Case: Lopez v. Massachusetts Division of Human Resources

0984-CV-00576 | Massachusetts state trial court

Filed Date: Feb. 11, 2009

Case Ongoing

Clearinghouse coding complete

Case Summary

In this class-action lawsuit filed in Suffolk County Superior Court, a Massachusetts state trial court, several African-American and Hispanic police officers employed throughout Massachusetts alleged that the Massachusetts Human Resources Division engaged in racial discrimination that violated state law in its administration of promotional exams for police sergeants. This case followed a separate (non-class-action) lawsuit, Lopez v. Lawrence ("Lopez I"), filed in the U.S. District Court for the…

In this class-action lawsuit filed in Suffolk County Superior Court, a Massachusetts state trial court, several African-American and Hispanic police officers employed throughout Massachusetts alleged that the Massachusetts Human Resources Division engaged in racial discrimination that violated state law in its administration of promotional exams for police sergeants. This case followed a separate (non-class-action) lawsuit, Lopez v. Lawrence ("Lopez I"), filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts in 2007, where several African-American and Hispanic police officers employed by the Cities of Methuen and Lawrence, Massachusetts brought similar allegations under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1994.

Lopez I: 

In Lopez I, several African-American and Hispanic police officers sued the Massachusetts Human Resources Division (HRD), the HRD’s chief executive in his official capacity and the officers’ employers (various municipalities and the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. Represented by private counsel, the officers brought a disparate impact claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, specifically alleging that the HRD-administered promotional exams had an impermissible disparate impact on the promotion of African-American and Hispanic officers by their employers and lacked a job-related purpose. They also brought claims under Massachusetts state law, and sought declaratory and injunctive relief to address the effects of the examinations on past discrimination, in addition to compensatory damages, including backpay, and attorneys’ fees.  

The state defendants (HRD and its chief executive) moved to dismiss and for summary judgment in the alternative, arguing that Title VII abrogates a state’s sovereign immunity under the Eleventh Amendment of the U.S. Constitution only when the state functions as an employer. Since the officers were employed by the municipalities and MBTA, rather than the HRD, the state defendants contended that they remained immune from suit. The district court judge denied their motion. On interlocutory appeal, however, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reversed, holding that the HRD was not the officers’ employer under Title VII. 588 F.3d 69. Accordingly, the state defendants were dismissed as defendants and, on remand, that case proceeded to go to trial against the municipalities and the MBTA. The District Court determined after a bench trial that the examinations were nevertheless job-related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity; and that the plaintiffs failed to prove that Boston had refused to adopt an alternative employment practice that would have equally or better served its business needs with less disparate impact. 2014 WL 12978866. The First Circuit affirmed this judgment. 823 F.3d 102.  


Lopez II: 

In response, on February 11, 2009, the officers filed this class action lawsuit on behalf of all African-American and Hispanic police officers who are subject to a Massachusetts civil service law against the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and the HRD in Suffolk County Superior Court. Represented by private counsel, the plaintiffs alleged that the HRD engaged in discrimination by administering an examination for promotion to the position of police sergeant that had an adverse and discriminatory impact on African-American and Hispanic candidates and were not valid predictors of job performance, in violation of several state laws. The officers alleged that their municipal employers relied on their ranking by exam results, causing them to be denied promotional opportunities. As a result, they contended, there is a substantial disparity between the number of African-American and Hispanic police sergeants and entry-level police officers. The case was assigned to Associate Justice Thomas E. Connolly.  

In July 2010, the defendants moved to dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction on the basis of the state’s sovereign immunity and, in the alternative, for failure to state a claim. On January 10, 2011, Judge Connolly granted their motion to dismiss on both grounds, without issuing an opinion.  

The officers filed an application for direct appellate review to the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, which was granted on June 23, 2011. Writing for the court, Associate Justice Fernande R. V. Duffly reversed the trial court’s decision on November 9, 2012. 463 Mass. 696. Justice Duffly found that the state and HRD did not have sovereign immunity from the police officers’ claims because the statute prohibiting racial discrimination expressly permitted suit against the state and its agencies. She further determined that the officers’ claim under the statute prohibiting discrimination in terms or conditions by an employer was properly dismissed because neither the state nor the HRD were the officers’ employers; since the officers’ employers, the municipalities and MBTA, were not obliged to rely on the examination when making promotional decisions, Judge Duffly held that they were also not liable. She also held that their claim for aiding and abetting a violation of the statute prohibiting unlawful discrimination was correctly dismissed because the officers did not allege that the municipalities who employed police officers committed distinct underlying acts of discrimination. By contrast, Judge Duffly found that the officers sufficiently alleged that the HRD interfered with their exercise of the right to be free from discrimination in employment because this claim could be established by evidence of disparate impact, and did not require a direct employment relationship. Pursuant to her order, the case was remanded to the Suffolk County Superior Court.  

On September 18, 2013, the court denied the motion by defendants to stay the state court proceedings pending resolution of the parallel federal action, and granted plaintiffs’ motion for class certification for liability purposes only, subject to further consideration if the action reached the stage of remedy. The parties proceeded to engage in discovery for two years, during which the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on February 7, 2014. The parties subsequently filed a joint motion to stay the state court proceedings pending resolution of the parallel federal action, however, on April 2, 2015. The court granted this motion on April 9, 2015, staying all proceedings until December 1, 2015. Subsequently, however, the court granted several joint motions by the parties to stay the proceedings.  

On June 27, 2018, the defendants moved for judgment on the pleadings, contending that the plaintiffs’ discrimination claim was barred under the doctrine of issue preclusion because of the prior decision in the parallel federal action dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims under Massachusetts state law. Justice Robert N. Tochka of the Suffolk County Superior Court granted their motion on January 7, 2019. 

The plaintiffs appealed to the Appeals Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. On July 22, 2020, the panel for the Appeals Court—composed of Associate Justice Mary T. Sullivan, Associate Justice C. Jeffrey Kinder and Associate Justice Sabita Singh—reversed, finding that the application of the issue preclusion doctrine was inappropriate with respect to the plaintiffs’ interference claim.  

On remand, the case was reassigned to Associate Justice of the Superior Court Douglas H. Wilkins on August 3, 2021. Before Justice Wilkins, the parties continued to engage in discovery. The case went to a bench trial limited to liability, which was held in June, July and September of 2022. Justice Wilkins issued a lengthy opinion with respect to liability on October 27, 2022 in which he found that the “[o]verwhelmingly persuasive evidence prove[d] that HRD interfered with the class members’ rights to consideration for promotion to police sergeant without regard to race or national origin,'' in violation of Massachusetts law. On November 3, 2022, Justice Wilkins ordered the parties to exchange proposals regarding injunctive relief and damages. 

On March 10, 2023, the parties had a final pre-trial conference, with a bench trial scheduled for March 30, 2023. This was subsequently canceled and the parties instead had a settlement conference on March 31, 2023. The parties proposed a settlement that awarded the plaintiffs $40,000,000 to resolve all claims brought in this case, with $50,000 to be allocated for incentive awards for named plaintiffs, $300,000 to pay for any disputes involving class members who were left off from the class list, and potential attorneys’ fees and costs to be determined at a final approval hearing. In addition, the settlement stated that defendants would create and administer a new exam for police sergeants that is “developed consistent with generally accepted validation principles,” with the court to determine the level of oversight the plaintiffs would have in the final approval hearing. Any settlement funds left over after distribution would become cy pres funds that the parties would give to selected charitable organizations. 

On May 1, 2023, the plaintiffs moved for final approval of the class settlement. In that motion, they also asked the court to let the plaintiffs’ experts oversee the defendants’ implementation of the new exam. The defendants filed a memorandum in opposition to the plaintiffs’ request for oversight on the same day. Later that month, on May 11, the court approved the class action settlement, finding that the agreement was “fair, adequate and reasonable for the class.” The court denied the plaintiffs’ request for oversight over the exam, holding that it did not have the authority to specify how the defendants should meet their statutory or constitutional obligations. Instead, the court ordered the defendants to provide plaintiffs’ counsel the following documents: job analysis, proposed weights for components of the exam, instruction to question writers, and instructions to subject matter experts. The court also pointed approvingly to portions of the settlement agreement in which the defendants agreed to or proposed various changes to the exam and procedures for creating the new exam. The court also granted attorneys’ fees to plaintiffs’ counsel, resulting in a 20% fee of the fund ($8,000,000), plus $750,000 for litigation costs and fees, for a total award of $8,750,000.  

However, on July 18, 2023, the plaintiffs filed an emergency motion to enforce the settlement agreement and/or for a temporary injunction. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants failed to provide the required documents and refused to allow class members to sit for the new 2023 exam unless they previously signed up for the canceled 2022 exam. The plaintiffs’ sought court enforcement of the May 11, 2023 settlement agreement and/or injunctive relief. Because Justice Wilkins had retired, the case was now heard by Justice Rosemary Connolly. 

On August 10, 2023, Justice Connolly denied the plaintiffs’ emergency motion. As to the required documents, the court concluded that the defendants did not have to provide them until they had finished creating them, which they had not yet done. As to the exam itself, the court found that neither the Settlement Agreement nor the subsequent order mentioned allowing class members to sit for the 2023 test as part of the remedy. Therefore, the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not shown that they were likely to succeed on their claim that the defendants had breached the settlement agreement or the order. 

Four days later, on August 14, the plaintiffs appealed the denial of their motion to the Massachusetts Appeals Court. Later that month, on August 29, the Massachusetts Appeals Court denied the plaintiffs’ petition because they did not meet their burden of showing that Justice Connolly “committed an error of law or abused her discretion when she denied their motion.”

As of November 1, 2023, the case is ongoing. 

Summary Authors

Chris Miller (12/21/2022)

Venesa Haska (11/1/2023)

People


Judge(s)
Attorney for Plaintiff

Adkins, John F. (Massachusetts)

Attorney for Defendant

Ackil, Ann (Massachusetts)

Adkins, J. Mark (Massachusetts)

Alexander, William Clifton (Massachusetts)

Alland, Alexandra B. (Massachusetts)

Expert/Monitor/Master/Other
Attorney for Plaintiff

Adkins, John F. (Massachusetts)

Alperstein, Robin L. (Massachusetts)

Ashkin, Roberta Ellen (Massachusetts)

Baker, Robert B. (Massachusetts)

Ballew, Bryan (Massachusetts)

Barrault, Leah M (Massachusetts)

Benson, William F. (Massachusetts)

Blackman, Duane Gordon (Massachusetts)

Bograd, Louis M (Massachusetts)

Bohenek, Matthew T. (Massachusetts)

Bor-Zale, James (Massachusetts)

Bresnahan, Elizabeth M. (Massachusetts)

Carrieri, Matthew P (Massachusetts)

Carter, Vincent J. (Massachusetts)

Cazort, Brad A. (Massachusetts)

Churchill, Stephen S (Massachusetts)

Cohen, Nadine M. (Massachusetts)

Cooper, Jenny K. (Massachusetts)

Cretcher, Grace Cathryn (Massachusetts)

Daniels, Harry T. (Massachusetts)

Earles, Derrick Glenn (Massachusetts)

Edwards, Flora (Massachusetts)

El-Mallawany, Deana K. (Massachusetts)

Fisher, Nikki J. (Massachusetts)

Gibbons, Thomas James (Massachusetts)

Girardi, Thomas V. (Massachusetts)

Gleason, Jeffrey S. (Massachusetts)

Gunn, W. Howard (Massachusetts)

Hall, Rahsaan D. (Massachusetts)

Harris, John A. (Massachusetts)

Hartzog, Dan M. (Massachusetts)

Heining, Eric A. (Massachusetts)

Hogue, Sharon (Massachusetts)

Jaikumar, Arjun K. (Massachusetts)

Jensen, Keith M. (Massachusetts)

John, Jennifer (Massachusetts)

Johnson, Kari R. (Massachusetts)

Kim, Phillip C (Massachusetts)

Lichten, Harold L. (Massachusetts)

Liss-Riordan, Shannon E. (Massachusetts)

Lue, Yin-Shuan (Massachusetts)

Macris, Aaron (Massachusetts)

Maslow-Armand, Laura (Massachusetts)

McGee, Amanda V. (Massachusetts)

Menken, Bruce Eric (Massachusetts)

Moulton, David I. (Massachusetts)

Nimick, Virginia Jackson (Massachusetts)

Noyes, Christopher R. (Massachusetts)

O'Bryan, Dennis Michael (Massachusetts)

O'Callahan, James G (Massachusetts)

Olshan, Jeffrey (Massachusetts)

Pinnock, Theodore A (Massachusetts)

Pirozzolo, Lisa J. (Massachusetts)

Prussia, Kevin S. (Massachusetts)

Rachal, Doreen M. (Massachusetts)

Reynolds, Alexandra Rueckle (Massachusetts)

Robertson, Paul M. (Massachusetts)

Rodriques, Louis A. (Massachusetts)

Rollins, Rachael S. (Massachusetts)

Rosen, Laurence Matthew (Massachusetts)

Rubin, Zachary L (Massachusetts)

Rutkowski, J. Rheba (Massachusetts)

Schwartz, Joshua B. (Massachusetts)

Sellstrom, Oren M. (Massachusetts)

Selwyn, Mark D. (Massachusetts)

Simpson, Scott (Massachusetts)

Sulman, Joseph L. (Massachusetts)

Todaro, Gerald J. (Massachusetts)

Vititoe, James W. (Massachusetts)

Wakefield, David C (Massachusetts)

Weber, Benjamin (Massachusetts)

Webster, Raquel J. (Massachusetts)

Woodard, Jonathan W. (Massachusetts)

Woodham, Maricia D. (Massachusetts)

Zhu, Ming M (Massachusetts)

Attorney for Defendant

Ackil, Ann (Massachusetts)

Adkins, J. Mark (Massachusetts)

Alexander, William Clifton (Massachusetts)

Alland, Alexandra B. (Massachusetts)

Alvarez, Iraida J. (Massachusetts)

Anderson, Austin W. (Massachusetts)

Arthur, Elizabeth G. (Massachusetts)

Atwood, Gina M. (Massachusetts)

Baker, D. Cameron (Massachusetts)

Balakrishna, Annapurna (Massachusetts)

Barnico, Thomas A. (Massachusetts)

Barry-Smith, Christopher K. (Massachusetts)

Batten, Mark W. (Massachusetts)

Baxley, Franklin L. (Massachusetts)

Beato, Andrew Michael (Massachusetts)

Beauchesne, Dawn M. (Massachusetts)

Bein, Philip Michael (Massachusetts)

Betts, Rebecca A. (Massachusetts)

Blume, Todd M. (Massachusetts)

Bok, Geoffrey R. (Massachusetts)

Bongiorno, Michael G. (Massachusetts)

Bonistalli, John J. (Massachusetts)

Boone, Floyd E. (Massachusetts)

Boscia, John J. (Massachusetts)

Bowers, James M. (Massachusetts)

Boyle, Colin R. (Massachusetts)

Braddy, Lauren Elizabeth (Massachusetts)

Brazier, Alexandra L. (Massachusetts)

Brock, Matthew T. (Massachusetts)

Brown, Daniel C. (Massachusetts)

Brown, Rachel M. (Massachusetts)

Burgess, Brian T. (Massachusetts)

Cahillane, Maurice M. (Massachusetts)

Carlson, C. Michael (Massachusetts)

Carroll, Harry P. (Massachusetts)

Carvalho, Ashley K. (Massachusetts)

Cederbaum, Adam N. (Massachusetts)

Chincheck, Julia A. (Massachusetts)

Chorover, Nora (Massachusetts)

Ciollo, Julie A. (Massachusetts)

Coakley, Martha (Massachusetts)

Coburn, Edward (Massachusetts)

Cohen, Jared B. (Massachusetts)

Colb, Sara A. (Massachusetts)

Cole, Victoria S. (Massachusetts)

Condon, Amy E (Massachusetts)

Cook, Kathryn Rebecca (Massachusetts)

Costello, Thomas H. (Massachusetts)

Courchesne, Christophe G (Massachusetts)

Cournoyer, Madonna E (Massachusetts)

Cray, Pierce O. (Massachusetts)

Cueto, Christopher F. (Massachusetts)

Cullen, Paul T (Massachusetts)

Cullinan, William G. (Massachusetts)

D'Agostino, Richard J. (Massachusetts)

D'Amato, Laura E. (Massachusetts)

Deck, Laura E. (Massachusetts)

deSousa, Lisa C. (Massachusetts)

Dewar, Elizabeth N. (Massachusetts)

DiGangi, Thomas Vincent (Massachusetts)

Dirks, Katherine B. (Massachusetts)

Dollar, Robyn P. (Massachusetts)

Donoghue, Laurence J. (Massachusetts)

Donohue, Thomas R (Massachusetts)

Donovan, Brian M. (Massachusetts)

Doyle, Katharine Isabel (Massachusetts)

Duffy, Conor P. (Massachusetts)

Dundin, Louis M. (Massachusetts)

Early, Shane P. (Massachusetts)

Edwards, Joseph L. (Massachusetts)

Engdahl, Laurie W. (Massachusetts)

Englander, John C. (Massachusetts)

Faillace, Michael Antonio (Massachusetts)

Farmer, Gary Michael (Massachusetts)

Farringer, Craig S. (Massachusetts)

Feiner, Gillian R. (Massachusetts)

Feltner, Jonathan P. (Massachusetts)

Ferrer, Nicole Murati (Massachusetts)

Flowers, Jodi Westbrook (Massachusetts)

Flynn, Jennifer H (Massachusetts)

Foskett, John C. (Massachusetts)

Freeley, Mary B (Massachusetts)

Friedman, David S. (Massachusetts)

Galle, Katherine N. (Massachusetts)

George, William David (Massachusetts)

Geraghty, Peter M. (Massachusetts)

Germano, Michael F. (Massachusetts)

Glasgow, Karen A. (Massachusetts)

Goldsmith, Aaron M. (Massachusetts)

Gordon, Gary D. (Massachusetts)

Gould, Kevin M. (Massachusetts)

Grant, Sheryl F. (Massachusetts)

Greene, Thomas M. (Massachusetts)

Gropman, Elizabeth R. (Massachusetts)

Gurland, Harvey W. (Massachusetts)

Hadas, David (Massachusetts)

Haefele, Robert Turner (Massachusetts)

Hanson, Kirk G. (Massachusetts)

Harrington, Edward P. (Massachusetts)

Harrington, William T. (Massachusetts)

Harris, Mary Jo (Massachusetts)

Head, Carol E. (Massachusetts)

Healey, Maura T. (Massachusetts)

Hernandez, Robert LeRoux (Massachusetts)

Hinkley, Michelle K. (Massachusetts)

Hoblitzell, John D. (Massachusetts)

Hodge, Kay H. (Massachusetts)

Hodges, David Wayne (Massachusetts)

Holland, Robert E. (Massachusetts)

Holland, Lee M. (Massachusetts)

Holstrom, Stephen L. (Massachusetts)

Holtz, Herbert L. (Massachusetts)

Horgan, James J. (Massachusetts)

Hucksam, John Richard (Massachusetts)

Hurld, Christopher S. (Massachusetts)

Iancu, Carol A. (Massachusetts)

Isley, Kate R (Massachusetts)

Jaso, Eric H. (Massachusetts)

Jay, William M. (Massachusetts)

Jenness, Kerry Regan (Massachusetts)

Johnson, Jenifer Lynn (Massachusetts)

Jolly, Joseph H. (Massachusetts)

Joss, Sarah M. (Massachusetts)

Joyce, Austin M. (Massachusetts)

Jr, David Clarke (Massachusetts)

Katz, Scott A. (Massachusetts)

Kaufmann, Aaron D. (Massachusetts)

Kelley, Jean M. (Massachusetts)

Kelly, Sheila Creaton (Massachusetts)

Kendall, Joe (Massachusetts)

Kennedy, Mary J. (Massachusetts)

Kim, Tori T. (Massachusetts)

Kobick, Julia E. (Massachusetts)

Koster, Andrew W. (Massachusetts)

Krim, Eben A. (Massachusetts)

Lagorio, Peter A. (Massachusetts)

LaGrassa, Adam R. (Massachusetts)

Lang, James A (Massachusetts)

Langlais, Alison M. (Massachusetts)

Laurent, Jeremy Saint (Massachusetts)

Leahey, Brian W. (Massachusetts)

Lee, Jennifer M. (Massachusetts)

Lent, Sarah E. (Massachusetts)

Liebel, John T. (Massachusetts)

Lindemann, Jessica M. (Massachusetts)

LoPalo, Christopher R. (Massachusetts)

Lowell, Appointing Authority (Massachusetts)

Lucia, Joseph P. (Massachusetts)

Lyons, Matthew M. (Massachusetts)

MacDonald, Mary Ellen (Massachusetts)

MacKenzie, Michael B. (Massachusetts)

Magnanini, Robert A. (Massachusetts)

Maki, Lisa Skehill (Massachusetts)

Manganaro, Kevin W. (Massachusetts)

Manousos, Gregory A. (Massachusetts)

Markey, Patrick J. (Massachusetts)

Marks, David R. (Massachusetts)

Martignetti, Eric (Massachusetts)

Martin, Kevin P. (Massachusetts)

Martinez, Frank (Massachusetts)

Martland, Douglas S. (Massachusetts)

Massachusetts, Commonwealth of (Massachusetts)

Mathias, James D (Massachusetts)

Matlack, William T. (Massachusetts)

McAuliffe, Eileen Ryan (Massachusetts)

McDermott, Kevin S. (Massachusetts)

McKenna-DOJ, Sean Robert (Massachusetts)

McKey, Jamie Jean (Massachusetts)

McMahon, Kimberley A. (Massachusetts)

McQuillan, Peter J. (Massachusetts)

Meally, Edmund J (Massachusetts)

Miles, Sabrina (Massachusetts)

Miller, Kara Sue (Massachusetts)

Miller, Jonathan B. (Massachusetts)

Mitchell, Matthew L. (Massachusetts)

Moore, David M. (Massachusetts)

Moran, Timothy E. (Massachusetts)

Morin, Erica (Massachusetts)

Morris, Robert P. (Massachusetts)

Morrison, Eileen L. (Massachusetts)

Mosley, Gwendolyn T. (Massachusetts)

Mulcahy, Michael E. (Massachusetts)

Mullin, Peter A. (Massachusetts)

Murray, Jill M. (Massachusetts)

Mustokoff, Michael M. (Massachusetts)

Nabulsi, Sammy S. (Massachusetts)

Nadeau, Genevieve C. (Massachusetts)

Nannis, Veronica Byam (Massachusetts)

Neal, Angela J. (Massachusetts)

Nelson, Ronald G. (Massachusetts)

Norris, Tim D. (Massachusetts)

O'Connor, Nicole M. (Massachusetts)

O'Connor, Christine P. (Massachusetts)

Olivere, Mark D. (Massachusetts)

Olmedo, Giselle (Massachusetts)

Orent, Jonathan D. (Massachusetts)

Ouellette, Evan C. (Massachusetts)

Paine, William H. (Massachusetts)

Palmer, R. Scott (Massachusetts)

Pappenheim, Hannah B. (Massachusetts)

Pardee, William L. (Massachusetts)

Paris, Lynda Carey (Massachusetts)

Patten, Robert P (Massachusetts)

Phan, Susan (Massachusetts)

Phelps, Melinda M. (Massachusetts)

Pierce, Rudolph F. (Massachusetts)

Pikula, Edward M. (Massachusetts)

Plotkin, Wendy S. (Massachusetts)

Pogrel, David Philip (Massachusetts)

Prince, Walter B. (Massachusetts)

Prior, Ian D. (Massachusetts)

Pyle, Jeffrey Jackson (Massachusetts)

Quinan, Robert L. (Massachusetts)

Quinn, Wendy L. (Massachusetts)

Rahn, Steven C (Massachusetts)

Randazzo, Michele E. (Massachusetts)

Randazzo, Anne L. (Massachusetts)

Ravitz, Randall E. (Massachusetts)

Regan, Kerry Maddox (Massachusetts)

Reidy, Catherine S. (Massachusetts)

Reis, Erika P. (Massachusetts)

Rice, Juliana deHaan (Massachusetts)

Rios, Ricardo Brandon (Massachusetts)

Rogers, Robert M (Massachusetts)

Rossetti, Kenneth J. (Massachusetts)

Ruano, Raquel D. (Massachusetts)

Salinger, Kenneth W. (Massachusetts)

Samy, Sharad (Massachusetts)

Santos, Jaime A. (Massachusetts)

Schenk-Hargrove, Christina M. (Massachusetts)

Schmit, John P (Massachusetts)

Schofield, Seth (Massachusetts)

Schreiber, Philip M. (Massachusetts)

Schuh, James A. (Massachusetts)

Sclarsic, Jonathan (Massachusetts)

Scott, Andrew G (Massachusetts)

Shalov, Lee Scott (Massachusetts)

Shapiro, Jeffrey S. (Massachusetts)

Sharobem, Steven T. (Massachusetts)

Shavit, Yael (Massachusetts)

Sheehy, Maria (Massachusetts)

Shin, Sookyoung (Massachusetts)

Simon, John M. (Massachusetts)

Sinkel, Ginny (Massachusetts)

Sivitz, Rebecca J. (Massachusetts)

Slagle, R. Eric (Massachusetts)

Smith, Charles John (Massachusetts)

Smith, Jordan Michael (Massachusetts)

Soisson, Amy M. (Massachusetts)

Spaeth, Peter A. (Massachusetts)

Stark, Zoe (Massachusetts)

Steinfield, Joseph D. (Massachusetts)

Stengle, Linda Jeffries (Massachusetts)

Sterman, Anne L. (Massachusetts)

Stone, David S. (Massachusetts)

Sullivan, Eugene J (Massachusetts)

Sweeney, Thomas E. (Massachusetts)

Tang, Yeatyng Evelyn (Massachusetts)

Taub, Nicole I. (Massachusetts)

Thomas, Elizabeth Abimbola (Massachusetts)

Valicenti, Todd M. (Massachusetts)

Walle, Erin McCarthy (Massachusetts)

Warner, Jonathon David (Massachusetts)

Weise, Susan M. (Massachusetts)

Wellock, James F. (Massachusetts)

Whitesell, Edward F. (Massachusetts)

Wilson, Anthony I. (Massachusetts)

Witherby, H. Reed (Massachusetts)

Wolkoff, Eric D. (Massachusetts)

Wotring, Earnest William (Massachusetts)

Yanchunis, John Allen (Massachusetts)

Young, James Dennis (Massachusetts)

Zivyon, Ari (Massachusetts)

show all people

Documents in the Clearinghouse

Document

0984-CV-00576

Docket

Lopez v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Feb. 11, 2009

Feb. 11, 2009

Docket
1

1:07-cv-11693

Complaint; Injunctive and Declaratory Relief Requested

U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts

Sept. 11, 2007

Sept. 11, 2007

Complaint

09-01664

Opinion

U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

Dec. 3, 2009

Dec. 3, 2009

Order/Opinion

588 F.3d 588

SJC-11013

Opinion

Massachusetts state supreme court

Nov. 9, 2012

Nov. 9, 2012

Order/Opinion

463 Mass. 463

1:07-cv-11693

Findings of Facts, Conclusions of Law, and Order for Judgment

Lopez v. City of Lawrence

U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts

Sept. 5, 2014

Sept. 5, 2014

Order/Opinion

2014 WL 2014

09-01664

Opinion

Lopez v. City of Lawrence

U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

May 18, 2016

May 18, 2016

Order/Opinion

823 F.3d 823

0984-CV-00576

Endorsement Regarding "Defendants' Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings"

Tatum v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Jan. 7, 2019

Jan. 7, 2019

Order/Opinion

0984-CV-00576

Docket

Jan. 14, 2019

Jan. 14, 2019

None

19-P-835

Memorandum and Order Pursuant to Rule 23.0

Tatum v. Commonwealth

Massachusetts state appellate court

July 22, 2020

July 22, 2020

Order/Opinion

150 N.E.3d 150

0984-CV-00576

Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on Phase I (Liability)

Oct. 27, 2022

Oct. 27, 2022

Order/Opinion

Docket

Last updated Aug. 30, 2023, 1:27 p.m.

Docket sheet not available via the Clearinghouse.

Case Details

State / Territory: Massachusetts

Case Type(s):

Equal Employment

Policing

Key Dates

Filing Date: Feb. 11, 2009

Case Ongoing: Yes

Plaintiffs

Plaintiff Description:

Black and Hispanic police officers in Massachusetts who took promotional exams for the position of police sergeant administered statewide and in Boston in 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2010, and 2012.

Plaintiff Type(s):

Private Plaintiff

Public Interest Lawyer: No

Filed Pro Se: No

Class Action Sought: Yes

Class Action Outcome: Granted

Defendants

Commonwealth of Massachusetts, State

Defendant Type(s):

Jurisdiction-wide

Case Details

Causes of Action:

State law

Title VII (including PDA), 42 U.S.C. § 2000e

Available Documents:

Trial Court Docket

Complaint (any)

Monetary Relief

Injunctive (or Injunctive-like) Relief

Any published opinion

Outcome

Prevailing Party: Plaintiff

Nature of Relief:

Attorneys fees

Document/information produced

Damages

Source of Relief:

Settlement

Litigation

Form of Settlement:

Court Approved Settlement or Consent Decree

Amount Defendant Pays: $40,000,000

Order Duration: 2023 - None

Issues

Discrimination Area:

Disparate Impact

Discrimination Basis:

National origin discrimination

Race discrimination

Affected National Origin/Ethnicity(s):

Hispanic

Affected Race(s):

Black