Case: Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. EPA

Commonwealth of Massachusetts et al. v. EPA et al.

PETITION FOR REVIEW [2164582] of a decision by federal agency filed by City and County of Denver Colorado, City and County of San Francisco, California, City of Albuquerque, New Mexico, City of Boston, Massachusetts, City of Chicago, Illinois, City of Cleveland, Ohio, City of Columbus, Ohio, City of Los Angeles, California, City of New York, New York, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Virginia, DC, Harris County, Texas, Martin Luther King Jr. County, Washington, Santa Clara County, California, Josh Shapiro, State of Arizona, State of California, State of Colorado, State of Connecticut, State of Delaware, State of Hawaii, State of Illinois, State of Maine, State of Maryland, State of Michigan, State of Minnesota, State of Nevada, State of New Jersey, State of New Mexico, State of New York, State of North Carolina, State of Oregon, State of Rhode Island, State of Vermont, State of Washington, State of Wisconsin and Virgin Islands [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] Disclosure Statement: Not Applicable to this Party. [26-1061] [Entered: 03/20/2026 09:09 AM]

PETITION FOR REVIEW CASE docketed. [26-1061] [Entered: 03/20/2026 08:29 AM]

CERTIFIED COPY [2164583] of Petition for Review sent to respondent [2164582-2] [26-1061] [Entered: 03/20/2026 09:11 AM]

LETTER [2164585] sent regarding attorney membership to Richard N. Coglianese for City of Columbus, Ohio, K. Brunetti Ireland for State of Nevada and Christopher Sanders for Martin Luther King Jr. County, Washington. Application for Admission due 04/20/2026. [26-1061] [Entered: 03/20/2026 09:15 AM]

CLERK'S ORDER [2164588] filed consolidating cases 26-1061 (Consolidation started 03/20/2026) with 26-1037; directing party to file in 26-1061 initial submissions: PETITIONER docketing statement due 04/20/2026. PETITIONER statement of issues due 04/20/2026 [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 03/20/2026 09:18 AM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2164657] filed by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club, Union of Concerned Scientists and Conservation Law Foundation [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/20/2026 12:16 PM]

CERTIFICATE AS TO PARTIES, RULINGS AND RELATED CASES [2164659] filed by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club and Union of Concerned Scientists [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/20/2026 12:18 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2164663] filed by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club and Union of Concerned Scientists [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/20/2026 12:20 PM]

UNDERLYING DECISION IN CASE [2164669] submitted by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club and Union of Concerned Scientists [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/20/2026 12:38 PM]

CONSENT STATEMENT OF INTENT REGARDING APPENDIX DEFERRAL [2164674] filed by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club and Union of Concerned Scientists [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] Intent: AppxDeferred [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/20/2026 12:40 PM]

MOTION [2164718] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by Truck and Engine Manufacturers Association [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061]--[Edited 03/20/2026 by FAW] (Wehrum, William) [Entered: 03/20/2026 02:18 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2164721] filed by Frank D. Garrison and co-counsel Tyler Fry on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent Domestic Energy Producers Alliance in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Garrison, Frank) [Entered: 03/20/2026 02:20 PM]

MOTION [2164781] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Not Attached] filed by National Federation of Independent Business, American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce, and the Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Missouri, North Dakota, and Tennessee Corn Growers Associations [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061]--[Edited 03/23/2026 by FAW] (Buschbacher, Michael) [Entered: 03/20/2026 04:02 PM]

MOTION [2164792] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by NACCO Natural Resources Corporation [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061]--[Edited 03/23/2026 by FAW] (Lucas, Brinton) [Entered: 03/20/2026 04:43 PM]

MOTION [2164799] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by CO2 Coalition [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061]--[Edited 03/23/2026 by FAW] (Grossman, Andrew) [Entered: 03/20/2026 05:09 PM]

MOTION [2164843] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by American Petroleum Institute [Service Date: 03/20/2026 ] [26-1037]--[Edited 03/23/2026 by FAW] (Clement, Paul) [Entered: 03/20/2026 09:39 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2165032] filed by Brinton Lucas and co-counsel S. Matthew Krsacok; Jeffrey D. Ubersax on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent NACCO Natural Resources Corporation in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Lucas, Brinton) [Entered: 03/23/2026 01:39 PM]

RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION [2165141] to motion to extend time [2163614-2] filed by EPA and Lee M. Zeldin in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061 [Service Date: 03/23/2026 by CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 976 words. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Chen, Sue) [Entered: 03/23/2026 06:02 PM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2165170] filed by J.G., C.E., E.S., J.K., L.D. and R.D., L.R.F., Ariela Lara, Linnea Lentfer, M.B., M.D., Katherine McIntosh, N.G., N.N., Taylin Nishida, Elena Venner, Emma Weibel and Maya Williams in 26-1038 [Service Date: 03/23/2026 ] [26-1038, 26-1037, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Olson, Julia) [Entered: 03/23/2026 10:51 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2165173] filed by C.E., E.S., J.G., J.K., L.D. and R.D., L.R.F., Ariela Lara, Linnea Lentfer, M.B., M.D., N.G., N.N., Taylin Nishida, Elena Venner, Emma Weibel, Maya Williams and Katherine McIntosh in 26-1038 [Service Date: 03/23/2026 ] [26-1038, 26-1037, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Olson, Julia) [Entered: 03/23/2026 11:05 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2165638] filed by Meghan Greenfield and co-counsel Elizabeth Deutsch, Elizabeth Starr, Maura Smyles on behalf of Petitioner Business Climate Initiative Action in 26-1039. [26-1037, 26-1039] (Greenfield, Meghan) [Entered: 03/25/2026 04:25 PM]

NOTICE [2165643] to change party information filed by Business Climate Initiative Action in 26-1039 [Service Date: 03/25/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1039] (Greenfield, Meghan) [Entered: 03/25/2026 04:47 PM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2165648] filed by Business Climate Initiative Action in 26-1039 [Service Date: 03/25/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1039] (Greenfield, Meghan) [Entered: 03/25/2026 04:59 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2165653] filed by Business Climate Initiative Action in 26-1039 [Service Date: 03/25/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1039] (Greenfield, Meghan) [Entered: 03/25/2026 05:18 PM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2165996] filed by Metropolitan Congregations United for St. Louis and Missouri Coalition for the Environment in 26-1043 [Service Date: 03/27/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1043] (Morrison, Bruce) [Entered: 03/27/2026 04:42 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2165999] filed by Metropolitan Congregations United for St. Louis and Missouri Coalition for the Environment in 26-1043 [Service Date: 03/27/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1043] (Morrison, Bruce) [Entered: 03/27/2026 04:44 PM]

NOTICE [2166199] Notice of Consent to Extension Motion filed by Elena Venner, E.S., C.E., J.G., J.K., L.D. and R.D., L.R.F., Ariela Lara, Linnea Lentfer, M.B., M.D., Katherine McIntosh, N.G., N.N., Taylin Nishida, Emma Weibel and Maya Williams in 26-1038 [Service Date: 03/30/2026 ] [26-1038, 26-1037, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Nicholson, Haley) [Entered: 03/30/2026 05:00 PM]

REPLY [2166208] filed by American Public Health Association, Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club and Union of Concerned Scientists to response [2165141-2] [Service Date: 03/30/2026 by Email, CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 1,598 words. [26-1037] (Kolman, Chloe) [Entered: 03/30/2026 06:32 PM]

MOTION [2166511] for leave to file reply filed by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 (Service Date: 04/01/2026 by CM/ECF NDA, Clerk) Length Certification: 1 page. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/01/2026 10:58 AM]

CORRECTED REPLY [2166515] lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 to response [2163207-2] [Service Date: 04/01/2026 by Clerk, CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 8 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/01/2026 11:03 AM]

MOTION [2166517] for summary judgment lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 (Service Date: 04/01/2026 by CM/ECF NDA, Clerk) Length Certification: 7 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/01/2026 11:07 AM]

SUPPLEMENT [2166520] to motion for judicial notice [2164059-2] lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 [Service Date: 04/01/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/01/2026 11:13 AM]

CLERK'S ORDER [2166312] filed granting motion to participate as amicus curiae [2164476-2] in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051; The Clerk is directed to file Amicus brief [2164479-2] in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051 [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 03/31/2026 01:03 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2166467] filed by Paul D. Clement and co-counsel Danielle R. Sassoon and Nicholas A. Aquart on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent American Petroleum Institute in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] (Clement, Paul) [Entered: 03/31/2026 10:55 PM]

NOTICE [2166519] lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 [Service Date: 04/01/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/01/2026 11:09 AM]

MOTION [2166704] for leave to file amicus brief filed by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 (Service Date: 04/02/2026 by CM/ECF NDA, Clerk) Length Certification: 5 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/02/2026 09:30 AM]

AMICUS FOR RESPONDENT BRIEF [2166706] lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 [Service Date: 04/02/2026 ] Length of Brief: 109 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/02/2026 09:37 AM]

MOTION [2166708] for summary disposition correcting motion for summary judgment lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 (Service Date: 04/02/2026 by CM/ECF NDA, Clerk) Length Certification: 8 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/02/2026 09:40 AM]

PER ABOVE ORDER lodged Amicus brief [2164479-2] is filed [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 03/31/2026 01:11 PM]

NOTICE [2167713] lodged by John Worthington in 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043 [Service Date: 04/09/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061] [Entered: 04/09/2026 09:33 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2167439] filed by K. Brunetti Ireland on behalf of Petitioner State of Nevada in 26-1061. [26-1061, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051] (Ireland, Kiel) [Entered: 04/07/2026 12:46 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2167812] filed by Hadley Tuthill on behalf of Petitioner State of Michigan in 26-1061. [26-1061, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051] (Tuthill, Hadley) [Entered: 04/09/2026 03:38 PM]

CLERK'S ORDER [2168319] filed consolidating cases 26-1083 (Consolidation started 04/13/2026) with 26-1037; directing party to file initial submissions: PETITIONER docketing statement due 05/13/2026. PETITIONER statement of issues due 05/13/2026 [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] [Entered: 04/13/2026 01:11 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168412] filed by William Seidleck on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent State of Missouri. [26-1037] (Seidleck, William) [Entered: 04/13/2026 04:13 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168421] filed by Graham Miller on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent State of Missouri. [26-1037] (Miller, Graham) [Entered: 04/13/2026 04:31 PM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2168428] filed by Service Employees International Union in 26-1051 [Service Date: 04/13/2026 ] [26-1051, 26-1037] (Hoshijima, Tsuki) [Entered: 04/13/2026 04:41 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2168429] filed by Service Employees International Union in 26-1051 [Service Date: 04/13/2026 ] [26-1051, 26-1037] (Hoshijima, Tsuki) [Entered: 04/13/2026 04:42 PM]

MOTION [2168454] for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Not Attached] filed by American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers and Energy Marketers of America [Service Date: 04/13/2026 ] [26-1061, 26-1051]--[Edited 04/14/2026 by LMM] (Feith, Daniel) [Entered: 04/13/2026 07:23 PM]

MOTION [2168455] to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by SENATORS TED CRUZ AND CYNTHIA LUMMIS [Service Date: 04/13/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083]--[Edited 04/14/2026 by FAW] (Torchinsky, Jason) [Entered: 04/13/2026 07:37 PM]

AMICUS FOR RESPONDENT FINAL BRIEF [2168456] lodged by SENATORS TED CRUZ AND CYNTHIA LUMMIS [Service Date: 04/13/2026 ] Length of Brief: 3,196 words. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083]--[Edited 04/14/2026 by FAW--MODIFIED EVENT FROM FILED TO LODGED] (Torchinsky, Jason) [Entered: 04/13/2026 07:44 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168591] filed by Daniel J. Feith and co-counsel Justin A. Savage: Kathleen Mueller on behalf of Movant-Intervenors for Respondent American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers and Energy Marketers of America. [26-1061] (Feith, Daniel) [Entered: 04/14/2026 12:35 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168592] filed by Daniel J. Feith and co-counsel Justin A. Savage: Kathleen Mueller on behalf of Movant-Intervenors for Respondent American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers and Energy Marketers of America. [26-1051] (Feith, Daniel) [Entered: 04/14/2026 12:36 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168804] filed by Kristin Brainerd on behalf of Petitioner City and County of Denver, Colorado in 26-1061. [26-1061, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1083] (Brainerd, Kristin) [Entered: 04/15/2026 01:44 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2168950] filed by Richard N. Coglianese on behalf of Petitioner City of Columbus, Ohio. [26-1061] (Coglianese, Richard) [Entered: 04/16/2026 10:12 AM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2169010] filed by City and County of Denver, Colorado, City and County of San Francisco, California, City of Albuquerque, New Mexico, City of Boston, Massachusetts, City of Chicago, Illinois, City of Cleveland, Ohio, City of Columbus, Ohio, City of Los Angeles, California, City of New York, New York, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Virginia, DC, Harris County, Texas, Martin Luther King Jr. County, Washington, Santa Clara County, California, Josh Shapiro, State of Arizona, State of California, State of Colorado, State of Connecticut, State of Delaware, State of Hawaii, State of Illinois, State of Maine, State of Maryland, State of Michigan, State of Minnesota, State of Nevada, State of New Jersey, State of New Mexico, State of New York, State of North Carolina, State of Oregon, State of Rhode Island, State of Vermont, State of Washington, State of Wisconsin and Virgin Islands in 26-1061 [Service Date: 04/16/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Jonas-Day, Julia) [Entered: 04/16/2026 02:02 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2169012] filed by City and County of Denver, Colorado, City and County of San Francisco, California, City of Albuquerque, New Mexico, City of Boston, Massachusetts, City of Chicago, Illinois, City of Cleveland, Ohio, City of Columbus, Ohio, City of Los Angeles, California, City of New York, New York, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Virginia, DC, Harris County, Texas, Martin Luther King Jr. County, Washington, Santa Clara County, California, Josh Shapiro, State of Arizona, State of California, State of Colorado, State of Connecticut, State of Delaware, State of Hawaii, State of Illinois, State of Maine, State of Maryland, State of Michigan, State of Minnesota, State of Nevada, State of New Jersey, State of New Mexico, State of New York, State of North Carolina, State of Oregon, State of Rhode Island, State of Vermont, State of Washington, State of Wisconsin and Virgin Islands in 26-1061 [Service Date: 04/16/2026 ] [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Jonas-Day, Julia) [Entered: 04/16/2026 02:17 PM]

MOTION [2169080] Defer the call for merits briefing until June 4, 2026, pending EPA action on administrative reconsideration petitions. filed by ZETA in 26-1039, Service Employees International Union in 26-1051, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, State of California, State of New York, State of Connecticut, State of Arizona, State of Colorado, State of Delaware, State of Hawaii, State of Illinois, State of Maine, State of Maryland, State of Michigan, State of Minnesota, State of Nevada, State of New Jersey, State of New Mexico, State of North Carolina, State of Oregon, Josh Shapiro, State of Rhode Island, State of Vermont, Commonwealth of Virginia, State of Washington, State of Wisconsin, DC, Virgin Islands, City of Albuquerque, New Mexico, City of Boston, Massachusetts, City of Chicago, Illinois, City of Cleveland, Ohio, City of Columbus, Ohio, City and County of Denver, Colorado, Harris County, Texas, City of Los Angeles, California, Martin Luther King Jr. County, Washington, City of New York, New York, City and County of San Francisco, California and Santa Clara County, California in 26-1061 (Service Date: 04/16/2026 by Email, CM/ECF NDA) Length Certification: 4,314 Words. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Perls, Hannah) [Entered: 04/16/2026 09:52 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169182] filed by Rachel Heron and co-counsel Joseph Brau, Atid B. Kimelman, Gavin G. McCabe, Glenda Valdez, Abirami Vijayan on behalf of Petitioner Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Heron, Rachel) [Entered: 04/17/2026 12:58 PM]

MOTION [2169572] defer call for briefing proposals pending EPA action on administrative petitions, or, in the alternative, to sever issue filed by Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments, American Lung Association, American Public Health Association, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Friends of the Earth, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Physicians for Social Responsibility, Public Citizen, Rio Grande International Study Center, Sierra Club, Union of Concerned Scientists and American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce in 26-1037 (Service Date: 04/20/2026 by Email, CM/ECF NDA) Length Certification: 4,665 words. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] (Heron, Rachel) [Entered: 04/20/2026 06:15 PM]

[VACATED IN PART BY ORDER FILED 4/22/26] CLERK'S ORDER [2169888] filed granting motions for leave to intervene [2162369-2], [2162506-2], [2164415-2], [2164542-2], [2164718-2], [2164781-2], [2164792-2], [2164799-2], [2164843-2] in 26-1037 [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] [Entered: 04/22/2026 03:33 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169901] filed by Michael R. Williams and co-counsel Caleb B. David on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of West Virginia. [26-1037] (David, Caleb) [Entered: 04/22/2026 04:08 PM]

CLERK'S ORDER [2169930] filed, on the court's own motion, that the court's April 22, 2026 order be vacated as to the granting of the motion for leave to intervene filed by movant John Worthington. The Clerk is directed to note the docket accordingly [2169888-2]. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] [Entered: 04/22/2026 05:34 PM]

PER CURIAM ORDER [2169939] filed ORDERED that the motion for leave to file a corrected reply [2166511-2] be granted. The Clerk is directed to file the lodged corrected reply [2166515-2]. It is FURTHER ORDERED that Worthington’s motion for leave to intervene [2162369-2] be denied. It is FURTHER ORDERED that Worthington’s motion to participate as amicus curiae [2162369-2] be denied. It is FURTHER ORDERED that Worthington’s remaining motions for leave to file [2166704-2] & [2164054-2] be denied. It is FURTHER ORDERED that the motion to extend time [2163614-2] be granted. The following deadlines will now apply in these cases: Petitioners’ and Respondents’ Procedural Motions, if any due 05/20/2026. Petitioners’ and Respondents’ Dispositive Motions, if any due 06/04/2026. It is FURTHER ORDERED that the request that the parties file briefing proposals by April 27, 2026 [2165141-2] be denied and the motions to defer [2169572-2] & [2169080-2] be granted to the extent that any order directing the parties to file briefing proposals will be entered after any procedural or dispositive motions are resolved. It is FURTHER ORDERED that the alternative motion to sever [2169572-2] be denied without prejudice. Before Judges: Walker, Childs and Garcia. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] [Entered: 04/22/2026 06:02 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169960] filed by Cristina Stella on behalf of Petitioner Santa Clara County, California. [26-1061] (Stella, Cristina)

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169967] filed by John Henry Thompson on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Georgia. [26-1037] (Thompson, John Henry) [Entered: 04/22/2026 08:41 PM]

PER ABOVE ORDER lodged corrected reply [2166515-2] is filed [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] [Entered: 04/22/2026 06:04 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169991] filed by James A. Barta on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Indiana. [26-1037] (Barta, James) [Entered: 04/23/2026 09:10 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169994] filed by David M.S. Dewhirst on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Florida. [26-1037] (Dewhirst, David) [Entered: 04/23/2026 09:27 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169997] filed by Eric H. Wessan on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Iowa. [26-1037] (Wessan, Eric) [Entered: 04/23/2026 09:54 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2169998] filed by Mathura J. Sridharan on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Ohio. [26-1037] (Sridharan, Mathura) [Entered: 04/23/2026 09:58 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170005] filed by Dwight R. Carswell on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Kansas. [26-1037] (Carswell, Dwight) [Entered: 04/23/2026 10:32 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170006] filed by A. Barrett Bowdre on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Alabama. [26-1037] (Bowdre, Alexander) [Entered: 04/23/2026 10:34 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170007] filed by D. David DeWald on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent State of Wyoming. [26-1037] (DeWald, D.) [Entered: 04/23/2026 10:36 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170015] filed by Michael Buschbacher and co-counsel James R. Conde on behalf of Intervenors for Respondent American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce, National Federation of Independent Business, Illinois Corn Growers Association, Kentucky Corn Growers Association, Missouri Corn Growers Association, Tennessee Corn Growers Association, North Dakota Corn Growers Associations and Iowa Corn Growers Association in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] (Conde, James) [Entered: 04/23/2026 11:04 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170016] filed by Emily M. Greco on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of South Dakota. [26-1037] (Greco, Emily) [Entered: 04/23/2026 11:05 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170018] filed by Justin L. Matheny on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Mississippi. [26-1037] (Matheny, Justin) [Entered: 04/23/2026 11:09 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170026] filed by Wesley S. Williams on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Texas. [26-1037] (Williams, Wesley) [Entered: 04/23/2026 11:53 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170042] filed by Zachary B. Pohlman on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Nebraska. [26-1037] (Pohlman, Zachary) [Entered: 04/23/2026 12:35 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170043] filed by Matthew F. Kuhn and co-counsel John H. Heyburn; Jacob M. Abrahamson on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent Commonwealth of Kentucky. [26-1037] (Abrahamson, Jacob) [Entered: 04/23/2026 12:39 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170047] filed by James Emory Smith, Jr. on behalf of Movant-Intervenor for Respondent State of South Carolina. [26-1037] (Smith, James) [Entered: 04/23/2026 12:49 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170075] filed by Hana V. Vizcarra and co-counsel Amanda Lineberry, Kevin Breiner on behalf of Petitioners Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice, Clean Air Council, Friends of the Earth, Physicians for Social Responsibility, Rio Grande International Study Center and Union of Concerned Scientists in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] (Vizcarra, Hana) [Entered: 04/23/2026 01:34 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170084] filed by Hana V. Vizcarra and co-counsel Amanda Lineberry, Kevin Breiner on behalf of Petitioners Alaska Institute for Justice, Chesapeake Bay Foundation, Chinik Eskimo Community, Native Village of Kwinhagak, Native Village of Nunapitchuk, Northeast Organic Farming Association of New York, WE ACT, West Virginia Highlands Conservancy and Wyoming Outdoor Council in 26-1083. [26-1083, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1090] (Vizcarra, Hana) [Entered: 04/23/2026 01:42 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170300] filed by Zachary R. Clark on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Tennessee in 26-1037. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] (Clark, Zachary) [Entered: 04/24/2026 12:10 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170339] filed by Brian H. Lynk and co-counsel Callie M. Sharp on behalf of Petitioner Environmental Law & Policy Center in 26-1037, Petitioners Hoosier Environmental Council, Illinois Environmental Council, Iowa Environmental Council, Minnesota Environmental Partnership and Ohio Environmental Council in 26-1083. [26-1037, 26-1083] (Lynk, Brian) [Entered: 04/24/2026 01:38 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170342] filed by Jenna Lorence on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Alaska. [26-1037] (Lorence, Jenna) [Entered: 04/24/2026 01:47 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170347] filed by Garry M. Gaskins, II and co-counsel Jennifer Lewis on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Oklahoma. [26-1037] (Gaskins, Garry) [Entered: 04/24/2026 02:00 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170447] filed by Andrea K. Rodgers on behalf of Petitioners C.E., E.S., J.G., J.K., L.D. and R.D., L.R.F., Ariela Lara, Linnea Lentfer, Maya Williams, Taylin Nishida, M.B., M.D., Katherine McIntosh, N.G., N.N., Emma Weibel and Elena Venner. [26-1038] (Rodgers, Andrea) [Entered: 04/24/2026 05:21 PM]

RESPONSE [2170630] to motion for other relief [2169080-2] lodged by John Worthington [Service Date: 04/27/2026 by CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 6 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090]--[Edited 04/28/2026 by FAW--MODIFIED EVENT FROM FILED TO LODGED] [Entered: 04/27/2026 04:40 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2170557] filed by Michael A. Zarian on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Idaho. [26-1037] (Zarian, Michael) [Entered: 04/27/2026 12:35 PM]

RESPONSE [2170998] to motion for other relief [2169572-2] lodged by John Worthington [Service Date: 04/29/2026 by Clerk, CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 6 pages. [26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083, 26-1090] [Entered: 04/29/2026 11:36 AM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2171134] filed by Erin Doran and co-counsel Tarah Heinzen on behalf of Petitioner Food & Water Watch in 26-1083. [26-1083, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1090] (Doran, Erin) [Entered: 04/29/2026 04:18 PM]

NOTICE [2172681] to withdraw attorney James Matthew Rice who represented State of Tennessee in 26-1037 filed by State of Tennessee [Service Date: 05/11/2026 ] [26-1037] (Rice, James) [Entered: 05/11/2026 10:54 AM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2173222] filed by Alaska Institute for Justice, Chinik Eskimo Community, Native Village of Kwinhagak, Native Village of Nunapitchuk, Northeast Organic Farming Association of New York, West Virginia Highlands Conservancy, Wyoming Outdoor Council, Hoosier Environmental Council, Illinois Environmental Council, Iowa Environmental Council, Minnesota Environmental Partnership, Ohio Environmental Council, Food & Water Watch, Chesapeake Bay Foundation and WE ACT in 26-1083 [Service Date: 05/13/2026 ] [26-1083, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1090] (Vizcarra, Hana) [Entered: 05/13/2026 05:34 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2173225] filed by Alaska Institute for Justice, Chesapeake Bay Foundation, Chinik Eskimo Community, Native Village of Kwinhagak, Native Village of Nunapitchuk, Northeast Organic Farming Association of New York, WE ACT, West Virginia Highlands Conservancy, Wyoming Outdoor Council, Hoosier Environmental Council, Illinois Environmental Council, Iowa Environmental Council, Minnesota Environmental Partnership, Ohio Environmental Council and Food & Water Watch in 26-1083 [Service Date: 05/13/2026 ] [26-1083, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1090] (Vizcarra, Hana) [Entered: 05/13/2026 05:41 PM]

MOTION [2173467] to exceed word limits in motion filed by C.E., E.S., J.G., J.K., L.D. and R.D., L.R.F., Ariela Lara, Linnea Lentfer, M.B., M.D., Katherine McIntosh, N.G., N.N., Taylin Nishida, Elena Venner, Emma Weibel and Maya Williams (Service Date: 05/14/2026 by CM/ECF NDA) Length Certification: 597 Words. [26-1038] (Nicholson, Haley) [Entered: 05/14/2026 04:03 PM]

DOCKETING STATEMENT [2173841] filed by Bay Area Air Quality Management District in 26-1090 [Service Date: 05/18/2026 ] [26-1090, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Jefferson, Jamie) [Entered: 05/18/2026 01:46 PM]

STATEMENT OF ISSUES [2173848] filed by Bay Area Air Quality Management District in 26-1090 [Service Date: 05/18/2026 ] [26-1090, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1061, 26-1083] (Jefferson, Jamie) [Entered: 05/18/2026 01:54 PM]

NOTICE [2173973] to substitute attorney Christopher G. King substituted by Alice R. Baker filed by City of New York, New York in 26-1061 [Service Date: 05/18/2026 ] [26-1061, 26-1037, 26-1038, 26-1039, 26-1043, 26-1051, 26-1083, 26-1090] (Baker, Alice) [Entered: 05/18/2026 08:49 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2174156] filed by Philip Axt on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of North Dakota. [26-1037] (Axt, Philip) [Entered: 05/19/2026 03:38 PM]

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [2174165] filed by Noah P. Watson on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent State of Arkansas. [26-1037] (Watson, Noah) [Entered: 05/19/2026 04:25 PM]