|
1
|
COMPLAINT against Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Filing Fee $ 150.00, Receipt Number 527025)Document filed by Sonia Klinger, Minel Tobertga Hider, Amy Velez, Michelle Williams, Penni Zelinkoff.(gf, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 11/24/2004 (gf, ). (Entered: 11/22/2004)
|
Nov. 19, 2004
|
Nov. 19, 2004
RECAP
|
|
2
|
NOTICE of Appearance by Jeremy Heisler on behalf of Sonia Klinger, Minel Tobertga Hider, Amy Velez, Michelle Williams, Penni Zelinkoff (gf, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 11/24/2004 (gf, ). (Entered: 11/22/2004)
|
Nov. 19, 2004
|
Nov. 19, 2004
PACER
|
|
3
|
AMENDED COMPLAINT against Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.Document filed by Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider.(dle, ) (Entered: 02/24/2005)
|
Feb. 23, 2005
|
Feb. 23, 2005
PACER
|
|
4
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jonathan A. Wexler dated 3/1/05 re: counsel for dfts request that the time for dfts to respond to the amended complaint be extended to 4/18/05. So Ordered. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 3/4/05) (dle, ) (Entered: 03/10/2005)
|
March 7, 2005
|
March 7, 2005
PACER
|
|
5
|
MOTION pursuant to Rule 1.3(c) of the Local Rules of the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York for an Order allowing the admission of Charles B. Wolf, Richard H. Schnadig, Thomas G. Abram, Aaron R. Gelb and Sara J. Kagay as attorneys Pro Hac Vice to argue or try this case in whole or in part as counsel or advocate. Affidavit of Jonathan A. Wexler in support and proposed Order attached. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Return Date set for 4/15/2005 10:00 AM. (yv, ) Modified on 4/6/2005 (yv, ). (Entered: 04/06/2005)
|
March 30, 2005
|
March 30, 2005
PACER
|
|
6
|
MOTION pursuant to Rule 1.3(c) of the Local Rules of the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York for an Order allowing the admission of Charles B. Wolf, Richard H. Schnadig, Thomas G. Abram, Aaron R. Gelb and Sara J. Kagay as attorneys Pro Hac Vice for defendant. Affidavit of Jonathan A. Wexler in support attached. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Return Date set for 4/15/2005 10:00 AM. (yv, ) Modified on 4/11/2005 (yv, ). Modified on 4/11/2005 (yv, ). (Entered: 04/11/2005)
|
April 4, 2005
|
April 4, 2005
PACER
|
|
7
|
MOTION for Summary Judgment. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Responses due by 5/2/2005 Return Date set for 5/16/2005 09:30 AM. (Attachments: # 1 # 2 # 3 # 4 # 5 # 6 # 7 # 8 # 9 # 10)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/19/2005)
1
View on PACER
2
View on PACER
3
View on PACER
4
View on PACER
5
View on PACER
6
View on PACER
7
View on PACER
8
View on PACER
9
View on PACER
10
View on PACER
|
April 19, 2005
|
April 19, 2005
PACER
|
|
8
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 7 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/19/2005)
|
April 19, 2005
|
April 19, 2005
PACER
|
|
9
|
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY-RULE 7.1 DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.(Wexler, Jonathan) Modified on 4/20/2005 (jp, ). (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
10
|
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Related document: 3 Amended Complaint, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,. (Attachments: # 1)(Wexler, Jonathan) Modified on 4/20/2005 (kg). Modified on 4/20/2005 (kg, ). (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
11
|
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - RULE 7.1 DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Document filed by Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.(Wexler, Jonathan) Modified on 4/20/2005 (kg). (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
12
|
RULE 7.1 DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Document filed by Novartis Corporation.(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
13
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. Related document: 3 Amended Complaint, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,. (Attachments: # 1)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/20/2005)
1
View on RECAP
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
RECAP
|
|
14
|
RULE 7.1 DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
15
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Related document: 3 Amended Complaint, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,. (Attachments: # 1)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 04/20/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
16
|
ORDER granting 5 Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice, granting 6 Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice . (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 4/16/05) (jco, ) (Entered: 04/22/2005)
|
April 20, 2005
|
April 20, 2005
PACER
|
|
17
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER: plaintiffs' opposition to defendants' motion for summary judgment due by 5/9/2005. Reply due by 5/23/2005. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/3/05) (kw, ) (Entered: 05/05/2005)
|
May 4, 2005
|
May 4, 2005
PACER
|
|
18
|
OPPOSITION BRIEF re: 7 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider.(Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 05/09/2005)
|
May 9, 2005
|
May 9, 2005
PACER
|
|
19
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: 7 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit of Sonia Klinger in Support of Opposition# 2 Exhibit B in Support of Opposition# 3 Responses to Statement of Uncontested Material Facts# 4 Statement of Contested Material Facts)(Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 05/09/2005)
2 Affidavit of Sonia Klinger in Support of Opposition
View on PACER
3 Exhibit B in Support of Opposition
View on PACER
4 Responses to Statement of Uncontested Material Facts
View on PACER
5 Statement of Contested Material Facts
View on PACER
|
May 9, 2005
|
May 9, 2005
PACER
|
|
20
|
MOTION for an order, admitting David W. Sanford and Lisa A. Goldblatt to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. Return Date set for 5/20/2005 at 10:00 AM. (sac, ) (Entered: 05/10/2005)
|
May 9, 2005
|
May 9, 2005
PACER
|
|
21
|
ORDER withdrawing without prejudice 7 Motion for Summary Judgment to renewing the motion at a subsequent date. Plaintiffs are to serve document demands and interrogatories on the limited issue of the relationship between defendant Novartis Corporation and its subsidiary and co-defendant, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation, no later than 5/27/05. The parties are to appear before the Court for an interim status conference in this matter on Friday, 10/14/05 at 10:30 a.m. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/13/05) (yv, ) (Entered: 05/17/2005)
|
May 16, 2005
|
May 16, 2005
PACER
|
|
22
|
CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Amended pleadings may be filed until 6/3/2005. Joinder of additional parties must be accomplished by 6/3/2005. The motion for class certification is to be served and filed by 3/31/2006. Answering papers are to be served and filed by 4/30/2006. Reply papers are to be served and filed by 5/31/2006. All fact discovery related to class certification is to be completed by 11/30/2005. First request for production of documents relating to class certification, if any, to be served by 6/30/05. Interrogatories relating to class certification pursuant to Local Rule 33.3(a) of the Civil Rules of the Southern District of New York to be served by 6/30/05. Experts, if any, in support of class certification are to be designated by plaintiffs by 10/31/05, and any reports furnished by 11/30/05. Any experts by defendants in opposition to class certification shall be designated by 11/30/05, and any reports furnished by 1/15/06. Experts may de deposed, but such depositions must occur by 1/31/06. The parties are to appear before the Court for an interim status conference in this matter on Friday, 10/14/2005 at 10:30 AM (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/13/05) (yv, ) (Entered: 05/17/2005)
|
May 16, 2005
|
May 16, 2005
RECAP
|
|
23
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER plaintiffs' memo in support of opposition to defendants' motion shall be no more than 30 pages; and defendants' reply to plaintiffs' memo in support of opposition shall be no more than 15 pages. So Ordered.(Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/11/05) (jco, ) (Entered: 06/02/2005)
|
May 31, 2005
|
May 31, 2005
PACER
|
|
24
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER that the parties time to serve their initial disclosures purs. to Rule 26(a)(1) of the FRCP is extended to and including 6/24/05. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/31/05) (dle, ) (Entered: 06/03/2005)
|
June 1, 2005
|
June 1, 2005
PACER
|
|
25
|
Second AMENDED COMPLAINT amending 3 Amended Complaint, against Thomas Ebeling, Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.Document filed by Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. Related document: 3 Amended Complaint, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,.(kw, ) (Entered: 06/06/2005)
|
June 3, 2005
|
June 3, 2005
PACER
|
|
26
|
STIPULATION ; that the time by which dfts Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp. and Novartis Corp. must respond to plaintiffs' First Set of Requests for Production of Documents to dfts, and plaintiffs' First Set of Interrogatories to Dfts, is extended to and including 7/27/05; dfts Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp. Novartis Corp. must respond to the Second Amended Class Action Complaint is extended to 7/24/05. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 6/15/05) (pl, ) (Entered: 06/20/2005)
|
June 17, 2005
|
June 17, 2005
PACER
|
|
27
|
NOTICE of Appearance by Heather McDevitt on behalf of Novartis Corporation (McDevitt, Heather) (Entered: 06/24/2005)
|
June 24, 2005
|
June 24, 2005
PACER
|
|
28
|
NOTICE of Appearance by Vincent R Fitzpatrick on behalf of Novartis Corporation (Fitzpatrick, Vincent) (Entered: 06/24/2005)
|
June 24, 2005
|
June 24, 2005
PACER
|
|
29
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Related document: 25 Amended Complaint,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,.(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 07/25/2005)
|
July 25, 2005
|
July 25, 2005
PACER
|
|
30
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. Related document: 25 Amended Complaint,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,.(McDevitt, Heather) (Entered: 07/25/2005)
|
July 25, 2005
|
July 25, 2005
PACER
|
|
31
|
STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL; that Class Rep. Fonna Martin hereby dismisses her claims without prejudice against Novartis Corp, Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp. and Thomas Ebeling. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 7/25/05) (pl, ) Modified on 7/27/2005 (pl, ). (Entered: 07/27/2005)
|
July 26, 2005
|
July 26, 2005
PACER
|
|
32
|
ORDER; granting 20 Motion for David W. Sanford and Lisa A. Goldblatt to Appear Pro Hac Vice . (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 7/25/05) (pl, ) (Entered: 07/27/2005)
|
July 26, 2005
|
July 26, 2005
PACER
|
|
33
|
NOTICE of Appearance by Jack Pace on behalf of Novartis Corporation (Pace, Jack) (Entered: 08/31/2005)
|
Aug. 31, 2005
|
Aug. 31, 2005
PACER
|
|
34
|
STIPULATION TO FILE THIRD AMENDED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 9/6/05) (sac, ) (Entered: 09/08/2005)
|
Sept. 7, 2005
|
Sept. 7, 2005
PACER
|
|
35
|
THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT amending 25 Amended Complaint,, against Thomas Ebeling, Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.Document filed by Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Dutkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Mary Anne Jacoby, Simona Lopez, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Michelle Williams, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. Related document: 25 Amended Complaint,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Tobertga Hider,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta Vonlintel,.(cd, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 9/20/2005 (cd, ). (Entered: 09/13/2005)
|
Sept. 9, 2005
|
Sept. 9, 2005
PACER
|
|
36
|
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - (DOCUMENT WAS NAMED INCRRECTLY) - PROPOSED MOTION for Leave to Appear By telephone. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Dutkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Mary Anne Jacoby, Simona Lopez, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. Return Date set for 10/13/2005 12:00 PM. (Wittels, Steven) Modified on 10/18/2005 (gf, ). (Entered: 10/11/2005)
|
Oct. 11, 2005
|
Oct. 11, 2005
PACER
|
|
37
|
MOTION for Leave to Appear By Telephone. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Dutkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Mary Anne Jacoby, Simona Lopez, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. Return Date set for 10/13/2005 12:00 PM. (Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 10/12/2005)
|
Oct. 12, 2005
|
Oct. 12, 2005
PACER
|
|
38
|
REVISED CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Amended Pleadings due by 8/18/2005. Joinder of Parties due by 6/3/2005. Discovery due by 2/28/2006. Status Conference set for 2/3/2006 11:30 AM before Judge Gerard E. Lynch. Additional discovery deadlines are as set forth in this Order. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 10/14/05) (pl, ) (Entered: 10/20/2005)
|
Oct. 14, 2005
|
Oct. 14, 2005
PACER
|
|
39
|
CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Motions due by 8/15/2006. Responses due by 9/29/2006 Replies due by 11/10/2006. Discovery due by 2/28/2006. Status Conference set for 2/3/2006 11:30 AM before Judge Gerard E. Lynch. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 10/14/05) (db, ) (Entered: 10/20/2005)
|
Oct. 19, 2005
|
Oct. 19, 2005
RECAP
|
|
40
|
JOINT MOTION for Protective Order Joint Motion for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Stipulated Protective Order)(Kirshner, Alison) (Entered: 10/21/2005)
2 Stipulated Protective Order
View on PACER
|
Oct. 21, 2005
|
Oct. 21, 2005
PACER
|
|
41
|
STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER...regarding procedures to be followed that shall govern the handling of confidential material.... (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 10/25/05) (cd, ) (Entered: 10/28/2005)
|
Oct. 27, 2005
|
Oct. 27, 2005
RECAP
|
|
42
|
CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Status Conference set for 2/3/2006 11:30 AM before Judge Gerard E. Lynch. Discovery due by 2/28/2006. Responses due by 5/1/2006 Motions due by 8/15/2006. Replies due by 11/10/2006. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 10/14/2005) (jmi, ) (Entered: 11/21/2005)
|
Nov. 21, 2005
|
Nov. 21, 2005
PACER
|
|
43
|
ORDER for the pro hac vice appearance of Laura Fentomiller for plaintiffs. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 12/2/05) (cd, ) (Entered: 12/08/2005)
|
Dec. 7, 2005
|
Dec. 7, 2005
PACER
|
|
44
|
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE of Summons and Amended Complaint,,,. Thomas Ebeling served on 11/4/2005, answer due 11/25/2005. Service was accepted by Unknown, Guard. Service was made by Mail. Document filed by Michelle Williams; Kelly Corbett; Marta Deyne; Joan Dutkin; Sue Earl; Jamie Holland; Mary Anne Jacoby; Simona Lopez; Ashley Narmour; Catherine White; Amy Velez; Stephanie Cates; Lori Horton; Karen Liggins; Wendy Pinson; Roberta Vonlintel; Holly Waters; Jennifer Waxman-Recht; Sonia Klinger; Penni Zelinkoff; Minel Tobertga Hider. (Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 12/16/2005)
|
Dec. 16, 2005
|
Dec. 16, 2005
PACER
|
|
45
|
MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Dutkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Mary Anne Jacoby, Simona Lopez, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. (Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 12/19/2005)
|
Dec. 19, 2005
|
Dec. 19, 2005
PACER
|
|
46
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 45 MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Dutkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Mary Anne Jacoby, Simona Lopez, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Stephanie Cates, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Sonia Klinger, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Tobertga Hider. (Attachments: # 1 Supplement Affirmation of Jeremy Heisler# 2 Exhibit Exhibit A to Heisler Aff# 3 Exhibit Exhibit B to Heisler Aff# 4 Exhibit Exhibit C to Heisler Aff# 5 Exhibit Exhibit D to Heisler Aff# 6 Exhibit Exhibit E to Heisler Aff)(Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 12/19/2005)
2 Supplement Affirmation of Jeremy Heisler
View on PACER
3 Exhibit Exhibit A to Heisler Aff
View on PACER
4 Exhibit Exhibit B to Heisler Aff
View on PACER
5 Exhibit Exhibit C to Heisler Aff
View on PACER
6 Exhibit Exhibit D to Heisler Aff
View on PACER
7 Exhibit Exhibit E to Heisler Aff
View on PACER
|
Dec. 19, 2005
|
Dec. 19, 2005
PACER
|
|
47
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER that the date for Thomas Ebeling's opposition to plaintiffs' motion for a judicial finding that plaintiffs have validly served dft Thomas Ebeling or alternatively an order under CPLR 308(5) directing that e-mail or mail service on Ebeling is sufficient shall be adjourned from 1/9/06 until 2/10/06 with a reply due by 2/21/06. Counsel for Thomas Ebeling will hand deliver his opposition to counsel for plaintiffs on or before 2/10/06 at 5:00 p.m. Plaintiffs will hand deliver its reply to counsel for Mr. Ebeling on or before 2/21/06 at 5:00 p.m. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 1/12/06) (dle, ) (Entered: 01/12/2006)
|
Jan. 12, 2006
|
Jan. 12, 2006
PACER
|
|
48
|
ORDER; re: granting 37 MOTION for Leave to Appear By Telephone. filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Hider Tobertga,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta VonLintel,, Ashley Narmour,, Catherine White,, Kelly Corbett,, Sue Earl,, Jamie Holland,, Joan Durkin,, Simona Lopes,, Maryanne Jacoby,, Marta Deyne, (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 2/2/06) (pl, ) (Entered: 02/03/2006)
|
Feb. 2, 2006
|
Feb. 2, 2006
PACER
|
|
49
|
REVISED CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Amended Pleadings due by 8/18/2005. Joinder of Parties due by 6/3/2005. Discovery due by 4/28/2006. Status Conference set for 5/5/2006 10:30 AM before Judge Gerard E. Lynch. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 2/3/06) (jco, ) (Entered: 02/08/2006)
|
Feb. 7, 2006
|
Feb. 7, 2006
PACER
|
|
50
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER OF DISMISSAL pursuant to F.R.C.P. 41, that Class Representative Sonia Klinger hereby dismisses her claims with prejudice against Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation and Thomas Ebeling. So Ordered. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 2/7/06) (jco, ) (Entered: 02/08/2006)
|
Feb. 7, 2006
|
Feb. 7, 2006
PACER
|
|
51
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: 45 MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling.. Document filed by Thomas Ebeling. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Affidavit of Kortright Mullin# 2 Exhibit 2 - Affidavit of Theodias Sankey# 3 Cassandra Porter's Certificate of Service)(Norber, Dan) (Entered: 02/10/2006)
2 Exhibit 1 - Affidavit of Kortright Mullin
View on PACER
3 Exhibit 2 - Affidavit of Theodias Sankey
View on PACER
4 Cassandra Porter's Certificate of Service
View on PACER
|
Feb. 10, 2006
|
Feb. 10, 2006
PACER
|
|
52
|
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 45 MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 02/21/2006)
|
Feb. 21, 2006
|
Feb. 21, 2006
PACER
|
|
53
|
REPLY AFFIRMATION of Jeremy Heisler in Support re: 45 MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A)(Wittels, Steven) (Entered: 02/21/2006)
2 Exhibit Exhibit A
View on PACER
|
Feb. 21, 2006
|
Feb. 21, 2006
PACER
|
|
54
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER OF DISMISSAL pursuant to F.R.C.P. 41, that Class Representative Stephanie Cates hereby dismisses her claims with prejudice against Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation and Thoams Ebeling. So Ordered. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 2/22/06) (jco, ) (Entered: 02/27/2006)
|
Feb. 27, 2006
|
Feb. 27, 2006
PACER
|
|
55
|
STIPULATION TO FILE FOURTH AMENDED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT: Plaintiffs may file a fourth amended class action complaint, which is identical to the third amended class action complaint except that all references in the third amended class action complaint to Sonia Klinger and Stephanie Cates have been removed. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 3/8/2006) (lb, ) (Entered: 03/09/2006)
|
March 9, 2006
|
March 9, 2006
PACER
|
|
56
|
FOURTH AMENDED COMPLAINT amending 35 Amended Complaint,,, against Thomas Ebeling, Novartis Corporation, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation.Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. Related document: 35 Amended Complaint,,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Sonia Klinger,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Hider Tobertga,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Karen Liggins,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Stephanie Cates,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta VonLintel,, Ashley Narmour,, Catherine White,, Kelly Corbett,, Sue Earl,, Jamie Holland,, Joan Durkin,, Simona Lopes,, Maryanne Jacoby,, Marta Deyne,.(sac, ) (Entered: 03/14/2006)
|
March 13, 2006
|
March 13, 2006
RECAP
|
|
57
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. Related document: 56 Amended Complaint,,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Hider Tobertga,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta VonLintel,, Ashley Narmour,, Catherine White,, Kelly Corbett,, Sue Earl,, Jamie Holland,, Joan Durkin,, Simona Lopes,, Maryanne Jacoby,, Marta Deyne,. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit of Service)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 03/20/2006)
2 Affidavit of Service
View on PACER
|
March 20, 2006
|
March 20, 2006
PACER
|
|
59
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. Related document: 56 Amended Complaint,,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Hider Tobertga,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta VonLintel,, Ashley Narmour,, Catherine White,, Kelly Corbett,, Sue Earl,, Jamie Holland,, Joan Durkin,, Simona Lopes,, Maryanne Jacoby,, Marta Deyne,.(Fitzpatrick, Vincent) (Entered: 03/31/2006)
|
March 31, 2006
|
March 31, 2006
PACER
|
|
60
|
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by David W. Sanford on behalf of Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga (Sanford, David) (Entered: 04/04/2006)
|
April 4, 2006
|
April 4, 2006
PACER
|
|
61
|
OPINION AND ORDER re: 45 MOTION (1) Judicial Finding that Plaintiffs have validly served Defendant Thomas Ebeling, or alternatively (2) An Order Directing E-mail or Mail Service on Defendant Ebeling. Ebeling has been properly served, and plaintiffs' motion is GRANTED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 4/4/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 04/06/2006)
|
April 5, 2006
|
April 5, 2006
RECAP
|
|
62
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jeremy Heisler dated 4/7/06 re: Counsel writes to request that Your Honor endorse the briefing schedule as follows: 5/18/06: Plaintiffs' opposition to defendant Novartis Corporation's Motion for summary judgment due; 6/18/06: Defendant Novartis Corporation's reply to plaintiffs' opposition due. So Ordered. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 4/7/06) (jco, ) (Entered: 04/14/2006)
|
April 14, 2006
|
April 14, 2006
PACER
|
|
63
|
ANSWER to Amended Complaint. Document filed by Thomas Ebeling. Related document: 56 Amended Complaint,,, filed by Michelle Williams,, Amy Velez,, Penni Zelinkoff,, Minel Hider Tobertga,, Jennifer Waxman-Recht,, Lori Horton,, Holly Waters,, Wendy Pinson,, Roberta VonLintel,, Ashley Narmour,, Catherine White,, Kelly Corbett,, Sue Earl,, Jamie Holland,, Joan Durkin,, Simona Lopes,, Maryanne Jacoby,, Marta Deyne,.(Christensen, Andrea) (Entered: 04/20/2006)
|
April 20, 2006
|
April 20, 2006
PACER
|
|
64
|
MOTION for Leave to Appear By Telephone. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Sanford, David) (Entered: 05/02/2006)
|
May 2, 2006
|
May 2, 2006
PACER
|
|
65
|
MOTION for Leave to File Amended Answer. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 05/10/2006)
|
May 10, 2006
|
May 10, 2006
PACER
|
|
66
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 65 MOTION for Leave to File Amended Answer.. Document filed by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 05/10/2006)
|
May 10, 2006
|
May 10, 2006
PACER
|
|
67
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jeremy Heisler dated 5/22/06 re: a request for the following briefing schedule: opposition papers due by 5/30/06 and reply papers due by 7/10/06. ENDORSEMENT: SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/22/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 05/23/2006)
|
May 23, 2006
|
May 23, 2006
PACER
|
|
68
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jeremy Heisler dated 5/22/06 re: a request for the following briefing schedule: opposition papers due by 6/2/06 and reply papers due by 6/12/06. ENDORSEMENT: SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/22/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 05/23/2006)
|
May 23, 2006
|
May 23, 2006
PACER
|
|
69
|
REVISED CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN: Amended Pleadings due by 8/18/2006. Joinder of Parties due by 6/3/2006. Motions due by 1/15/2007. Responses due by 2/28/2007 Replies due by 3/11/2007. Status Conference set for 10/6/2006 at 11:00 AM before Judge Gerard E. Lynch. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 5/22/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 05/23/2006)
|
May 23, 2006
|
May 23, 2006
PACER
|
|
72
|
ORDER that the clerk of the court is respectfully directed to clsoe the motions doc. #64 and #65 for all internal statistical purposes. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 6/9/06) (dle, ) (Entered: 06/12/2006)
|
June 12, 2006
|
June 12, 2006
PACER
|
|
73
|
MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages /Motion to Expand Page Limits. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(McDevitt, Heather) (Entered: 06/29/2006)
2 Proposed Order
View on PACER
|
June 29, 2006
|
June 29, 2006
PACER
|
|
74
|
STIPULATION AND ORDER, Plantiffs and Defendant Novartis Corporation, by and through their undersigned counsel, hereby stipulate and agree that the deadline for Novartis Corporation's reply memorandum of law in further support of its motion for summary judgment willbe extended from July 10, 2006 to and including July 24, 2006. Motions due by 7/24/2006. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 6/30/2006) (jmi, ) (Entered: 07/06/2006)
|
July 6, 2006
|
July 6, 2006
PACER
|
|
75
|
ORDER granting 73 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages. . (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 7/24/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 07/25/2006)
|
July 24, 2006
|
July 24, 2006
PACER
|
|
76
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Richard H. Schnadig dated 7/20/06 re: a request for an extension of the class certification fact discovery cutoff date, currently set for 7/28/06 to and including 9/13/2006. ENDORSEMENT: SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 7/24/06) (kco, ) (Entered: 07/25/2006)
|
July 24, 2006
|
July 24, 2006
PACER
|
|
77
|
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by David W. Sanford on behalf of all plaintiffs. New Address: Sanford, Wittels & Heisler, LLP, 1666 Connecticut Ave NW, Suite 310, Washington, DC, USA 20009, 202-742-7777. (Sanford, David) (Entered: 07/25/2006)
|
July 25, 2006
|
July 25, 2006
PACER
|
|
79
|
MOTION for Angela Corridan to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. Proposed Order attached. (db, ) (Entered: 07/28/2006)
|
July 27, 2006
|
July 27, 2006
PACER
|
|
80
|
MOTION for Angela Corridan to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. Proposed Order attached. (db, ) (Entered: 08/24/2006)
|
Aug. 24, 2006
|
Aug. 24, 2006
PACER
|
|
81
|
NOTICE of Designation of Plaintiffs' Expert Witnesses. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Sanford, David) (Entered: 08/30/2006)
|
Aug. 30, 2006
|
Aug. 30, 2006
PACER
|
|
82
|
ORDER granting 80 Motion for Angela Corridan to Appear Pro Hac Vice . So Ordered.(Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 8/31/06) (jco, ) (Entered: 08/31/2006)
|
Aug. 31, 2006
|
Aug. 31, 2006
PACER
|
|
83
|
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Laura Christine Fentonmiller to Withdraw as Attorney. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum in Support of Motion)(Sanford, David) Modified on 10/25/2006 (kg, ). (Entered: 10/24/2006)
2 Memorandum in Support of Motion
View on PACER
|
Oct. 24, 2006
|
Oct. 24, 2006
PACER
|
|
84
|
ORDER: Having fully considered attorney Laura C. Fentonmiller's Motion to Withdraw as Counsel for Plaintiffs, it is this 25th day of October 2006 hereby: Ordered that Laura C. Fentonmiller's Motion to withdraw is GRANTED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 10/25/06) (js, ) (Entered: 10/26/2006)
|
Oct. 25, 2006
|
Oct. 25, 2006
PACER
|
|
85
|
MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Sanford, David) (Entered: 10/31/2006)
|
Oct. 31, 2006
|
Oct. 31, 2006
PACER
|
|
86
|
ORDER granting 85 Plaintiff's Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages . (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 11/6/2006) (lb, ) (Entered: 11/07/2006)
|
Nov. 6, 2006
|
Nov. 6, 2006
PACER
|
|
87
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jonathan E. Lynch dated 1/10/07 re: a request for a one day extension of time as set forth below: motions due 1/16/2007, responses due by 3/1/2007, and reply papers due by 3/12/2007. ENDORSEMENTS: SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 1/10/07) (kco, ) (Entered: 01/11/2007)
|
Jan. 11, 2007
|
Jan. 11, 2007
PACER
|
|
88
|
MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga.(Sanford, David) (Entered: 01/16/2007)
|
Jan. 16, 2007
|
Jan. 16, 2007
PACER
|
|
89
|
MOTION to Certify Class. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga.(Sanford, David) (Entered: 01/16/2007)
|
Jan. 16, 2007
|
Jan. 16, 2007
PACER
|
|
90
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 89 MOTION to Certify Class.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Ex 1 - O'Hagan Day 1 Dep# 2 Exhibit Ex 2 - O'Hagan Day 2 Dep# 3 Exhibit Ex 3 - O'Hagan Day 3 Dep Excerpts# 4 Exhibit Ex 4 - DiCindio Dep Excerpts# 5 Exhibit Ex 5 - Freire Dep Exceprts# 6 Exhibit Ex 6 - Perkins Dep Excerpts# 7 Exhibit Ex 7 - Anhalt Dep Excerpts# 8 Exhibit Ex 8 - Ebeling Dep Excerpts# 9 Exhibit Ex 9 - Corbett Dep Excerpts# 10 Exhibit Ex 10 - Deyne Dep Excerpts# 11 Exhibit Ex 11 - Durkin Dep Excerpts# 12 Exhibit Ex 12 - Holland Dep Excerpts# 13 Exhibit Ex 13 - Horton Dep Excerpts# 14 Exhibit Ex 14 - Jacoby Dep Excerpts# 15 Exhibit Ex 15 - Liggins Dep Excerpts# 16 Exhibit Ex 16 - Lopes Dep Excerpts# 17 Exhibit Ex 17 - Pinson Dep Excerpts# 18 Exhibit Ex 18 - Recht Dep Excerpts# 19 Exhibit Ex 19 - Tobertga Dep Excerpts# 20 Exhibit Ex 20 - Velez Dep Excerpts# 21 Exhibit Ex 21 - VonLintel Dep Excerpts# 22 Exhibit Ex 22 - Waters Dep Excerpts# 23 Exhibit Ex 23 - White Dep Excerpts# 24 Exhibit Ex 24 - Williams Dep Excerpts# 25 Exhibit Ex 25 - Zelinkoff Dep Excerpts# 26 Exhibit Ex 26 - Merkelson Dep Excerpts# 27 Exhibit Ex 27 - Declarations - Defranze-Wilmesher# 28 Exhibit Ex 28 - Declarations - Markowitz-Allen# 29 Exhibit Ex 29 - Declarations - Meyer-Beck# 30 Exhibit Ex 30 - Declarations - Peldiak-Bruce# 31 Exhibit Ex 31 - Declarations - Frank-Houlmont# 32 Exhibit Ex 32 - Declarations - Joslin-Lewis# 33 Exhibit Ex 33 - Declarations - Zykan-Gesler# 34 Exhibit Ex 34 - Lopes Declaration# 35 Exhibit Ex 35 - Chart of Declarations# 36 Exhibit Ex 36 - Martin Report# 37 Exhibit Ex 37 - Lanier Report# 38 Exhibit Ex 38 - Lanier Declaration# 39 Exhibit Ex 39 - Lanier Dep Excerpts# 40 Exhibit Ex 40 - Ask Ebeling# 41 Exhibit Ex 41 - Lanier Report Table 4# 42 Exhibit Ex 42 - Deyne Declaration# 43 Appendix App. A Sanford Dec.# 44 Appendix App. B Morris Dec.# 45 Appendix App. C Westlaw Cases Volume 1# 46 Appendix App. D Westlaw Cases Volume 2# 47 Appendix App. E Westlaw Cases Volume 3# 48 Appendix App. F Westlaw Cases Volume 4)(Sanford, David) (Entered: 01/16/2007)
2 Exhibit Ex 1 - O'Hagan Day 1 Dep
View on PACER
3 Exhibit Ex 2 - O'Hagan Day 2 Dep
View on PACER
4 Exhibit Ex 3 - O'Hagan Day 3 Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
5 Exhibit Ex 4 - DiCindio Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
6 Exhibit Ex 5 - Freire Dep Exceprts
View on PACER
7 Exhibit Ex 6 - Perkins Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
8 Exhibit Ex 7 - Anhalt Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
9 Exhibit Ex 8 - Ebeling Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
10 Exhibit Ex 9 - Corbett Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
11 Exhibit Ex 10 - Deyne Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
12 Exhibit Ex 11 - Durkin Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
13 Exhibit Ex 12 - Holland Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
14 Exhibit Ex 13 - Horton Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
15 Exhibit Ex 14 - Jacoby Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
16 Exhibit Ex 15 - Liggins Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
17 Exhibit Ex 16 - Lopes Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
18 Exhibit Ex 17 - Pinson Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
19 Exhibit Ex 18 - Recht Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
20 Exhibit Ex 19 - Tobertga Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
21 Exhibit Ex 20 - Velez Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
22 Exhibit Ex 21 - VonLintel Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
23 Exhibit Ex 22 - Waters Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
24 Exhibit Ex 23 - White Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
25 Exhibit Ex 24 - Williams Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
26 Exhibit Ex 25 - Zelinkoff Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
27 Exhibit Ex 26 - Merkelson Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
28 Exhibit Ex 27 - Declarations - Defranze-Wilmesher
View on PACER
29 Exhibit Ex 28 - Declarations - Markowitz-Allen
View on PACER
30 Exhibit Ex 29 - Declarations - Meyer-Beck
View on PACER
31 Exhibit Ex 30 - Declarations - Peldiak-Bruce
View on PACER
32 Exhibit Ex 31 - Declarations - Frank-Houlmont
View on PACER
33 Exhibit Ex 32 - Declarations - Joslin-Lewis
View on PACER
34 Exhibit Ex 33 - Declarations - Zykan-Gesler
View on PACER
35 Exhibit Ex 34 - Lopes Declaration
View on PACER
36 Exhibit Ex 35 - Chart of Declarations
View on PACER
37 Exhibit Ex 36 - Martin Report
View on PACER
38 Exhibit Ex 37 - Lanier Report
View on PACER
39 Exhibit Ex 38 - Lanier Declaration
View on PACER
40 Exhibit Ex 39 - Lanier Dep Excerpts
View on PACER
41 Exhibit Ex 40 - Ask Ebeling
View on PACER
42 Exhibit Ex 41 - Lanier Report Table 4
View on PACER
43 Exhibit Ex 42 - Deyne Declaration
View on PACER
44 Appendix App. A Sanford Dec.
View on PACER
45 Appendix App. B Morris Dec.
View on PACER
46 Appendix App. C Westlaw Cases Volume 1
View on PACER
47 Appendix App. D Westlaw Cases Volume 2
View on PACER
48 Appendix App. E Westlaw Cases Volume 3
View on PACER
49 Appendix App. F Westlaw Cases Volume 4
View on PACER
|
Jan. 16, 2007
|
Jan. 16, 2007
PACER
|
|
91
|
ORDER granting 88 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages. The page limit for the plaintiffs' memorandum of law in support of their motion for class certification is extended from 50 pages to 52 pages. The page limit for the defendants' memorandumof law in opposition to plaintiff's motion for class certification is extended from 50 pages to 52 pages. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 1/17/07) (kco) (Entered: 01/19/2007)
|
Jan. 18, 2007
|
Jan. 18, 2007
PACER
|
|
92
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Jonathan A. Wexler dated 1/18/07 re: a request that the briefing schedule be modified as follows: opposition papers due by 3/22/07 and reply papers due by 4/9/07. ENDORSEMENT: SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 1/19/07) (kco) (Entered: 01/25/2007)
|
Jan. 24, 2007
|
Jan. 24, 2007
PACER
|
|
93
|
CONSENT MOTION for Lisa Goldblatt to Withdraw as Attorney. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga.(Sanford, David) (Entered: 02/28/2007)
|
Feb. 28, 2007
|
Feb. 28, 2007
PACER
|
|
94
|
CONSENT MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 93 CONSENT MOTION for Lisa Goldblatt to Withdraw as Attorney.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Sanford, David) (Entered: 02/28/2007)
|
Feb. 28, 2007
|
Feb. 28, 2007
PACER
|
|
95
|
ORDER granting 93 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. Attorney Lisa A. Goldblatt terminated. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 3/7/2007) (jmi) (Entered: 03/08/2007)
|
March 7, 2007
|
March 7, 2007
PACER
|
|
96
|
ORDER: The Court is advised that plts' motion for Angela Corridan to appear pro hace vice, Doc#79, appears as an open motion on certain internal reports. The docket entry is a duplicate of Doc#80, dated 8/24/2006, which was granted by order dated 8/31/2006 (Doc.#82.) Accordingly, The Clerk of the Court is respectfullly directe to close the motion (Doc.#79) for all internal statistical purposes. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 3/7/2007) (jar) (Entered: 03/09/2007)
|
March 8, 2007
|
March 8, 2007
PACER
|
|
97
|
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: 89 MOTION to Certify Class.. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1)(Fitzpatrick, Vincent) (Entered: 03/22/2007)
2 Exhibit 1
View on PACER
|
March 22, 2007
|
March 22, 2007
PACER
|
|
98
|
DECLARATION of Vincent R. FitzPatrick in Opposition re: 89 MOTION to Certify Class.. Document filed by Novartis Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Fitzpatrick, Vincent) (Entered: 03/22/2007)
2 Exhibit A
View on PACER
|
March 22, 2007
|
March 22, 2007
PACER
|
|
99
|
BRIEF In Opposition To Class Certification. Document filed by Thomas Ebeling, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation And Thomas Ebling's Brief In Opposition To Class Certification Part 2# 2 Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation And Thomas Ebling's Brief In Opposition To Class Certification Part 3)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 03/22/2007)
2 Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation And Thomas Ebling's Brief In Oppositi
View on PACER
3 Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation And Thomas Ebling's Brief In Oppositi
View on PACER
|
March 22, 2007
|
March 22, 2007
PACER
|
|
100
|
NOTICE of Of Filing Of Appendix To Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation And Thomas Ebeling's Brief In Opposition To Class Certification re: 99 Brief,. Document filed by Thomas Ebeling, Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix Appendix Table of Contents and Exhibit 1-5# 2 Appendix Exhibit 6-10# 3 Appendix Exhibit 11 Part 1# 4 Appendix Exhibit 11 Part 2# 5 Appendix Exhibit 12-13# 6 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 1# 7 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 2# 8 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 3# 9 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 4# 10 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 5# 11 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 6# 12 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 7# 13 Appendix Exhibit 15-18# 14 Appendix Exhibit 18-21# 15 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 1# 16 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 2# 17 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 3# 18 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 4# 19 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 1# 20 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 2# 21 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 3# 22 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 4# 23 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 5# 24 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 1# 25 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 2# 26 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 3-25# 27 Appendix Exhibit 26-27 Part 1# 28 Appendix Exhibit 26-27 Part 2# 29 Appendix Exhibit 28-29# 30 Appendix Exhibit 30# 31 Appendix Exhibit 31# 32 Appendix Exhibit 32-35# 33 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 1# 34 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 2# 35 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 3# 36 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.1# 37 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.2# 38 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.3# 39 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.1# 40 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.2# 41 Exhibit 36 Part 5.3# 42 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.4# 43 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 6# 44 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 7# 45 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 8# 46 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 9# 47 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 10# 48 Appendix Exhibit 37 Part 1# 49 Appendix Exhibit 37 Part 2# 50 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 1# 51 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 2# 52 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 3# 53 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 4# 54 Appendix Exhibit 39# 55 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 1# 56 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 2# 57 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 3# 58 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 4# 59 Appendix Exhibit 41 Part 1# 60 Appendix Exhibit 41 Part 2)(Wexler, Jonathan) (Entered: 03/22/2007)
2 Appendix Appendix Table of Contents and Exhibit 1-5
View on PACER
3 Appendix Exhibit 6-10
View on PACER
4 Appendix Exhibit 11 Part 1
View on PACER
5 Appendix Exhibit 11 Part 2
View on PACER
6 Appendix Exhibit 12-13
View on PACER
7 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 1
View on PACER
8 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 2
View on PACER
9 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 3
View on PACER
10 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 4
View on PACER
11 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 5
View on PACER
12 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 6
View on PACER
13 Appendix Exhibit 14 Part 7
View on PACER
14 Appendix Exhibit 15-18
View on PACER
15 Appendix Exhibit 18-21
View on PACER
16 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 1
View on PACER
17 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 2
View on PACER
18 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 3
View on PACER
19 Appendix Exhibit 22 Part 4
View on PACER
20 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 1
View on PACER
21 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 2
View on PACER
22 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 3
View on PACER
23 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 4
View on PACER
24 Appendix Exhibit 23 Part 5
View on PACER
25 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 1
View on PACER
26 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 2
View on PACER
27 Appendix Exhibit 24 Part 3-25
View on PACER
28 Appendix Exhibit 26-27 Part 1
View on PACER
29 Appendix Exhibit 26-27 Part 2
View on PACER
30 Appendix Exhibit 28-29
View on PACER
31 Appendix Exhibit 30
View on PACER
32 Appendix Exhibit 31
View on PACER
33 Appendix Exhibit 32-35
View on PACER
34 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 1
View on PACER
35 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 2
View on PACER
36 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 3
View on PACER
37 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.1
View on PACER
38 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.2
View on PACER
39 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 4.3
View on PACER
40 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.1
View on PACER
41 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.2
View on PACER
42 Exhibit 36 Part 5.3
View on PACER
43 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 5.4
View on PACER
44 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 6
View on PACER
45 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 7
View on PACER
46 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 8
View on PACER
47 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 9
View on PACER
48 Appendix Exhibit 36 Part 10
View on PACER
49 Appendix Exhibit 37 Part 1
View on PACER
50 Appendix Exhibit 37 Part 2
View on PACER
51 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 1
View on PACER
52 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 2
View on PACER
53 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 3
View on PACER
54 Appendix Exhibit 38 Part 4
View on PACER
55 Appendix Exhibit 39
View on PACER
56 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 1
View on PACER
57 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 2
View on PACER
58 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 3
View on PACER
59 Appendix Exhibit 40 Part 4
View on PACER
60 Appendix Exhibit 41 Part 1
View on PACER
61 Appendix Exhibit 41 Part 2
View on PACER
|
March 22, 2007
|
March 22, 2007
PACER
|
|
101
|
ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Gerard E. Lynch from Angela Corridan dated 4/4/07 re: Request an extension of seven days to file their reply so that plaintiff's reply is to be served and filed by April 16, 2007. ENDORSEMENT: So Ordered (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 4/4/07) (js) (Entered: 04/05/2007)
|
April 4, 2007
|
April 4, 2007
PACER
|
|
102
|
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 89 MOTION to Certify Class.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix G# 2 Exhibit 43# 3 Exhibit 44)(Sanford, David) (Entered: 04/16/2007)
2 Appendix G
View on PACER
3 Exhibit 43
View on PACER
4 Exhibit 44
View on PACER
|
April 16, 2007
|
April 16, 2007
PACER
|
|
103
|
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 89 MOTION to Certify Class.. Document filed by Michelle Williams, Kelly Corbett, Marta Deyne, Joan Durkin, Sue Earl, Jamie Holland, Maryanne Jacoby, Simona Lopes, Ashley Narmour, Catherine White, Amy Velez, Lori Horton, Karen Liggins, Wendy Pinson, Roberta VonLintel, Holly Waters, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix A)(Sanford, David) (Entered: 04/16/2007)
2 Appendix A
View on PACER
|
April 16, 2007
|
April 16, 2007
PACER
|
|
104
|
OPINION AND ORDER # 94991 :Defendant Novartis Corporation's motion for summary judgment (Doc.# 7) is granted. As to the remaining defendants, plaintiffs have demonstrated that their proposed class and its representatives satisfy the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a) and 23(b). Accordingly, plaintiffs' motion for class certification (Doc. # 89) is granted. Amy Velez, Penni Zelinkoff, Minel Hider Tobertga, Michelle Williams, Jennifer Waxman-Recht, Karen Liggins, Lori Horton, Holly Waters, Wendy Pinson, Roberta Vonlinte, Catherine White, Kelly Corbett, Jamie Holland, Joan Durkin, Simona Lopes, Maryanne Jacoby, and Marta Deyne are appointed as class representatives. The firm of Sanford, Wittels & Heisler, LLP, is appointed as lead counsel for the class. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Gerard E. Lynch on 7/31/2007) (jmi) Modified on 8/3/2007 (rw). (Entered: 08/01/2007)
|
July 31, 2007
|
July 31, 2007
RECAP
|