. (Georgia)

Huber, Mary Janet (Georgia)

Ieyoub, Richard P. (Georgia)

Jordan, Dawn Marie (Georgia)

Lorch, Pamela S. (Georgia)

Lowther, Edwin Lee (Georgia)

Mayes, Cayenne (Georgia)

Miller, Staci J. (Georgia)

Phillips, Wesley L (Georgia)

Power, Stephen A. (Georgia)

Rahman, Tanvir Haque (Georgia)

Rashad, Maiysha (Georgia)

Sallings, Jerry Jon (Georgia)

Shahar, Robin Joy (Georgia)

Terry, LaShawn W. (Georgia)

Valladares, Richard J. (Georgia)

Ware, Daniel D. (Georgia)

Watts, Mikal C. (Georgia)

Wyatt-Bullman, Alisha Irene (Georgia)

Young, Dennis McRay (Georgia)

Expert/Monitor/Master

Whitley, Joe D. (Georgia)

Other

Augsback, Scott David (Georgia)

Hampton, Cathy D. (Georgia)

Hoff, David J (Georgia)

Kruer, David A. (Georgia)

Attorney Contact Information via CourtListener

Documents in the Clearinghouse

Documents in this case

1:09-cv-03286	Docket [PACER]	Nov. 13, 2019	Nov. 13, 2019 Docket
44 1:09-cv-03286	First Amended Complaint	March 17, 2010	March 17, 2010 Complaint
236 1:09-cv-03286	Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Discovery and for Sanctions	Oct. 6, 2010	Oct. 6, 2010 Pleading / Motion / Brief
251 1:09-cv-03286	Defendants' Motion in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Discovery and for Sanctions	Oct. 22, 2010	Oct. 22, 2010 Pleading / Motion / Brief
265 1:09-cv-03286	Order Approving the Settlement	Dec. 8, 2010	Dec. 8, 2010 Order/Opinion
265-1 1:09-cv-03286	Exhibit A: Reforms of the Atlanta Police Department	Dec. 8, 2010	Dec. 8, 2010 Settlement Agreement
271 1:09-cv-03286	Motion for Sanctions	June 16, 2011	June 16, 2011 Pleading / Motion / Brief
281 1:09-cv-03286	Motion for Contempt	March 17, 2015	March 17, 2015 Pleading / Motion / Brief
323 1:09-cv-03286	Consent Order Setting Forth Initial Special Master Monitoring, Discovery, and Dispute Resolution Procedures	Sept. 23, 2016	Sept. 23, 2016 Order/Opinion
324 1:09-cv-03286	Special Master Quarterly Compliance Report Dated September 29, 2016	Sept. 29, 2016	Sept. 29, 2016 Monitor/Expert/Receiver Report

show / hide documents

Resources

Resources related to this case
Title	Description		External URL Date / External URL
Atlanta Eagle Raid Dan Grossman	This website is presented by the Atlanta Eagle, and has been prepared by Dan Grossman, Attorney-at-Law, who represents the Atlanta Eagle and many of its patrons in connection with the civil rights is…	Sept. 10, 2009	Sept. 10, 2009 http://atlantaeagleraid.com/...

show / hide resources

Docket

See docket on RECAP: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/4548299/calhoun-v-pennington/

Last updated July 22, 2026, 5:33 a.m.

ECF Number	Date	Description	Link
1	Nov. 24, 2009	COMPLAINT with Jury Demand filed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Consent form to proceed before U.S. Magistrate and pretrial instructions provided. (Filing fee $350 receipt number 18636.) (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet)(alc) Please visit our website at http://www.gand.uscourts.gov to obtain Pretrial Instructions. (Entered: 11/25/2009) 1 Civil Cover Sheet View on PACER	RECAP
2	Nov. 24, 2009	NOTICE of Appearance by Daniel J. Grossman on behalf of Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (alc) (Entered: 11/25/2009)	RECAP
3	Nov. 24, 2009	NOTICE of Appearance by Graham Spencer Lee on behalf of Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (alc) (Entered: 11/25/2009)	RECAP
4	Nov. 24, 2009	NOTICE of Appearance by Elizabeth Lynn Littrell on behalf of Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (alc) (Entered: 11/25/2009)	RECAP
5	Nov. 24, 2009	Certificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement, filed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (alc) (Entered: 11/25/2009)	RECAP
6	Nov. 25, 2009	INSTRUCTIONS to Parties and Counsel. Signed by Judge Timothy C. Batten, Sr. on 11/25/2009. (alc) (Entered: 11/25/2009)	RECAP
	Nov. 30, 2009	Clerks Notation re 5 Certificate of Interested Persons reviewed by TCB. (jgs)
	Nov. 30, 2009	Clerks Notation for LOA/CIP
7	Dec. 7, 2009	Mail Returned as Undeliverable. Mail sent to atty Daniel J. Grossman at Powell Goldstein Frazer and Murphy re 6 Instructions to Parties and Counsel. (alc) (Entered: 12/09/2009)	RECAP
	Dec. 9, 2009	Clerk's Certificate of Re-Mailing as to atty Daniel J. Grossman re 6 Instructions to Parties and Counsel. Documents mailed to atty at new address of Daniel J. Grossman, Attorney at Law, Suite 138, 1579-F Monroe Drive, Atlanta, GA 30324 (new address as updated on the docket). (alc)
	Dec. 9, 2009	Clerks Certificate of Mailing
8	Dec. 17, 2009	Summons Issued as to Richard Pennington, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins. (alc) (Entered: 12/17/2009)	RECAP
9	Jan. 19, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. B.E. Bridges (in his official capacity) waiver mailed on 12/30/2009, answer due 3/1/2010. (Lee, Graham) Modified on 2/26/2010 to add notation re capacity (alc). (Entered: 01/19/2010)	RECAP
10	Jan. 19, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. City of Atlanta waiver mailed on 12/30/2009, answer due 3/1/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 01/19/2010)	RECAP
11	Jan. 19, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Richard Pennington waiver mailed on 12/30/2009, answer due 3/1/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 01/19/2010)	RECAP
12	Feb. 4, 2010	MOTION for Clerks Entry of Default of Defendant Richard Pennington by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 02/04/2010)	RECAP
13	Feb. 4, 2010	PROPOSED ORDER Default Judgment as to Richard Pennington . (Lee, Graham) Modified on 2/5/2010 to correct docket text to accurately reflect e-filed pleading (alc). (Entered: 02/04/2010)	RECAP
14	Feb. 5, 2010	Return of Service Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Richard Pennington in his individual capacity served on 1/2/2010, answer due 1/25/2010. (Lee, Graham) Modified on 2/5/2010 to add text re defendant capacity and correct answer due date (alc). (Entered: 02/05/2010)	RECAP
	Feb. 5, 2010	Notification of Docket Correction re 13 PROPOSED ORDER Default Judgment as to Richard Pennington: the docket has been corrected to accurately reflect the e-filed pleading as a proposed order. (alc)
	Feb. 5, 2010	Notification of Docket Correction
	Feb. 5, 2010	Notification of Docket Correction re 14 Return of Service Executed as to Richard Pennington: the docket text has been updated to reflect the service executed as to Defendant in his individual capacity, with corresponding answer due date of 1/25/2010. (Note: Defendant in his official capacity waived service via the 11 Waiver of Service Executed, with corresponding answer due date of 3/1/2010). (alc)
15	Feb. 11, 2010	MOTION to Set Aside Default by Richard Pennington. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit "A", # 2 Exhibit "B", # 3 Affidavit of Amber A. Robinson, # 4 Affidavit of Dennis M. Young)(Young, Dennis) (Entered: 02/11/2010) 1 Exhibit "A" View on PACER 2 Exhibit "B" View on PACER 3 Affidavit of Amber A. Robinson View on PACER 4 Affidavit of Dennis M. Young View on PACER	RECAP
16	Feb. 25, 2010	RESPONSE re 15 MOTION to Set Aside Default filed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit of Graham S. Lee)(Lee, Graham) (Entered: 02/25/2010) 1 Affidavit of Graham S. Lee View on PACER	RECAP
17	Feb. 26, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. B.E. Bridges waiver (in his individual capacity) mailed on 2/18/2010, answer due 4/19/2010. (Lee, Graham) Modified on 2/26/2010 to add notation re capacity (alc). (Entered: 02/26/2010)	RECAP
18	Feb. 26, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Marlon O. Noble waiver (in his individual capacity) mailed on 2/18/2010, answer due 4/19/2010. (Lee, Graham) Modified on 3/1/2010 to add notation re capacity (alc). (Entered: 02/26/2010)	RECAP
	Feb. 26, 2010	Submission to District Judge
	Feb. 26, 2010	Submission of 12 MOTION for Clerk's Entry of Default of Defendant Richard Pennington, submitted to District Judge Timothy C. Batten, Sr. (alc)
19	March 1, 2010	City Defendants' ANSWER to 1 COMPLAINT by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins. Discovery ends on 7/29/2010.(Young, Dennis) Please visit our website at http://www.gand.uscourts.gov to obtain Pretrial Instructions. (Entered: 03/01/2010)	RECAP
20	March 2, 2010	NOTICE of Appearance by Stephen A. Power on behalf of Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins. (Power, Stephen) Modified on 3/2/2010 to remove John/Jane Does 1-45 as filers (alc). (Entered: 03/02/2010)	RECAP
21	March 9, 2010	First Initial Disclosures by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins. (Power, Stephen) Modified on 3/10/2010 to remove John/Jane Does 1-45 as filers (alc). (Entered: 03/09/2010)	RECAP
22	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Robert Kelley filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
23	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of David Shepherd filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
24	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Matthew Pressley filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
25	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of David Thomas filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
26	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Thomas Hayes filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
27	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Kenneth Keck filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
28	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of John Curran filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
29	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Nicholas Koperski filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
30	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Geoffrey Calhoun filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
31	March 11, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Brian Hughes filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/11/2010)	RECAP
32	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Mark Danak filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
33	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Raymond Matheson filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
34	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of M. Du-Wayne Ray filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
35	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Rob Treutel filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
36	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Benjamin Cheaves filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
37	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Gary Ziemer filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
38	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Sean Gaboya filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
39	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Robert Marlow filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
40	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Alan Dale filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
41	March 12, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Thomas Fast filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/12/2010)	RECAP
42	March 15, 2010	Initial Disclosures by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Littrell, Elizabeth) (Entered: 03/15/2010)	RECAP
43	March 16, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Robert Marlow filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, B.E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, J.G. Watkins (Power, Stephen) (Entered: 03/16/2010)	RECAP
44	March 17, 2010	First AMENDED COMPLAINT against all defendants, filed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Mark Danak, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr., and Gary Ziemer. (Littrell, Elizabeth) Please visit our website at http://www.gand.uscourts.gov to obtain Pretrial Instructions. Modified on 3/18/2010 to add Garcia, McLeod, Schmaltz, Thomas, Treutel, and Ziemer as filers (alc). (Entered: 03/17/2010)	RECAP
45	March 19, 2010	Joint PRELIMINARY REPORT AND DISCOVERY PLAN filed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III, Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, Bennie E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, Jared G. Watkins. (Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 3/22/2010 to add dft co-filers (alc). (Entered: 03/19/2010)	RECAP
46	March 22, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Melonie Mague waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/22/2010)	RECAP
47	March 22, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Debra A. Williams waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/22/2010)	RECAP
48	March 23, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Felix Garcia filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, Bennie E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, Jared G. Watkins, George Turner, Willie Adams, III, John H. Brock, Dimitrio O. Caldwell, Kelly Collier, Craig Condon, Gregory D. Dabney, Stalone Davis, Christipher Dowd, Jeremy D. Edwards, Herman E. Glass, Robert C. Godwin, Brandon Jackson, Dimitri Jaques, Melonie Mague, Vicente Marcano, Cayenne Mayes, Timothy McClain, James Menzoian, Dion Meridith, Scott Pautsch, Darnell Perry, Scott Perry, William Porter, Edward Rabb, Cedric F. Smith, Tyrone Taylor, Kelleita Thurman, Stephanie Upton, Ronald J. Walker, William Walters, Debra A. Williams (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/23/2010)	RECAP
49	March 23, 2010	NOTICE to Take Deposition of Jeffrey McLeod filed by Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, Bennie E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, Jared G. Watkins, George Turner, Willie Adams, III, John H. Brock, Dimitrio O. Caldwell, Kelly Collier, Craig Condon, Gregory D. Dabney, Stalone Davis, Christipher Dowd, Jeremy D. Edwards, Herman E. Glass, Robert C. Godwin, Brandon Jackson, Dimitri Jaques, Melonie Mague, Vicente Marcano, Cayenne Mayes, Timothy McClain, James Menzoian, Dion Meridith, Scott Pautsch, Darnell Perry, Scott Perry, William Porter, Edward Rabb, Cedric F. Smith, Tyrone Taylor, Kelleita Thurman, Stephanie Upton, Ronald J. Walker, William Walters, Debra A. Williams (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/23/2010)	RECAP
50	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. George Turner waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
51	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Willie Adams, III waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
52	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. John H. Brock waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
53	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Dimitrio O. Caldwell waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
54	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Kelly Collier waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
55	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Craig Condon waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
56	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Gregory D. Dabney waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
57	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Stalone Davis waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
58	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Christipher Dowd waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
59	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Herman E. Glass waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
60	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Robert C. Godwin waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
61	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Brandon Jackson waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
62	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Dimitri Jaques waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
63	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Cayenne Mayes waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
64	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Timothy McClain waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
65	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. James Menzoian waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
66	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Dion Meridith waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
67	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Scott Pautsch waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
68	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Darnell Perry waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
69	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. William Porter waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
70	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Edward Rabb waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
71	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Cedric F. Smith waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
72	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Tyrone Taylor waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
73	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Kelleita Thurman waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
74	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Ronald J. Walker waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
75	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. William Walters waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
76	March 24, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Jared G. Watkins waiver mailed on 3/15/2010, answer due 5/14/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/24/2010)	RECAP
77	March 26, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Jeremy D. Edwards waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/26/2010)	RECAP
78	March 26, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Vicente Marcano waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/26/2010)	RECAP
79	March 26, 2010	NOTICE of Appearance by Dennis McRay Young on behalf of Richard Pennington, City of Atlanta, Bennie E. Bridges, Marlon O. Noble, Jared G. Watkins, George Turner, Willie Adams, III, John H. Brock, Dimitrio O. Caldwell, Kelly Collier, Craig Condon, Gregory D. Dabney, Stalone Davis, Christipher Dowd, Jeremy D. Edwards, Herman E. Glass, Robert C. Godwin, Brandon Jackson, Dimitri Jaques, Melonie Mague, Vicente Marcano, Cayenne Mayes, Timothy McClain, James Menzoian, Dion Meridith, Scott Pautsch, Darnell Perry, Scott Perry, William Porter, Edward Rabb, Cedric F. Smith, Tyrone Taylor, Kelleita Thurman, Stephanie Upton, Ronald J. Walker, William Walters, Debra A. Williams (Young, Dennis) (Entered: 03/26/2010)	RECAP
80	March 29, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Stephanie Upton waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 03/29/2010)	RECAP
	April 1, 2010	Submission of 15 MOTION to Set Aside Default, submitted to District Judge Timothy C. Batten, Sr. (alc)
	April 1, 2010	Submission to District Judge
81	April 2, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Plaintiffs First Request For Production To Defendant City Of Atlanta by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) (Entered: 04/02/2010)	RECAP
82	April 2, 2010	WAIVER OF SERVICE Returned Executed by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. Scott Perry waiver mailed on 3/17/2010, answer due 5/17/2010. (Lee, Graham) (Entered: 04/02/2010)	RECAP
83	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant Willie Adams, III by Geoffrey Calhoun, Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III. (Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service and add co-filers (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
84	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant Bennie E. Bridges by Geoffrey Calhoun, Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III..(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service and add co-filers (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
85	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant John H. Brock by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
86	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant Dimitrio O. Caldwell by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
87	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' Second Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant City of Atlanta by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
88	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant Kelly Collier by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP
89	April 5, 2010	CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Discovery - Plaintiffs' First Request for Production and First Continuing Interrogatories to Defendant Craig Condon by Saverio Monteleone, Matthew Presley, M. Du-Wayne Ray, David Shepherd, Allan Vives, Ramey & Kelley, Inc., Rawhide Leather, Inc., John Curran, Geoffrey Calhoun, Alan Dale, Felix Garcia, Jeffrey McLeod, Mark Danak, Chris Schmaltz, David Thomas, Robert Treutel, Jr, Gary Ziemer, Christopher Daniels, Thomas Fast, Sean Gaboya, Thomas Hayes, Brian Hughes, Kenneth Keck, Nicholas Koperski, Robert Marlow, Benjamin Cheaves, Raymond Matheson, Robert McLendon, III.(Grossman, Daniel) Modified on 4/6/2010 to update text re subject of service (alc). (Entered: 04/05/2010)	RECAP

show / hide docket entries

Case Details

State / Territory:

Georgia

Case Type(s):

Policing

Special Collection(s):

Multi-LexSum (in sample)

Key Dates

Filing Date: Nov. 24, 2009

Case Ongoing: Yes

Plaintiffs

Plaintiff Description:

Patrons of Atlanta Eagle, a gay bar in Atlanta, Georgia, who were unlawfully searched, detained, and/or arrested on September 10-11, 2009, by the Atlanta Police Department.

Plaintiff Type(s):

Private Plaintiff

Attorney Organizations:

Lambda Legal

Southern Center for Human Rights (SCHR)

Public Interest Lawyer: Yes

Filed Pro Se: No

Class Action Sought: No

Class Action Outcome: Not sought

Defendants

State

City of Atlanta Police Department