Case: Drummond v. Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board
121694 | Oklahoma state supreme court
Filed Date: Oct. 20, 2023
Closed Date: June 23, 2025
Clearinghouse coding complete
Case Summary
This case asked whether Oklahoma could sponsor and fund the nation’s first religious public charter school. In 2023, Oklahoma’s Statewide Virtual Charter School Board (the “Board”) approved St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, an online K-12 school established by the Archdiocese of Oklahoma City and the Diocese of Tulsa. St. Isidore planned to operate as a Catholic school and to participate “in the evangelizing mission of the church.”
In December 2022, then-state Attorney General John O’Connor issued an opinion concluding that the state could not exclude religious schools from its charter school program. His successor, Gentner Drummond, withdrew that opinion in February 2023. Nonetheless, on June 5, 2023, the Board voted 3-2 to approve St. Isidore’s application, and on October 9 it approved the school’s charter contract by another 3-2 vote. The parties signed the contract on October 16. The contract departed from the Board’s model contract in several ways. It omitted the model’s section prohibiting religious affiliation, stated that St. Isidore was affiliated with a religious institution, and recognized the school’s right to freely exercise its religious beliefs. It was set to take effect on July 1, 2024.
On October 20, 2023, Attorney General Drummond, on behalf of the State of Oklahoma, filed this lawsuit directly in the Supreme Court of Oklahoma. He asked the court to take the case in the first instance rather than on appeal. He sued the Board and its five members in their official capacities. Represented by the Attorney General’s office, the state sought a writ of mandamus requiring the Board to cancel the contract, along with a declaratory judgment that the contract was unlawful. The state claimed that the contract violated the Oklahoma Charter Schools Act and the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. It also claimed the contract violated two provisions of the Oklahoma Constitution: one requiring public schools to be “free from sectarian control,” and one barring the use of public money for the benefit of any religious institution. The petition noted that a separate challenge to the Board’s approval was already pending in Oklahoma County District Court.
On November 14, 2023, the court allowed St. Isidore to join the case to defend its contract. St. Isidore was represented by Dechert LLP, the Notre Dame Law School Religious Liberty Clinic, and Perri Dunn, PLLC. The Board was represented by private counsel and Alliance Defending Freedom. The court denied requests to intervene by the Oklahoma State Department of Education and State Superintendent of Public Instruction Ryan Walters, and later by a group of Oklahoma taxpayers, parents, and clergy. Both groups participated instead by filing amicus briefs. The taxpayers were represented by Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the American Civil Liberties Union, the Education Law Center, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation. The court heard oral argument on April 2, 2024.
On June 25, 2024, the Oklahoma Supreme Court granted the writ of mandamus and the declaratory relief. 558 P.3d 1. Writing for the majority, Justice James R. Winchester held that the contract violated the Oklahoma Constitution, the Charter Schools Act, and the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. Because state law made St. Isidore a public school, the court reasoned, spending public funds on its operations meant using state money “for the benefit and support of the Catholic church.” That violated the Oklahoma Constitution’s ban on public aid to religion and its requirement that public schools be nonsectarian. The court also held that St. Isidore was a state actor, because it would carry out Oklahoma’s constitutional duty to provide free public education. Its religious instruction would therefore amount to the government establishing religion. Finally, the court rejected the argument that excluding St. Isidore violated the Free Exercise Clause. It distinguished recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions striking down states’ exclusion of private religious schools from generally available benefits: this case, the court said, involved the state creating and funding a new religious school, not excluding a private religious entity. The court directed the board to rescind its contract with St. Isidore.
Five other justices joined his opinion. Vice Chief Justice Dustin P. Rowe agreed only that the Oklahoma Constitution requires public charter schools to be nonsectarian, and dissented from the rest. Justice Dana Kuehn dissented. She would have held that St. Isidore would not become a state actor merely by contracting with the state, and that excluding religious organizations from such contracts would violate the Free Exercise Clause. Chief Justice M. John Kane IV recused.
On July 5, 2024, St. Isidore asked the court for a limited stay of its ruling. The court denied the request on August 5, 2024, over Justice Kuehn’s dissent. Meanwhile, on July 1, 2024, a new Statewide Charter School Board took over the duties of the Statewide Virtual Charter School Board under a new state law. On July 30, the Attorney General asked the court to substitute the new board and its members as respondents and to order them to comply with the writ or face contempt. The new board rescinded St. Isidore’s contract at its August 12, 2024 meeting. On September 16, 2024, the court substituted the new board as respondent. It found the contempt request moot because the board had complied. Justice Kuehn concurred in part and dissented in part.
The new board and St. Isidore each asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s decision (Nos. 24-394 and 24-396). The petitions were filed on October 7, 2024. They asked whether a privately run school’s educational choices become state action simply because it contracts with the state to offer a free educational option. They also asked whether a state violates the Free Exercise Clause by excluding privately run religious schools from its charter program solely because they are religious. On January 24, 2025, the Supreme Court agreed to hear both cases and consolidated them. 145 S. Ct. 1134. Justice Amy Coney Barrett took no part. The United States filed an amicus brief supporting the board and St. Isidore, and Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued on their side at oral argument on April 30, 2025. On May 22, 2025, the Court affirmed the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s judgment by an equally divided vote, in a one-sentence unsigned opinion. 605 U.S. 165. The tie left the Oklahoma decision in place but set no nationwide precedent.
The Supreme Court issued its judgment on June 23, 2025, and the Oklahoma Supreme Court received the record back on August 21, 2025. Because the board had rescinded the contract and the appeals were over, nothing remained to litigate.
The case is closed.
Summary Authors
Ian Carley (10/25/2026)
People
Bursch, John J.
Barnard-Yanni, Alyssa Marie
Blackwell, Geoffrey Thomas
Bradley, Gerard V.
Brook, Christopher Anderson
Documents in the Clearinghouse
Resources
Docket
Docket for: Drummond v. Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board
Docket sheet not available via the Clearinghouse.Case Details
State / Territory:
Case Type(s):
Key Dates
Filing Date: Oct. 20, 2023
Closing Date: June 23, 2025
Case Ongoing: No reason to think so
Plaintiffs
Plaintiff Description:
The Attorney General of Oklahoma, suing on behalf of the State of Oklahoma.
Plaintiff Type(s):
Attorney Organizations:
Public Interest Lawyer: Yes
Filed Pro Se: No
Class Action Sought: No
Class Action Outcome: Not sought
Defendants
State
Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board
Defendant Type(s):
Facility Type(s):
Case Details
Causes of Action:
Constitutional Clause(s):
Other Dockets:
Oklahoma state supreme court 121694
Supreme Court of the United States 24-394
Supreme Court of the United States 24-396
Special Case Type(s):
Appellate Court is initial court
Available Documents:
Injunctive (or Injunctive-like) Relief
U.S. Supreme Court merits opinion
Outcome
Prevailing Party: Plaintiff OR Mixed
Relief Sought:
Relief Granted:
Injunction / Injunctive-like Settlement
Source of Relief:
Order Duration: 2024 - 2024
Issues
General/Misc.:
Public benefits (includes, e.g., in-state tuition, govt. jobs)
Discrimination Basis:
Affected Religion(s):
Case Summary of Drummond v. Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board, Civil Rights Litig. Clearinghouse, https://clearinghouse.net/case/45802/ (last updated 10/25/2026).