Case: Hope v. Pelzer

2:96-cv-02968 | U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama

Filed Date: Nov. 14, 1996

Closed Date: 2005

Clearinghouse coding complete

Case Summary

On November 14, 1996, a prisoner in Alabama's Limestone Correctional Facility, represented by private counsel, filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama seeking damages under 42 U.S.C. §1983. The plaintiff complained that he had been subjected to cruel and unusual punishment, and to due process violations by the defendant correctional officers. According to the complaint, defendants handcuffed plaintiff to a hitching post, an outdoor restrainin…

On November 14, 1996, a prisoner in Alabama's Limestone Correctional Facility, represented by private counsel, filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama seeking damages under 42 U.S.C. §1983. The plaintiff complained that he had been subjected to cruel and unusual punishment, and to due process violations by the defendant correctional officers. According to the complaint, defendants handcuffed plaintiff to a hitching post, an outdoor restraining bar, in the sun, with little water and irregular bathroom breaks, causing him physical injury (sunburn, chafing, muscle strain and dehydration) and mental trauma and emotional distress. After the parties filed sworn affidavits and reports at the court's request, the case was dismissed on March 24, 2000, by U.S. District Judge H. Dean Buttram, who adopted the March 10, 2000, Report and Recommendation of U.S. Magistrate Judge John E. Ott. Judge Ott had found that the defendants had qualified immunity for their conduct. (The District Court did not address the due process claim, as the plaintiff had not signed that portion of his pleadings.)

Plaintiff appealed to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, which affirmed the dismissal on qualified immunity grounds on February 2, 2001; however, reaching the constitutional question, the appellate opinion also found that the defendants' conduct did violate the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment to the extent that the period of restraint, without regular water and restroom breaks, exceeded the time "required to address an immediate threat or danger." Hope v. Pelzer, 240 F. 3d 975, 982 (11th Cir. 2001) (Judge Stanley F. Birch, Jr.).

On January 2, 2002, the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari. Hope v. Pelzer, 534 U.S. 1120 (2002). The ACLU, the United States and several states filed amici curiae briefs on the merits. The Supreme Court issued its decision on June 27, 2002. In an opinion by Justice John Paul Stevens, the Court held that the prison guards' handcuffing of an already-subdued plaintiff to the hitching post subjected him to cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment, and that the state prison guards were not shielded by qualified immunity, given the existence of binding Eleventh Circuit precedent, of their state correctional department's applicable regulation, and of a prior Department of Justice report informing the corrections department of constitutional infirmity in its use of the hitching post. Hope v. Pelzer, 536 U.S. 730 (2002). Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justice Antonin Scalia, dissented.

Subsequently, on August 20, 2004, plaintiff's counsel filed an amended complaint in the District Court , which sought (1) a declaratory judgment that the defendants' conduct violated the plaintiff's rights under the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, (2) a permanent injunction to preclude future similar violations, (3) compensatory, punitive and nominal damages, and (4) payment (pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §1988) of plaintiff's attorneys' fees and reasonable expenses. After a hearing, a defense motion for summary judgment was denied by the District Court (Judge Karon Owen Bowdre) on September 28, 2005. In her Order, Judge Bowdre ruled that the plaintiff's request for declaratory and injunctive relief had been mooted, but the damages and individual liability claims still raised disputed questions of fact.

On November 8, 2005, after the plaintiff completed his case in chief at trial, Judge Bowdre granted the defendants' motion for judgment as a matter of law, ruling that individual liability of the three named defendants had not been proven, given that no evidence established that any defendant acted with deliberate indifference or was aware of a substantial risk of serious harm.

Summary Authors

Mike Fagan (4/8/2008)

People

For PACER's information on parties and their attorneys, see: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/5308738/parties/hope-v-pelzer/


Judge(s)

Birch, Stanley F. Jr. (Georgia)

Bowdre, Karon O. (Alabama)

Breyer, Stephen Gerald (District of Columbia)

Buttram, H. Dean Jr. (Alabama)

Attorney for Plaintiff
Attorney for Defendant
Expert/Monitor/Master/Other

Brown, Mark R. (Ohio)

Documents in the Clearinghouse

Documents in this case

01-00309

Supreme Court Docket

Supreme Court of the United States

March 21, 2002

March 21, 2002

Docket

00-12150

USCA Docket (PACER)

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Oct. 15, 2002

Oct. 15, 2002

Docket

2:96-cv-02968

Docket (PACER)

Hope, et al v. Pelzer, et al

May 4, 2006

May 4, 2006

Docket
47

2:96-cv-02968

Memorandum Opinion [Re: Dismissal]

March 24, 2000

March 24, 2000

Order/Opinion

2000 WL 35501948

00-12150

[Order Affirming District Court]

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Feb. 2, 2001

Feb. 2, 2001

Order/Opinion

240 F.3d 975

01-00309

Granting Writ of Certiorari

Supreme Court of the United States

Jan. 4, 2002

Jan. 4, 2002

Order/Opinion

534 U.S. 1073

00-12150

Amended Grant of Writ of Certiorari

Supreme Court of the United States

Jan. 29, 2002

Jan. 29, 2002

Order/Opinion

534 U.S. 1120

01-00309

[Opinion]

Supreme Court of the United States

June 27, 2002

June 27, 2002

Order/Opinion

536 U.S. 730

00-12150

[Order]

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Sept. 12, 2002

Sept. 12, 2002

Order/Opinion

304 F.3d 1331

77

2:96-cv-02968

Amended and Substituted Complaint and Jury Demand

Larry Hope v. Mark Pelzer, Keith Gates, and and Gene McClaran

Aug. 20, 2004

Aug. 20, 2004

Complaint

Resources

Docket

See docket on RECAP: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/5308738/hope-v-pelzer/

Last updated Oct. 29, 2026, 5:20 p.m.

Docket for: Hope v. Pelzer
ECF Number Date Description Link
1 Nov. 14, 1996

COMPLAINT filed (referred to Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) (SRJ) (Entered: 11/14/1996)

RECAP
2 Nov. 14, 1996

DECLARATION by plaintiff Larry Hope in support of request to proceed in forma pauperis filed (SRJ) Modified on 11/14/1996 (Entered: 11/14/1996)

RECAP
3 Nov. 21, 1996

ORDER that the pla shall submit partial payments until the $120.00 filing fee is paid in full filed ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (KAM) (Entered: 11/21/1996)

RECAP
Dec. 11, 1996

Filing Fee Received

Dec. 11, 1996

FILING FEE paid: on 12/9/96 in the amount of $ 13.3 receipt # 200 108111. (KAM)

4 Dec. 31, 1996

ORDER ( Special Report) ; dft to file a special report by 3/3/97 as set out in this order filed ( Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm with complaint attached (CJV) (Entered: 12/31/1996)

RECAP
5 Jan. 7, 1997

ORDER that the pla has paid a partial filing fee in the amount of $13.30; the warden shall deduct from the pla's account until the $120 filing fee is paid in full filed ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (KAM) (Entered: 01/07/1997)

RECAP
Jan. 9, 1997

Filing Fee Received

Jan. 9, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 1/8/97 in the amount of $ .30 receipt # 200 108786. (KAM)

Feb. 10, 1997

Filing Fee Received

Feb. 10, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 2/7/97 in the amount of $ 3.3 receipt # 200 109612. (KAM)

6 Feb. 19, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope to supplement record to include photographs filed (KAM) (Entered: 02/19/1997)

RECAP
7 Feb. 25, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope to supplement [7-1] filed (KAM) (Entered: 02/25/1997)

RECAP
8 Feb. 27, 1997

MOTION by defendant Mark Pelzer, defendant McClaran, defendant Kent, defendant MaGuee, defendant Laugan, defendant Gates, defendant Jackson, defendant Stephen to extend time to answer by 20 days filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 02/27/1997)

RECAP
9 Feb. 28, 1997

8 - ORDER granting motion to extend time to answer by 20 days [8-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 03/03/1997)

RECAP
10 March 10, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope to compel medical records filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 03/11/1997)

RECAP
March 10, 1997

Filing Fee Received

March 10, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 3/10/97 in the amount of $ .30 receipt # 200 110435. (KAM)

11 March 24, 1997

SPECIAL report by defendant Mark Pelzer, defendant McClaran, defendant MaGuee, defendant Gates, defendant Jackson, defendant Stephen filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 03/25/1997)

RECAP
12 April 7, 1997

10 - ORDER denying motion to compel medical records [10-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 04/09/1997)

RECAP
13 April 7, 1997

6 - ORDER granting motion to supplement record to include photographs [6-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 04/09/1997)

RECAP
14 April 7, 1997

7 - ORDER granting motion to supplement [7-1] [7-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 04/09/1997)

RECAP
15 April 9, 1997

ORDER that counsel for the DOC shall within 20 days inform th ecourt whether Officers Kent and Loggins continue to be employed by DOC filed ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (KAM) (Entered: 04/09/1997)

RECAP
April 14, 1997

Filing Fee Received

April 14, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 4/14/97 in the amount of $ .30 receipt # 200 111440. (KAM)

16 April 24, 1997

RESPONSE by defendant order [15-1] filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 04/24/1997)

RECAP
17 April 24, 1997

SPECIAL report by defendant Kent filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 04/24/1997)

RECAP
18 May 6, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope for entry of default as to Kent, Laugan filed (KAM) (Entered: 05/07/1997)

RECAP
May 6, 1997

Filing Fee Received

May 6, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 5/6/97 in the amount of $ .30 receipt # 200 112076. (KAM)

19 May 20, 1997

18 - ORDER denying plff's motion for entry of default as to Kent, Laugan [18-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 05/21/1997)

RECAP
20 May 21, 1997

ORDER that Clerk is directed to send copy of court's order for special report to Ted Loggins; dft Loggins to respond within 30 days filed ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 05/21/1997)

RECAP
June 11, 1997

Filing Fee Received

June 11, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 6/11/97 in the amountof $3.30 receipt #200113097. (Former Employee)

21 June 26, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope for entry of default as to Mark Pelzer filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 06/27/1997)

RECAP
July 14, 1997

Filing Fee Received

July 14, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 7/14/97 in the amount of $ 3.30 receipt # 200 114036. (KAM)

22 July 22, 1997

ORDER denying motion for entry of default as to Mark Pelzer [21-1]; the clerk is directed to issue summons to dft Ted Loggins filed ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 07/22/1997)

RECAP
July 22, 1997

Summons Issued

July 22, 1997

SUMMONS and complaint issued to dft Ted Loggins, c/o Beasley Produce, South Marion Street, Athens, AL 35611; mailed cert mail, return receipt requested per order [doc 22] (Former Employee)

23 July 24, 1997

SUMMONS and complaint returned executed: upon defendant Laugan (Ted Loggins) on 7/23/97 filed (Former Employee) (Entered: 07/24/1997)

RECAP
Aug. 6, 1997

Filing Fee Received

Aug. 6, 1997

FILING FEE paid: on 8/6/97 in the amount of $ 3.30 receipt # 200 114844. (KAM)

24 Aug. 13, 1997

NOTICE by plaintiff Larry Hope of change of address filed (KAM) (Entered: 08/14/1997)

RECAP
25 Aug. 21, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope for entry of default as to Laugan filed (KAM) (Entered: 08/25/1997)

RECAP
26 Sept. 2, 1997

SPECIAL report (supplemental) by defendant Laugan filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 09/03/1997)

RECAP
27 Oct. 14, 1997

25 - ORDER denying motion for entry of default as to Laugan [25-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 10/15/1997)

RECAP
28 Oct. 14, 1997

ORDER that dfts' special report will be treated as a motion for summary judgment: plff is afforded 20 days to respond in accordance w/provision of Rule 56, filed ( Magistrate-Judge T M. Putnam ) cm (KAM) (Entered: 10/15/1997)

RECAP
29 Oct. 17, 1997

NOTICE of appearance for plaintiff Larry Hope by James Alan Mendelsohn filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 10/21/1997)

RECAP
30 Oct. 17, 1997

RESPONSE by plaintiff Larry Hope special report [26-1] filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 10/21/1997)

RECAP
31 Oct. 17, 1997

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope for attorney Craig T. Jones to appear pro hac vice filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 10/21/1997)

RECAP
Oct. 22, 1997

PHV Fee Paid

Oct. 22, 1997

PRO HAC VICE admission fee paid on 10/22/97 receipt # 200 118961 in the amount of $50.00 (KAM)

32 Nov. 3, 1997

AFFIDAVIT of Larry Hope filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 11/03/1997)

RECAP
33 Nov. 3, 1997

RESPONSE by plaintiff Larry Hope special report [26-1] filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 11/03/1997)

RECAP
34 Nov. 5, 1997

31 - ORDER granting motion for attorney Craig T. Jones to appear pro hac vice [31-1] ( by Judge Sharon L. Blackburn ) entered cm (KAM) (Entered: 11/05/1997)

RECAP
April 10, 1998

Order

April 10, 1998

DOCKET modification (utility event) Case referred to Magistrate-Judge John E. Ott (Former Employee)

35 Nov. 19, 1998

NOTICE of reassignment Case reassigned to Judge H D. Buttram cm (KAM) (Entered: 11/19/1998)

RECAP
37 Feb. 19, 1999

RESPONSE by defendant order [36-1] filed cs (Former Employee) (Entered: 02/22/1999)

RECAP
36 Feb. 22, 1999

ORDER dfts 10 days to file briefs in support of motions for sumjgm; plas 10 days to respond; thereafter motions will be deemed submitted filed ( by Magistrate-Judge John E. Ott ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 02/22/1999)

RECAP
38 Nov. 26, 1999

BRIEF by plaintiff Larry Hope in opposition to dft's motoin for summary judgment filed cs (KAM) (Entered: 11/29/1999)

RECAP
39 Dec. 29, 1999

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope to stay filed cs (Former Employee) (Entered: 12/29/1999)

RECAP
40 Dec. 29, 1999

BRIEF in support of motion to stay by plaintiff Larry Hope filed cs (Former Employee) (Entered: 12/29/1999)

RECAP
41 March 8, 2000

COMPLAINT (amended-supplemental) deemed filed 2/10/97 filed (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/08/2000)

RECAP
42 March 8, 2000

BRIEF (supplemental) in opposition to summary judgment by plaintiff Larry Hope deemed filed 12/29/97 filed cs (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/08/2000)

RECAP
43 March 8, 2000

BRIEF (second supplemental) in oppoosition to dfts' motion for summary judgment by plaintiff Larry Hope deemed filed 3/1/99 filed cs (Former Employee) Modified on 03/08/2000 (Entered: 03/08/2000)

RECAP
44 March 10, 2000

39 - ORDER denying motion to stay [39-1] ( by Magistrate-Judge John E. Ott ) entered cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/10/2000)

RECAP
45 March 10, 2000

Report and Recommendation that dfts' special reports be treated as motions for sumjgm that motions be granted and this action is dismissed w/prejudice; objs w/in 10 days filed ( by Magistrate-Judge John E. Ott ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/10/2000)

RECAP
46 March 20, 2000

OBJECTIONS by plaintiff Larry Hope to [45-1] filed cs w/exhibits attached (KAM) (Entered: 03/20/2000)

RECAP
47 March 24, 2000

MEMORANDUM opinion filed ( by Judge H D. Buttram ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/24/2000)

RECAP
48 March 24, 2000

ORDER in accordance w/the memorandum entered contemporaneously herewith [47-1], adopting Report and Recommendation that dfts' special reports be treated as motions for sumjgm that motions be granted and this action is dismissed w/prejudice; costs taxed to pla and as further set out in this order [45-1] terminating case as set out in this order filed ( by Judge H D. Buttram ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 03/24/2000)

RECAP
49 April 24, 2000

NOTICE of appeal by plaintiff Larry Hope from District Court decision [48-2] ; notice of appeal, order appealed from and court copy of docket entries w/transmittal letter mailed cm (KAM) (Entered: 04/25/2000)

RECAP
April 24, 2000

USCA Appeal Fees

April 24, 2000

APPEAL fee received in amount of $ 105.00 rec # 200 150148 (KAM)

May 2, 2000

USCA Case Number

May 2, 2000

NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate docket number 00-12150DD (Former Employee)

May 10, 2000

USCA Appeal Fees

May 10, 2000

APPEAL fee received in amount of $ 105.00 filing fee and $25.00 return check (Former Employee)

50 May 26, 2000

ORDER that pla was permitted to proceed w/o prepayment of entire filing fee; pla has paid entire appellate filing fee of $105.00; consequently provisions of 28:1915(a)(3) and FRAP 24(a) do not apply and no dterminatino as to whether his appeal is taken in good faith is required and as further set out in this order filed ( by Judge H D. Buttram ) cm (Former Employee) (Entered: 05/26/2000)

RECAP
July 11, 2000

Appeal Record Sent to USCA

July 11, 2000

CERTIFICATE of readiness issued cm (Former Employee)

July 11, 2000

USCA Notice of Docketing ROA

July 11, 2000

CERTIFIED record on appeal with certified copy of docket entries and transmittal mailed USCA cm (Former Employee)

51 May 17, 2001

CERTIFIED copy of Appellate Court order: affirming the decision of the District Court [49-1] filed (Former Employee) (Entered: 05/17/2001)

RECAP
March 13, 2002

Appeal Record Sent to USCA

March 13, 2002

ORIGINAL court file mailed to U. S. Supreme Court with certified copy of docket entries cm (Former Employee)

52 Sept. 17, 2002

NOTICE of reassignment Case assigned to Judge Karon O. Bowdre cm (MAA) (Entered: 10/17/2002)

RECAP
53 Oct. 17, 2002

CERTIFIED copy of Appellate Court order: reversing and remanding the decision of the District Court [Appeal [0-0] issued as mandate 10/15/02 with memorandum opinion consistent with the Supreme Court's opinion attached Judges Tjoflat, Birch and Vining filed (MAA) (Entered: 10/17/2002)

RECAP
Oct. 17, 2002

Order

Oct. 17, 2002

DOCKET modification (utility event) Case reopened (MAA)

Nov. 26, 2002

USCA Notice of Docketing Record on Appeal

Nov. 26, 2002

Original APPEAL Record returned by US Supreme Court; 1 vol pldgs, 1 exp folder (KWC) Modified on 11/27/2002

54 Dec. 2, 2002

ORDER Joint status rpt (Notice of Compliance) ddl 4:30 1/6/03 as set out filed ( by Judge Karon O. Bowdre ) cm (KWC) (Entered: 12/02/2002)

RECAP
55 Jan. 6, 2003

Joint status rpt, NOTICE of compliance by plaintiff, defendant with [54-1] filed cs (KWC) (Entered: 01/06/2003)

RECAP
56 Jan. 7, 2003

ORDER staying case for 90 days pla counsel is ordered to rport status of McDonald court's decision as soon as ruling is issued, or w/in 90 days, whichever is sooner; filed ( by Judge Karon O. Bowdre ) cm (KWC) (Entered: 01/07/2003)

RECAP
57 April 24, 2003

MOTION by plaintiff Larry Hope for order for leave of absence for atty Craig T Jones from 07/28/03 - 08/08/03 filed cs (KWC) (Entered: 04/24/2003)

RECAP
58 April 28, 2003

ORDER to show cause-plaintiff is ordered to SHOW CAUSE why this case should not be dismissed for failure to comply with this court's Order filed ( by Judge Karon O. Bowdre ) cm (KSS) (Entered: 04/28/2003)

RECAP
59 May 2, 2003

RESPONSE by plaintiff Larry Hope to show cause order [58-1] filed cs (KWC) (Entered: 05/02/2003)

RECAP
Oct. 20, 2003

Order

Case Details

State / Territory:

Alabama

Case Type(s):

Prison Conditions

Special Collection(s):

Multi-LexSum (in sample)

Key Dates

Filing Date: Nov. 14, 1996

Closing Date: 2005

Case Ongoing: No

Plaintiffs

Plaintiff Description:

Prisoner who was detained at Limestone Correctional Facility and was subjected to abuse by their staff, including being handcuffed to a hitching post with no water or bathroom breaks for several hours.

Public Interest Lawyer: Yes

Filed Pro Se: Yes

Class Action Sought: No

Class Action Outcome: Not sought

Defendants

State

Alabama Department of Corrections

Limestone Correctional Facility in the Northern District of Alabama

Facility Type(s):

Government-run

Case Details

Causes of Action:

42 U.S.C. § 1983

Constitutional Clause(s):

Cruel and Unusual Punishment

Due Process

Other Dockets:

Northern District of Alabama 2:96-cv-02968

Supreme Court of the United States 01-309

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit 00-12150

Available Documents:

Any published opinion

Complaint (any)

Trial Court Docket

U.S. Supreme Court merits opinion

Outcome

Prevailing Party: Defendant

Relief Granted:

None

Source of Relief:

None

Issues

General/Misc.:

Assault/abuse by staff

Disciplinary procedures

Affected Sex/Gender(s):

Male

Jails, Prisons, Detention Centers, and Other Institutions:

Assault/abuse by non-staff (facilities)

Assault/abuse by staff (facilities)

Restraints (physical)

Recommended Citation