Case: Jones v. Hobbs

CV-2010-1118 | Arkansas state trial court

Filed Date: March 8, 2010

Case Ongoing

Clearinghouse coding complete

Case Summary

On March 8. 2010, a prisoner scheduled to be executed in Arkansas, filed an action against the Arkansas Department of Corrections (ADC) in the Circuit Court for the County of Pulaski. The Plaintiff, represented by the Federal Defenders, sought an injunction against the state prohibiting his execution, claiming that the Arkansas Method of Execution Act (MEA), violated the state constitution. Specifically, the plaintiff claimed that the MEA's removal of standards for lethal injection and 'menu-st…

In 2008, an injunction had been entered in the U.S. District Court against the ADC prohibiting executions until the execution policy was found to comply with the Administrative Procedures Act. The Act requires a 30 day public comment period before enactment proposed regulations and policies. The ADC had promulgated a detailed execution policy without complying with this provision.

Rather than complying with the Administrative Procedures Act requirements, the Legislature passed a law which gave the Director of the ADC authority to select from several methods of legislatively-sanctioned lethal injection. The plaintiffs filed a suit to enjoin the law as violating Article IV of the Arkansas state constitution, which is a separation-of-powers article. The plaintiffs claimed that the law gave the Director of the ADC unfettered discretion in choosing the method of execution. Plaintiffs further claimed that "[t]he legislative record shows that the Method of Execution Act (MEA) was purposefully designed to avoid the embarrassment of public oversight and the inconvenience of judicial review." Lastly, the plaintiffs claimed that the legislation would allow for 'single-chemical' lethal injections, which were so barbaric that they were not allowed in animal euthanasia.

Several prisoners awaiting execution intervened in the lawsuit.

On December 16, 2010, the Court (Judge Timothy Davis Fox) dismissed claims from several intervenor's complaints in an unpublished order. The separation-of-powers issue was the only issue left for consideration. The plaintiffs and defendants filed cross motions for summary judgment.

On August 29, 2011, in entering a Final Order, the Court found that the MEA was unconstitutional, and ordered that the language granting unlimited authority to the Director of the ADC ("any other chemical or chemicals, including but not limited to") stricken. The Defendants and Plaintiffs both objected to this order, and both filed cross appeals directly to the Arkansas Supreme Court.

On June 22, 2012, the Arkansas Supreme Court (Judge Jim Gunter) entered a published opinion (2012 Ark. 293) finding the law unconstitutional, but that the Circuit Court's Order striking language from the statute did not correct the constitutional infirmity. The Court found that the statute was not severable, and struck down the entire MEA. It then remanded the case to the Circuit Court.

As of this writing (6/26/2012), there have been no further developments in this case.

Summary Authors

Blase Kearney (6/26/2012)

People

Judge(s)

Baker, Karen Renee (Arkansas)

Fox, Timothy Davis (Arkansas)

Attorney for Plaintiff

Adams, Dale E. (Arkansas)

Braden, Scott W. (Oklahoma)

Czuba, Deborah Anne (Arkansas)

Judge(s)

Baker, Karen Renee (Arkansas)

Fox, Timothy Davis (Arkansas)

Gunter, James Houston Jr. (Arkansas)

Attorney for Plaintiff

Adams, Dale E. (Arkansas)

Braden, Scott W. (Oklahoma)

Czuba, Deborah Anne (Arkansas)

Lee, Joshua R. (Arkansas)

Luby, Joseph W. (Arkansas)

Merrigan, Jennifer (Arkansas)

Rosenzweig, Jeffrey (Arkansas)

Sallings , Deborah Ruth (Arkansas)

Documents in the Clearinghouse

Documents in this case

11-01128	Docket [Arkansas Supreme Court] Hobbs v. Jones Arkansas state supreme court	June 22, 2012	June 22, 2012 Docket
10-cv-01118	Docket Jack Harold Jones v. Ray Hobbs U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit	April 15, 2013	April 15, 2013 Docket
10-cv-01118	Complaint Hobbs v. Jones	March 8, 2010	March 8, 2010 Complaint
10-cv-01118	Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Hobbs v. Jones	Dec. 16, 2010	Dec. 16, 2010 Order/Opinion 2010 WL 8757802
10-cv-01118	Order Dismissing Count Eight of the Complaint Hobbs v. Jones	April 7, 2011	April 7, 2011 Order/Opinion 2011 WL 8342342
11-00577	Opinion McGehee v. Hobbs Arkansas state supreme court	June 23, 2011	June 23, 2011 Order/Opinion 2011 Ark. 285
10-cv-01118	Final Order on Cross Motions for Summary Judgment Hobbs v. Jones	Aug. 29, 2011	Aug. 29, 2011 Order/Opinion 2011 WL 8342339
11-01128	Opinion Hobbs v. Jones Arkansas state supreme court	June 22, 2012	June 22, 2012 Order/Opinion 2012 Ark. 293
11-00577 10-00260 10-00351 10-00428	Opinion Arkansas state supreme court	April 11, 2013	April 11, 2013 Order/Opinion 2013 Ark. 151

show / hide documents

Docket

Last updated Jan. 24, 2024, 2:28 p.m.

Change selected docket

ECF Number	Date	Description
08032...	March 8, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV.6.2010.415
08032...	March 8, 2010	Description: MOTION OTHEREntry: MOTION FOR INJUCTIVE RELIEF OPERATING AS A STAY OF EXECUTION JEFF ROSENZWEIG
08032...	March 8, 2010	Description: AFFIDAVIT OF INDIGENCYEntry: none.
08032...	March 8, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: none.
	March 8, 2010	Description: SUMMONS ISSUEDEntry: none.
08032...	March 8, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: none.
	March 8, 2010	Description: MOF ORIGINALEntry: none.
10032...	March 10, 2010	Description: NOTICE OF APPEALEntry: NOTICE OF APPEAL AND DESIGNATION OF RECORD JEFF ROSENZWEIG
10032...	March 10, 2010	Description: ORDER OTHEREntry: ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF OPERATING AS A STAY OF EXECUTION CV.6.2010.424
	March 11, 2010	Description: TRANSCRIPTEntry: TRANSCRIPT PICKED UP BY JEFF ROSENZWIEG
16032...	March 16, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: MOTION OF DON W DAVIS TO INTERVENE AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT DEBORAH SALLINGS
16032...	March 16, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: DEBORAH SALLINGS
17032...	March 17, 2010	Description: MANDATEEntry: FROM SUPREME COURT / MOTION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION. MOTION MOOT. CV.6.2010.460
19032...	March 19, 2010	Description: BRIEF IN SUPPORTEntry: DEFENDANTS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
19032...	March 19, 2010	Description: MOTION DISMISSEntry: DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS C JOSEPH CORI JR
19032...	March 19, 2010	Description: AMENDED MOTIONEntry: FIRST AMENDED MOTION OF DON W. DAIVS TO INTERVEN AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT DEBORAH SALLINGS
23032...	March 23, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: none.
23032...	March 23, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: JEFF ROSENZWEIG
23032...	March 23, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: COMPLAINT IN INTERVENTION FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JEFF ROSENZWIG
23032...	March 23, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV.6.2010.483
26032...	March 26, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: DEFENDANT'S' RESPONSE TO DON W. DAVIS' FIRS AMENDED MOTION TO INTERVENE C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
01042...	April 1, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS DEBORAH SALLINGS
02042...	April 2, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: none.
02042...	April 2, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: MARCEL WILLIAMS CV.6.2010.546
02042...	April 2, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: DEBORAH A CZUBA , JOSH LEE
	April 5, 2010	Description: TRANSCRIPTEntry: TRANSCRIPT PICKED UP BY DEBORAH SALLINGS.
05042...	April 5, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV.6.2010.544 (DON DAVIS)
06042...	April 6, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: COMPLAINT IN INTERVENTION FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
06042...	April 6, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: JEFF ROSENZWEIG
06042...	April 6, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV.6.2010.566
06042...	April 6, 2010	Description: MOTION OTHEREntry: MOTION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS / ALVIN JACKSON AND KENNETH WILLIAMS JEFF ROSENZWEIG
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JOSEPH LUBY
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: MOTION OTHEREntry: MOTION OF JOSEPH W LUBY AND JENNIFER A. MERRIGAN FOR PERMISSION TO PRACTICE BY COMITY
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV.6.2010.567
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: (MOTION TO PROCEED) (BRUCE WARD)
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: BRUCE EARL WARD
07042...	April 7, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: CV..6.2010.565
08042...	April 8, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JOSH LEE
08042...	April 8, 2010	Description: MOTION INTERVENEEntry: (JASON MCGEHEE)
08042...	April 8, 2010	Description: AFFIDAVIT FILEDEntry: AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS (JASON MCGEHEE)
08042...	April 8, 2010	Description: PET PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: (JASON MCGEHEE
08042...	April 8, 2010	Description: ORDER PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPEREntry: FOR JASON MCGEHEE CV.6.2010.579
14042...	April 14, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO MOTIONS TO INTERVENE BY STACEY EUGENE JOHNSON, MARCEL WILLIAMS, FRANK WILLIAMS, JR. JASON MCGEHEE, AND BRUCE EARL WARD. C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
	April 27, 2010	Description: TRANSCRIPTEntry: TRANSCRIPT PICKED UP BY JOSEPH CUMMINGS III FOR JEFF ROSENZWEIG'S OFFICE
17052...	May 17, 2010	Description: NOTICE - OTHEREntry: CV.6.2010.768 FORMAL ORDER/AMENDED ORDER RENEWAL OF PETITION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION IS GRANTED FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS
19072...	July 19, 2010	Description: ORDER MOTION GRANTEDEntry: ORDER GRANTING ALL REQUESTING DEFENDANS' MOTIONS TO INTERVENE. INTERVENORS SHALL HAVE (10) CALENDER DAYS FROM THIS ENTRY TO FILE ALL COMPLAINTS IN INTERVENTION DEFENDANTS SHALL THEN HAVE (20) CALENDER DAYS FROM SERVICE TO FILE RESPONSE(S) CV.6.2010.1151
20072...	July 20, 2010	Description: NOTICE - OTHEREntry: LETTER GIVING NOTICE THAT ALL METIONED DEATH-ROW PRISONERS HAVE FILED MOTIONS TO INTERVENE IN THIS LAWSUIT C. JOSEPH CORDI, JR.
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVIENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF DEBORAH A CZUBBA
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JOSH LEE
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF DEBORAH SALLINGS
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JOSEPH W LUBY
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JEFF ROSENZWEIG
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: COMPLAINT/PETITION FILEDEntry: INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF SCOTT BRADEN
29072...	July 29, 2010	Description: AMENDED COMPLAINTEntry: AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF JEFF ROSENZWEIG
	Aug. 12, 2010	Description: SUMMONS SERVEDEntry: BY DEBORAH SALLINGS
	Aug. 12, 2010	Description: SUMMONS SERVEDEntry: DEF 08-09-2010 - BY SCOTT BRADEN
12082...	Aug. 12, 2010	Description: SUMMONS SERVEDEntry: JOSH LEE
	Aug. 12, 2010	Description: SUMMONS SERVEDEntry: DEBORAH ANNE CZUBA
17082...	Aug. 17, 2010	Description: BRIEF IN SUPPORTEntry: BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION N SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PLAINTIFF JONES AND THE COMPLAINTS OF THE INTERVENORS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
17082...	Aug. 17, 2010	Description: MOTION OTHEREntry: MOTION BY DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PLAINTIFF JONES AND THE COMPLAINTS OF THE INTERVENORS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
30082...	Aug. 30, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISSS AMENDED COMPLAINTS
10092...	Sept. 10, 2010	Description: MOTION EXTEND SERVICE TIMEEntry: DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE A REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PLAINTIFF JONES AND THE COMPLAINTS OF THE INTERVENORS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
15092...	Sept. 15, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PLAINTIFF JONES AND THE COMPLAINTS OF THE INTERVENORS C JOSEPH CORDI JR
21092...	Sept. 21, 2010	Description: ORDER EXTENSION OF TIMEEntry: SEPT 15,2010 CV.6.2010.1552
21092...	Sept. 21, 2010	Description: LETTEREntry: C JOSEPH CORDI, JR (ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL)
	Sept. 23, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: PLAINTIFFS' SURREPLY IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS.
29092...	Sept. 29, 2010	Description: BRIEF IN SUPPORTEntry: DEFENDANTS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER STAYING DISCOVERY PENDING THE COURT'S RULING ON THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS. JOE CORDI, JR
29092...	Sept. 29, 2010	Description: MOTION PROTECTIVE ORDEREntry: DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER STAYING DISCOVERY PENDING THE COURT'S RULING ON THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS JOE CORDI, JR
08102...	Oct. 8, 2010	Description: NOTICE - OTHEREntry: NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS FOR PLAINTIFF'S (BRUCE EARL WARD) ATTORNEY JOSEPH W LUBY NEW ADDRESS IS AS FOLLOWS DEATH PENALTY LITIGATION CLINIC 6155 OAK STREET, SUITE C KANSAS CITY, MO 64113 SUBMITTED BY JOSEPH W LUBY
11102...	Oct. 11, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER STAYING DISCOVERY PENDING THE MOTION TO DISMISS SCOTT W BRADEN
13102...	Oct. 13, 2010	Description: REPLY BRIEFEntry: DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER STAYING DISCOVERY PENDING THE COURT'S RULING ON THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
20102...	Oct. 20, 2010	Description: MOTION OTHEREntry: MOTION FOR SANCTIONS TO COMPEL AND FOR OTHER RELIEF SCOTT W BRADEN
03112...	Nov. 3, 2010	Description: LETTEREntry: JEFF ROSENZWEIG
03112...	Nov. 3, 2010	Description: LETTEREntry: C JOSEPH CORDI JR
03112...	Nov. 3, 2010	Description: NOTICE HEARING SCHEDULEDEntry: MOTION HEARING NOV 30,2010 @ 830
	Nov. 3, 2010	Description: MOTION HEARING CANCELLEDEntry: none.
04112...	Nov. 4, 2010	Description: LETTEREntry: TO JUDGE FOX FROM JOSEPH CORDI
04112...	Nov. 4, 2010	Description: RESPONSE/REPLYEntry: DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SANCTIONS, TO COMPEL, AND FOR OTHER RELIEF C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
05112...	Nov. 5, 2010	Description: TRIAL ACKNOWLEDGEDEntry: ACKNOWLEDGED BY DEBORAH ANNE CZUBA ON DATE OF NOVEMBER 4, 2010
05112...	Nov. 5, 2010	Description: TRIAL ACKNOWLEDGEDEntry: ACKNOWLEDGED BY JOSH LEE ON DATE OF NOVEMBER 3, 2010
05112...	Nov. 5, 2010	Description: TRIAL ACKNOWLEDGEDEntry: ACKNOWLEDGED BY SCOTT W BRADEN ON DATE OF NOVEMBER 4, 2010
10112...	Nov. 10, 2010	Description: TRIAL ACKNOWLEDGEDEntry: ACKNOWLEDGED BY JOE CORDI ON DATE OF NOVEMBER 8, 2010
	Nov. 30, 2010	Description: MOTION HEARING HELDEntry: none.
30112...	Nov. 30, 2010	Description: ORDER MOTION GRANTEDEntry: ORDER GRANTING MOTION OF JOSEPH W LUBY AND JENNIFER A MERRIGAN FOR PERMISSION TO PARACTICE BY COMITY. CV.6.2010.2048
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF BRUCE WARD JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF MARCEL WILLIAMS JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF FRANK WILLIAMS, JR JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF DON W DAVIS JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMOPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF KENNETH WILLIAMS JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF JASON MCGEHEE JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF ALVIN JACKSON JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE INTERVENING COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF STACEY EUGENE JOHNSON JOSEPH CORDI, JR
13122...	Dec. 13, 2010	Description: ANSWER FILEDEntry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS RAY HOBBS AND THE AR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO THE AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FILED BY PLAINTIFF JACK JONES JOSEPH CORDI, JR
16122...	Dec. 16, 2010	Description: ORDER OTHEREntry: ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART THE DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS, DENYING THE DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER, AND DENYING THE PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR SANCTIONS C JOSEPH CORDI, JR CV.6.2010.2193
24012...	Jan. 24, 2011	Description: CV COMPLAINT FILEDEntry: PLAINTIFFS' SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT
02022...	Feb. 2, 2011	Description: MOTION COMPELEntry: BOTH PLAINTIFF'S ASKING COURT TO COMPEL DEFENDANT RAY HOBBS UNDER RULE 37 SCOTT BRADEN
07022...	Feb. 7, 2011	Description: BRIEF IN SUPPORTEntry: BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
07022...	Feb. 7, 2011	Description: MOTION PROTECTIVE ORDEREntry: C JOSEPH CORDI, JR
16022...	Feb. 16, 2011	Description: BRIEF IN SUPPORTEntry: BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO DISMISS COUNTS EIGHT AND NINE OF THE PLAINTIFFS' SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT C JOSEPH CORDI, JR